Negatives

[kosifantutti]

One guy out there way too casual

Who?

Rhys Stanley...even does the fake head wobble when he pretends to run with intensity

Wow. A fake head wobble. I missed that.

[Wayne42]

Thought Mumford and Giles were fairly prominent?

Defence were undersized and exposed by Giles...

Fumbling by Gilbert, Gwilt was concerning , even though they battled hard,

GWS should have won....

Savage, just panicked with each disposal, off the pace....

Roberton just struggling for form and position.... Gilbert and him? Do we need two 6'4" flankers!

Beau and Rhys still devoid of confidence ...... Just need to break the shackles and attack the game? Rhys did it once.

Some of the turnovers, out of the back half were horrible

More positive the negatives though....

I'm sorry, Giants should have won?!? Which game were you at. We won most if not all the important stats today. They had two dominant periods of about ten minutes each in the whole match, as did we. The difference was our experienced players were better than theirs out there this afternoon. They were very good, no doubt, but did not deserve to win. The better side on the day won. 'Nuff said.
Agree with your comments re: Maister and Stanley though. Cannot play both of them in the same side.

I don't rate Josh Hunt. I can't work out why he is still playing AFL footy.

[SainterK]

Hunched shoulders, leaning well forward, head wobbling back & forth...

He isn't the first, won't be the last

It's quintessential faux endeavour 101

[elvis lives]

My one major negative was the fitness or should I say lack of fitness for Savage. He came in as a sub late in the third and by half way through the 4th he was running up and down on the spot, calling to the bench asking to come off. gWS players were just running away from him with ease. He had a full preseason, perfect run in, but cannot run for half a qtr. very disappointing.

[Jacks Back]

My one major negative was the fitness or should I say lack of fitness for Savage. He came in as a sub late in the third and by half way through the 4th he was running up and down on the spot, calling to the bench asking to come off. gWS players were just running away from him with ease. He had a full preseason, perfect run in, but cannot run for half a qtr. very disappointing.

Negatives:
5 possessions from savage for 0% efficiency. Great get!
Virtually nothing from Roberton.
Maister can't get the basics right.
Fumbling from Gilbert, Dempster, Gwilt, Jones

Positives:
Great game from all the rest of our players including those fumble finger ones towards the end of the game.

[The Redeemer]

Jones still has terrible disposal and gets team mates into trouble more often than not

[The Fireman]

a lesser chance of a better draft pick.

[SainterK]

a lesser chance of a better draft pick.

Recruiters are doing ok with what they have...

[Wayne42]

My one major negative was the fitness or should I say lack of fitness for Savage. He came in as a sub late in the third and by half way through the 4th he was running up and down on the spot, calling to the bench asking to come off. gWS players were just running away from him with ease. He had a full preseason, perfect run in, but cannot run for half a qtr. very disappointing.

Maybe he's not up to it..

Might be why Hawkthorn didn't pick him in their 2013 GF team.

Might be why he was traded.

Sandy need players, leave him there until he fires.

[The Fireman]

a lesser chance of a better draft pick.

Recruiters are doing ok with what they have...

we need more.. much more

[SainterK]

a lesser chance of a better draft pick.

Recruiters are doing ok with what they have...

we need more.. much more

Not at the expense at steering enthused kids towards less wins...didn't help melbourne much

Back em in to land some bargains...

Here's to starting naughty boy rumours about the guys we like the look of

[kosifantutti]

Hunched shoulders, leaning well forward, head wobbling back & forth...

He isn't the first, won't be the last

It's quintessential faux endeavour 101

Well I missed that. I was more concerned with the two kick able shots he missed.

[PADDLEPOP1001]

I can"t believe that comment by BM that the Giants should have won the St Kilda Football Clubs slogan at the moment is all about toughness and effort and we showed that in spades ,watched that game yesterday and the effort the boys put in compared to GWS was way better,to top it off we had the two most dominant players on the ground ,disappointed that you feel that way BM .It was a game that we deserved to win and did win ,well done boys!

[whiskers3614]

My one major negative was the fitness or should I say lack of fitness for Savage. He came in as a sub late in the third and by half way through the 4th he was running up and down on the spot, calling to the bench asking to come off. gWS players were just running away from him with ease. He had a full preseason, perfect run in, but cannot run for half a qtr. very disappointing.

Maybe he's not up to it..

Might be why Hawkthorn didn't pick him in their 2013 GF team.

Might be why he was traded.

Sandy need players, leave him there until he fires.

Too early to tell with Savage but TDL experience might be telling us to stop going for blokes on the outer fringes of premiership teams!