Sliding Doors
Moderators: Saintsational Administrators, Saintsational Moderators
Sliding Doors
Sliding Doors, free agency and the big unknown.
I am concerned.
We are being dismissed as almost the side that was. Yet decisions that were made and are being made can be seen to have two distinct paths. Depending, of course, which side you look at.
Ross Lyon. The fans were divided, the gate receipts were divided (we should have pushed 50k membership for the years of success) The AFL were disappointed in the end result for the move of Lyon to Freo but why? IMO it has become evident that it was the handling of Mark Harvey rather than Ross leaving us. Dog eat dog. Nettlefold left the gate open and the wolves descended.
Our list. Free agency has changed the game forever. Lock your players in and play for the here and now because tomorrow your gun player may be gone. Sentiment has no follower other than mediocrity from this point onwards. If Dal and Joey would like a chance at getting a premiership then the club should make it happen and bear the fruits of the trade.
Grant Thomas. Maybe he was close to being right. Maybe the coach needs to be more an English style manager who has control of the group as an entity without the interference of the board unless things get dire.
Scott Watters. Unknown entity. Maybe, and here is the optimist part, maybe he is so driven that he and Pelchen have a vision for the team going forward and given the new playing fields, that are free agency and the corresponding degradation of club loyalties, that can see an evolving team emerge.
To me, free agency will be about jigsaw puzzles. No more evident than Hawthorn this year and Sydney over the years. See a missing piece get a missing piece. See a piece that does not quite fit, trade that piece for one that does.
The clubs that can get hold of this quickly will benefit. Lock your good players away even at a risks that were not seen five years ago. A Jack Stevens should be on a five year contract now, front loaded but with options that give the club the upper hand to extend contracts not the players.
Just Thoughts!
I am concerned.
We are being dismissed as almost the side that was. Yet decisions that were made and are being made can be seen to have two distinct paths. Depending, of course, which side you look at.
Ross Lyon. The fans were divided, the gate receipts were divided (we should have pushed 50k membership for the years of success) The AFL were disappointed in the end result for the move of Lyon to Freo but why? IMO it has become evident that it was the handling of Mark Harvey rather than Ross leaving us. Dog eat dog. Nettlefold left the gate open and the wolves descended.
Our list. Free agency has changed the game forever. Lock your players in and play for the here and now because tomorrow your gun player may be gone. Sentiment has no follower other than mediocrity from this point onwards. If Dal and Joey would like a chance at getting a premiership then the club should make it happen and bear the fruits of the trade.
Grant Thomas. Maybe he was close to being right. Maybe the coach needs to be more an English style manager who has control of the group as an entity without the interference of the board unless things get dire.
Scott Watters. Unknown entity. Maybe, and here is the optimist part, maybe he is so driven that he and Pelchen have a vision for the team going forward and given the new playing fields, that are free agency and the corresponding degradation of club loyalties, that can see an evolving team emerge.
To me, free agency will be about jigsaw puzzles. No more evident than Hawthorn this year and Sydney over the years. See a missing piece get a missing piece. See a piece that does not quite fit, trade that piece for one that does.
The clubs that can get hold of this quickly will benefit. Lock your good players away even at a risks that were not seen five years ago. A Jack Stevens should be on a five year contract now, front loaded but with options that give the club the upper hand to extend contracts not the players.
Just Thoughts!
-
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 6656
- Joined: Tue 09 Mar 2004 12:24pm
- Location: Hotel Bastardos
- Has thanked: 198 times
- Been thanked: 166 times
- Contact:
Re: Sliding Doors
Free agency means smart clubs will move on their best players while they have currency. More turnover.
*Allegedly.
Bring back Lucky Burgers, and nobody gets hurt.
You can't un-fry things.
Last Post
Bring back Lucky Burgers, and nobody gets hurt.
You can't un-fry things.
Last Post
-
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 23243
- Joined: Sat 13 Mar 2004 11:44pm
- Has thanked: 741 times
- Been thanked: 1798 times
Re: Sliding Doors
I do think free agency will come at some cost to the game I'm just not sure that's evident yet
It's sad in a way when a player (like Dal who clearly wants to stay) has to convince the club not to treat him like cattle... I know its dog eat dog blah blah blah but you do fear the days of legends and 1 club heroes is drawing to a close, again , but at what cost?
I think winning a flag with a Rob Harvey type in the side (who has sacrificed for the club and rejected large offers) would mean so much more than winning one with a drop in mercenary whose gone a year later.... perhaps for many that wont matter?
It's sad in a way when a player (like Dal who clearly wants to stay) has to convince the club not to treat him like cattle... I know its dog eat dog blah blah blah but you do fear the days of legends and 1 club heroes is drawing to a close, again , but at what cost?
I think winning a flag with a Rob Harvey type in the side (who has sacrificed for the club and rejected large offers) would mean so much more than winning one with a drop in mercenary whose gone a year later.... perhaps for many that wont matter?
“Yeah….nah””
- Devilhead
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 8393
- Joined: Mon 08 Mar 2004 11:56pm
- Has thanked: 138 times
- Been thanked: 1174 times
Re: Sliding Doors
When the glue starts to breakdown thats when you replace it with new adhesive - the downside is you will just have to wait a little for it to set.degruch wrote:I just hope we're not the club that discovers if you trade all your 'currency' away, you have nothing to hold the team together.
The Devil makes work for idle hands!!!
- dragit
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 13047
- Joined: Tue 29 Jun 2010 11:56am
- Has thanked: 605 times
- Been thanked: 315 times
Re: Sliding Doors
Agree, I found Brian Lake standing on the stage with his norm smith a tad distasteful…Teflon wrote:I do think free agency will come at some cost to the game I'm just not sure that's evident yet
It's sad in a way when a player (like Dal who clearly wants to stay) has to convince the club not to treat him like cattle... I know its dog eat dog blah blah blah but you do fear the days of legends and 1 club heroes is drawing to a close, again , but at what cost?
I think winning a flag with a Rob Harvey type in the side (who has sacrificed for the club and rejected large offers) would mean so much more than winning one with a drop in mercenary whose gone a year later.... perhaps for many that wont matter?
This is a guy who was paid very well by the dogs and when they started to drop out of premiership contention, he just CBF'ed… even on 500K PA. Pretty shallow to jump ship for the best team in the comp to get a flag… no glory there IMO.
I have more empathy for players leaving for money than chasing glory.
- degruch
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 8948
- Joined: Mon 19 May 2008 4:29pm
- Location: Croydonia
- Has thanked: 146 times
- Been thanked: 237 times
Re: Sliding Doors
Yes, but I think it's a 50/50 proposition. Move free agency back a few years, when would we have dumped Harvs, when he was 28 and still had a season or 2 left in him? Hayes too? I worry that trading away experience and great clubmen could be fast tracking our path to becoming Melbourne.Devilhead wrote:When the glue starts to breakdown thats when you replace it with new adhesive - the downside is you will just have to wait a little for it to set.degruch wrote:I just hope we're not the club that discovers if you trade all your 'currency' away, you have nothing to hold the team together.
-
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 12038
- Joined: Sun 11 Sep 2011 2:26pm
- Has thanked: 3682 times
- Been thanked: 2567 times
Re: Sliding Doors
LikeDevilhead wrote: When the glue starts to breakdown thats when you replace it with new adhesive - the downside is you will just have to wait a little for it to set.
- Con Gorozidis
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 23532
- Joined: Thu 19 Jun 2008 4:04pm
- Has thanked: 100 times
- Been thanked: 78 times
Re: Sliding Doors
There is no doubt the game has reached a new level of professionalism and we have no choice but to step up to the plate.
GT stepped us up a notch in and off field and them once we has sustained on field success I think we slackened off off field and took the foot off the accelerator .
Then when the music stopped onfield in 2010.
We deteriorated rapidly because our off field structures were horrible . We'd dropped the ball but no one noticed because we were winning games and it kind of was shrugged off.
There has been a lot of people whinging about coaching hoping if we can somehow magically heal our onfield success we can continue to ignore the off field.
But right now I think our biggest issue is for our off field to step to the new level of professionalism .
All starts with the CEO appointment .
Nothing is more important .
If we get that right and also this years draft and trade period right we can be back in 3 years.
If not the club is in existential and mortal danger.
GT stepped us up a notch in and off field and them once we has sustained on field success I think we slackened off off field and took the foot off the accelerator .
Then when the music stopped onfield in 2010.
We deteriorated rapidly because our off field structures were horrible . We'd dropped the ball but no one noticed because we were winning games and it kind of was shrugged off.
There has been a lot of people whinging about coaching hoping if we can somehow magically heal our onfield success we can continue to ignore the off field.
But right now I think our biggest issue is for our off field to step to the new level of professionalism .
All starts with the CEO appointment .
Nothing is more important .
If we get that right and also this years draft and trade period right we can be back in 3 years.
If not the club is in existential and mortal danger.
Re: Sliding Doors
Interesting.degruch wrote:I just hope we're not the club that discovers if you trade all your 'currency' away, you have nothing to hold the team together.
If I was a NDS or a Joey I would see it as an opportunity to get the Saints something and them something at the end of their careers. I love the adage that you need players like NDS and Joey to learn from but I also see them as natural footballers and athletes. To me you learn more about footy in watching a lenny or a Joel Selwood than you will from NDS and Joey. Don't get me wrong I have loved watching both play over the years but the reality is that our side is now a young side, our leaders need to be 25-27 not 30-32.
You keep a number 12 because his game and work ethic is something that you want to pass on to others like Lee. Build for the future, respect the past but always look forward. Was seeing joey get 47 touches or so just as exciting as Stevens get 47?
- bobmurray
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 7910
- Joined: Mon 03 Oct 2005 11:08pm
- Location: In the stand at RSEA Park.
- Has thanked: 538 times
- Been thanked: 244 times
Re: Sliding Doors
I wonder if Stan Alves would agree with thatdragit wrote:Agree, I found Brian Lake standing on the stage with his norm smith a tad distasteful…Teflon wrote:I do think free agency will come at some cost to the game I'm just not sure that's evident yet
It's sad in a way when a player (like Dal who clearly wants to stay) has to convince the club not to treat him like cattle... I know its dog eat dog blah blah blah but you do fear the days of legends and 1 club heroes is drawing to a close, again , but at what cost?
I think winning a flag with a Rob Harvey type in the side (who has sacrificed for the club and rejected large offers) would mean so much more than winning one with a drop in mercenary whose gone a year later.... perhaps for many that wont matter?
This is a guy who was paid very well by the dogs and when they started to drop out of premiership contention, he just CBF'ed… even on 500K PA. Pretty shallow to jump ship for the best team in the comp to get a flag… no glory there IMO.
I have more empathy for players leaving for money than chasing glory.
Will we pick up a player in the SSP window