No Saints in AA side

[kosifantutti]

Roo unlucky IMO



More to come

2013 FOUR'N TWENTY ALL AUSTRALIAN TEAM

B: Corey Enright (Geel), Scott Thompson (NM), Michael Johnson (Freo)

HB: Jarrad McVeigh (Syd), Harry Taylor (Geel), Sam Mitchell (Haw)

C: Ryan Griffen (WB), Joel Selwood (Geel), Scott Pendlebury (Coll)

HF: Patrick Dangerfield (Adel), Travis Cloke (Coll), Kieren Jack (Syd)

F: Jarryd Roughead (Haw), Jeremy Cameron (GWS), Chad Wingard (PA)

Ruck: Will Minson (WB), Dane Swan (Coll), Gary Ablett (GC)

Int: Travis Boak (PA), Daniel Hannebery (Syd), Andrew Mackie (Geel), Jobe Watson (Ess)

[R. Harvey 3 votes!]

Fair enough, we finished 16th with 5 wins. Didn't expect any different really

[chook23]

Andrew Mackie?? Lucky to be in 40 (2013 form)

let alone make the team

[SainterK]

Mackie weird as...

[footynut]

Travis Cloke.... What a joke!

[Watts the Buzz]

Roo very unlucky with most marks in the league and a 50 goal season at centre half forward. Jack Steven could have easily been slotted in as well. I'm very cynical when it comes to these sorts of awards because essentially it's just based on people's opinions.....wish there was a more objective way of determining who makes the team.

May sound stupid but Supercoach / Dream Team scoring would be a lot more reliable to be honest.

[maverick]

How did Jobe make it, how do Jack's numbers compare?

[SaintPav]

How did Jobe make it, how do Jack's numbers compare?

Any emergencies in case there's a late out for some reason or do you just get an asterix around your name?

[mr six o'clock]

Roo missing out is no great crime but i'd have him in before watson !

[6621104]

did Cloke play at CHF? Who was the C'wood FF then?

[lloyd21]

Team should have been

Thompson / Carlisle /Hanley
Malceski /Johnson / Goddard
Dangerfield / Pendlebury / Hannebery
Wingard/N Riewoldt /S Johnson
Roughead / Cloke / Ballantyne

Minson/ Selwood/Ablett

Ic : Swan / Mitchell / Griffen /Boak

[st_Trav_ofWA]

honestly i dont have an issue with no saints in the team , we prob didnt have any standouts who deserved it (Roo and Steven maybe but neither were walk up starts imo) the thing that gets me is only two Hawks and one Docker making the list ... to me the AA teams are to geelong loving and even sydney loving for my likeing ....

[Con Gorozidis]

Realistically - we have only 1 - maybe 2 players in the AFL top 50.

[lloyd21]

Probably 3 this year

Reiwoldt Steven Montagna

[Moods]

I can live with Roo not being selected. He had a great start to the year, but a real down patch from about the bye to Rd 18-19. Cloke had easily the most contested marks in the league, which has to rate as highly as anything I reckon.

As for Lloydy21 putting Goddard in his AA team He played about 3 genuinely really good games. One of them was against the GWS. He was serviceable all year without being fantastic.

[The Redeemer]

I can live with Roo not being selected. He had a great start to the year, but a real down patch from about the bye to Rd 18-19. Cloke had easily the most contested marks in the league, which has to rate as highly as anything I reckon.

As for Lloydy21 putting Goddard in his AA team He played about 3 genuinely really good games. One of them was against the GWS. He was serviceable all year without being fantastic.

That is harsh on BJ. He did exactly what he is paid the big bucks for. Heaps of touches and direction around the ground.

Roo was stiff as Cloke played Full Forward. Actually come to think of it, has Kieran Jack ever played half-forward?

[BigMart]

Check out the raw numbers of Joey, Roo and Jack

They compare easily.... Riewoldt unlucky.... So was Kennedy if he wasn't in?

Was Kennedy from Sydney an in, Pyke, Fyfe, Hodge, Wells, Sloane, Goddard, a few tigers and others.... Some guns missed

Mackie, Enright?
We're they that good??

[BigMart]

Contested marks + Uncontested markers are required at CHF

Hitting up and presenting says something about work rate

[8856brother]

Check out the raw numbers of Joey, Roo and Jack

They compare easily.... Riewoldt unlucky.... So was Kennedy if he wasn't in?

Was Kennedy from Sydney an in, Pyke, Fyfe, Hodge, Wells, Sloane, Goddard, a few tigers and others.... Some guns missed

Mackie, Enright?
We're they that good??

No. They just play for a sexy side. Give me Hodge before either of them 100 times out of 100. Surprised Corey and Hawkins didn't get in.

[BigMart]

What about Chappie and Stevie J??

I heard Scarlo had a good year with south Barwon??