AFL Bad Boys

[mullet]

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/w ... 6656206504

Oh dear poor CJ has made the list.

North and Collingwood feature well, and yet their "culture" is not in question

Make of it of you want. Particularly love the saints emblem next to Lovett.

[plugger66]

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/w ... 6656206504

Oh dear poor CJ has made the list.

North and Collingwood feature well, and yet their "culture" is not in question

Make of it of you want. Particularly love the saints emblem next to Lovett.

Im not sure they couldnt put it there. Yes he didnt play a game for us but he was on our list and even out with our players on the night it all happened.

[bergholt]

Im not sure they couldnt put it there. Yes he didnt play a game for us but he was on our list and even out with our players on the night it all happened.

Well, the graphic isn't exactly accurate on that front. Jones has a Hawks flag next to his name - for no apparent reason - but Bock is missing a Crows flag, Scotland a Collingwood flag, Andy Krakouer a Richmond flag, Carey a Crows flag, Caddy a Suns flag, Ablett Sr a Hawks flag, Renouf a Hawks flag. And Cresswell could have Swans, Cats and Lions flags. No particular bias but it's a pretty shoddy piece of work.

[fingers]

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/w ... 6656206504

Oh dear poor CJ has made the list.

North and Collingwood feature well, and yet their "culture" is not in question

Make of it of you want. Particularly love the saints emblem next to Lovett.

THere has been nothing but the talk of COllingwood's culture over the last 3 days

[Kickit]

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/w ... 6656206504

Oh dear poor CJ has made the list.

North and Collingwood feature well, and yet their "culture" is not in question

Make of it of you want. Particularly love the saints emblem next to Lovett.

Im not sure they couldnt put it there. Yes he didnt play a game for us but he was on our list and even out with our players on the night it all happened.

Only one of the two incidents they described. So it would have been perfectly valid to put the Essendon symbol next to him. It also would have been correct to describe him as a 88 game Essendon player.

Including Jones with that lot is typical goldfish mentality. "Oohh who is bad let me think, I struggle with memory of more than a week so I'll go with Jones".

Once again we avoid mention of Collingwood players coercing a young woman into group sex , prompting her to complain to police about her treatment. Ooooh but CJ lit a dwarf.

[Johnny Member]

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/w ... 6656206504

Oh dear poor CJ has made the list.

North and Collingwood feature well, and yet their "culture" is not in question

Make of it of you want. Particularly love the saints emblem next to Lovett.

Im not sure they couldnt put it there. Yes he didnt play a game for us but he was on our list and even out with our players on the night it all happened.

He didn't represent the club at all.

Didn't even finish a pre-season, let alone don the guernsey.

[Johnny Member]

This clearly puts into perspective two things:

1) How much of an overreaction there was to the dwarf burning incident.

2) How much of a beat up the 'St Kilda has a terrible culture' thing is.

[Johnny Member]

Steve Lawrence pranged his car when pissed - got the sack.
Capuano doing silly things when pissed - got the sack.
Andrew Lovett being Andrew Lovett - got the sack.


Dare I say, we have the hardest line approach to this stuff than any other club in the AFL.

[gringo]

The Smedts and Caddy thing could have had the pair shot and could have endangered lives but was made less of a story because it didn't have the Jerry Springer style bizarreness.

[Johnny Member]

The Smedts and Caddy thing could have had the pair shot and could have endangered lives but was made less of a story because it didn't have the Jerry Springer style bizarreness.

Because they were winning.

If you're losing, and do the exact same thing - you get caned and it's suddenly a big problem.

[Dr Spaceman]

The Smedts and Caddy thing could have had the pair shot and could have endangered lives but was made less of a story because it didn't have the Jerry Springer style bizarreness.

Because they were winning.

If you're losing, and do the exact same thing - you get caned and it's suddenly a big problem.

But winning wouldn't have mattered had the incorrect house they were attempting to break into been the home of a Dwarf.

[Kickit]

No doubt they thought about including David Armitage and Sam Gilbert, but when they tried to quantify what was "bad" about them they found..........

[mr six o'clock]

CJ is the justin bieber of AFL bad boys!

[mullet]

This clearly puts into perspective two things:

1) How much of an overreaction there was to the dwarf burning incident.

2) How much of a beat up the 'St Kilda has a terrible culture' thing is.

right with ya Johnny

[savatage]

LMAO at CJ being considered a "bad boy".

[SinCitySainter]

The problem with saying St Kilda player Andrew Lovett in this context is that the incident where he was charged with rape was while he was a St Kilda listed player.
However, he was completely exonerated of that in a court of law therefore to use it as evidence that he was a bad egg is deliberately dishonest and borderline slanderous.

[bergholt]

The problem with saying St Kilda player Andrew Lovett in this context is that the incident where he was charged with rape was while he was a St Kilda listed player.
However, he was completely exonerated of that in a court of law therefore to use it as evidence that he was a bad egg is deliberately dishonest and borderline slanderous.

We sacked him before he'd played a game for us, so presumably we thought he was a bad boy.

[saintspremiers]

How the heck didn't Rooey make the team for flopping the chop, and Dal for that matter also?

[Johnny Member]

Because being naked in the privacy of your hotel room, isn't bad.

[st_Trav_ofWA]

Steve Lawrence pranged his car when pissed - got the sack.
Capuano doing silly things when pissed - got the sack.
Andrew Lovett being Andrew Lovett - got the sack.


Dare I say, we have the hardest line approach to this stuff than any other club in the AFL.

you could add Gram to that list as well ....


being in WA its a bit of a Dockers bubble at the moment but was there any where near as much fuss over brissys Daniel Rich'srun in with the bloke in the wheelchair as there was over CJ lighting up a little person ??

[Apples]

Liam Jurrah must be wondering what he's done not to get a mention..............