Joey

[wotever1]

oh joey two undisciplined acts in two minutes.

I have more faith in our youngsters than joey.

[The Fireman]

sack him along with Milne

[Old Mate]

He had a blinder of a game but undid his work with that selfish act.

[8856brother]

oh joey two undisciplined acts in two minutes.

I have more faith in our youngsters than joey.

You have no idea. He was our best player.

[BigMart]

I don't know what the Undisciplined acts were but his decision to bang it into F50 to a pack of 20 players with WC outnumbering 2:1 was poor, but worse was his decision to leave his man and enter a kick out ariel contest, even then not kill the ball and allow it to get over the back, resulting in game losing goal...

On Milney.... 11 games in and he plays a good one... Rate his season by using a memory longer than 2hrs ..... At his level, it would be hoped that would be his third big game this season with 4/5 serviceable games.... Few quiet ones

Not the ratio he's had.

[BigMart]

Having said that

Milney and Joey had very good games and get my votes.... Joey could have won us the game and ultimately cost us the game in the last two minutes

[southernsaint]

Yes two bad decisions, but a very good game overall

[QuestionOfAccuracy]

Bad decision late in the game, but still our best player by a country mile.

[1433davids]

sack him along with Milne

milne is statisically the best small forward in the afl the last 20 years problem now is the coaching staff at stkilda elect to play him out of the forward line for a big percentage of each match to try and develop someone else in a small forward position if you want your best small forward to kick 2 to three goals a game and ont the odd occasion 4 or more than play them in the forward line the whole game also milne is brilliant at spoting up a player in the forward 50 get rid of him you say." YOU ARE A FOOL". Just my opinion no offence.

[1433davids]

oh joey two undisciplined acts in two minutes.

I have more faith in our youngsters than joey.

You have no idea. He was our best player.

He is statisticall in the top 20 midfeilders in the afl this year "are you a fool the best youngster we have is robert harveys son if he has one .

[1433davids]

I don't know what the Undisciplined acts were but his decision to bang it into F50 to a pack of 20 players with WC outnumbering 2:1 was poor, but worse was his decision to leave his man and enter a kick out ariel contest, even then not kill the ball and allow it to get over the back, resulting in game losing goal...

On Milney.... 11 games in and he plays a good one... Rate his season by using a memory longer than 2hrs ..... At his level, it would be hoped that would be his third big game this season with 4/5 serviceable games.... Few quiet ones

Not the ratio he's had.

would love to now how many small forwards have kick more goals than him this year considering he plays a lot of the game out of the forward 50 now.

[8856brother]

I don't know what the Undisciplined acts were but his decision to bang it into F50 to a pack of 20 players with WC outnumbering 2:1 was poor, but worse was his decision to leave his man and enter a kick out ariel contest, even then not kill the ball and allow it to get over the back, resulting in game losing goal...

On Milney.... 11 games in and he plays a good one... Rate his season by using a memory longer than 2hrs ..... At his level, it would be hoped that would be his third big game this season with 4/5 serviceable games.... Few quiet ones

Not the ratio he's had.

would love to now how many small forwards have kick more goals than him this year considering he plays a lot of the game out of the forward 50 now.

All his AA rivals have. 5 genuine small forwards are in front of him even after his 5 last night.

[BigMart]

Off the top of my head

Jeff Gartlett

[8856brother]

Off the top of my head

Jeff Gartlett

Thomas
Punky Brewster
Benny McGlynn
Walters