Confirmed Team for Sunday's clash against West Coast

[coopergrech]

Sunday Teams:

St.Kilda:
In: Beau Maister, Clint Jones, Trent Dennis-Lane, Sam Dunell
Out: Arryn Siposs (Omitted), Ahmed Saad (Omitted), Sam Fisher (Foot), Jackson Ferguson (Omitted)

West Coast Eagles:
In: Ashton Hams, Jacob Brennan, Blayne Wilson
Out: Darren Glass, Mark LeCras, Mark Hutchings


Thoughts????

[Buckets]

HUGE!!!!!!!!! Glass and lecras are big outs!

[mightysainters]

Clinton Jones... i just don't know how he can possibly get game...

I'm of the opinion Maister will be a GOP... still getting over the hand injury but will offer up a bit this weekend, i have no doubt in my mind...

TDL in is a worry but im glad Saad got dropped..

[spot on]

I thought dunnel would be a regular this year, glad he gets his chance, got some poise about him. Not to keen for jones.

[Sobraz]

Happy to see Dunnell get a run... Rate him higher than a few other that have been given a good go, namely TDL, Saad and to a lesser extent, Terry... Although I think Terry's in one week out the next is a bit stiff also...

The other in's, not much to comment on... I guess Maister is getting a warm up match before his twice annual BOG against Melbourne the following week..

Would've preferred to see Ledger get a go as an inside mid as opposed to going back to Jones... ho-hum.

[howlinwolf]

Sipposs out surprises me. He could be used as another forward option to help out Roo.
I would have thought we were too thin on the ground to be able to drop him ?

[bergsone]

My guess is Jones to get a job on Kerr,Priddis ? Whether he can do it is another matter

Happy with Dunnell back in as I rate him

Maister to play forward,as he was very ordinary when tried in backline,so Stanley to stay back,would have liked to see Stanley go against Nic Nat in the ruck

TDL,doesnt fill me with confidence,hope I am wrong

[mad saint guy]

Pathetic. Another thrashing with the same underperformering old hacks is coming our way. If we're going to be playing old guys who aren't up to it, then it should be Blake to allow Stanley to play forward or Kosi to at least stretch the opposition for height.

[3rd generation saint]

I can see the logic with Maister, it was either him or Kosi as we need a second big forward. Lee has had one good game in the VFL, will need a couple more.
Mind you, though I see the logic, doesn't mean I'm happy about it, with Glass and Brown out, here is Maisters chance to do something.
After Saad didn't show up last week, and TDL kicking goals in the VFL, he has to be given another go, let's hope he shows more.
Sipposs has been poor, and has lost confidence, needs to be managed and get his head back together, has the ability, but looks a little lost at the moment.
Hopefully Dunnel will show some of the promise he showed last year.
Can anyone tell us about Simpkin, he seems to have disappeared, where is he out, fitness wise.

[Dis Believer]

I can see the logic with Maister, it was either him or Kosi as we need a second big forward. Lee has had one good game in the VFL, will need a couple more.
Mind you, though I see the logic, doesn't mean I'm happy about it, with Glass and Brown out, here is Maisters chance to do something.
After Saad didn't show up last week, and TDL kicking goals in the VFL, he has to be given another go, let's hope he shows more.
Sipposs has been poor, and has lost confidence, needs to be managed and get his head back together, has the ability, but looks a little lost at the moment.
Hopefully Dunnel will show some of the promise he showed last year.
Can anyone tell us about Simpkin, he seems to have disappeared, where is he out, fitness wise.

Based on what I saw last week from Simpkin I would say he is about right to go fitness wise after this week.

[saintspremiers]

You're funny Scotty.

TDL, Jones, Maister.

Is it the comedy channel on Sunday twilight at Etihad.

Must check what channel that is.

[saintspremiers]

Pathetic. Another thrashing with the same underperformering old hacks is coming our way. If we're going to be playing old guys who aren't up to it, then it should be Blake to allow Stanley to play forward or Kosi to at least stretch the opposition for height.

Be easy on SW. Selection night is not his strong point. But neither is match day.

At least he is developing the kids. Or keeping the seat warm.

[bigcarl]

St.Kilda:
In: Beau Maister, Clint Jones, Trent Dennis-Lane, Sam Dunell
Out: Arryn Siposs (Omitted), Ahmed Saad (Omitted), Sam Fisher (Foot), Jackson Ferguson (Omitted)

Hard to argue with the outs on last week's form. Don't know about the ins, though. I'd like to have seen Lee given a crack instead of Maister.

[chook23]

outs fair enough.......saad and sippos struggling.

our depth is poor and some of the young ones not yet ready............

[SainterK]

For mine, Milne hasn't been travelling that much better has he?

Didn't his opponent get 30+ on the weekend?

I do agree with only playing one of Saad and Milne and hope that when Saad gets back in we won't persevere with two specialist forward pocket players.

[dragit]

Sunday Teams:

St.Kilda:
In: Beau Maister, Clint Jones, Trent Dennis-Lane,


Thoughts????

I honestly thought the season couldn't get any worse until these three were selected.

If we don't play well, Watters will be under some serious scrutiny after picking another very odd team.

[mr six o'clock]

To be fair , Tdl has been kicking goals at sandy !
I just hope he can be more than a witches hat on sunday .

[Rosco]

I can see the logic with Maister, it was either him or Kosi as we need a second big forward. Lee has had one good game in the VFL, will need a couple more.
Mind you, though I see the logic, doesn't mean I'm happy about it, with Glass and Brown out, here is Maisters chance to do something.

Brown is named...?

[70s sainter]

Exactly the outs that I hoped for except that I thought they could have sipposs as sub- he is still unfit- he'd want to pull his finger out soon.
Saad - needs to go back to seconds
Ferguson - not up to it yet
Fisher - was useless last week.

However wanted lee and simpkin to come in. Happy with jones at the moment purely cause he gets clearances .dunno much about dunnell.

[Heidelberg_Saint]

Sipposs out surprises me. He could be used as another forward option to help out Roo.
I would have thought we were too thin on the ground to be able to drop him ?

To me, Siposs is a lazy footballer. He possesses some beautiful natural talent but lacks the required intensity and work rate that would see him become a first grade regular.

[chook23]

Sipposs out surprises me. He could be used as another forward option to help out Roo.
I would have thought we were too thin on the ground to be able to drop him ?

To me, Siposs is a lazy footballer. He possesses some beautiful natural talent but lacks the required intensity and work rate that would see him become a first grade regular.

spot on

[bergholt]

Sipposs out surprises me. He could be used as another forward option to help out Roo.
I would have thought we were too thin on the ground to be able to drop him ?

To me, Siposs is a lazy footballer. He possesses some beautiful natural talent but lacks the required intensity and work rate that would see him become a first grade regular.

Quite possibly - a lot of them do at the start. Let's hope the penny drops and he becomes good before we have to give up.

[plugger66]

Why was Hutchings dropped?

[dragit]

Why was Hutchings dropped?

Seems odd, 19 touches & 5 tackles in a losing side… 3rd game of AFL footy.

I didn't see it though…

[PJ]

It'll be good to get a close look at Brown. I think he'll still be on our radar at season's end.