Dempsey v Saad

Viking3 · Post: # 1323112Post **Viking3** » Mon 22 Apr 2013 2:50pm

Not sure if this was asked on any previous post, but has any heard anything about what was said?
Saad seems a very placid kind of guy but didn't appreciated whatever it was that Dempsey said.
I've heard it was racial and if so I'd be disappointed if the Club didn't take it further. If the shoe, or boot, was on the other foot I'm sure we'd hear about an Indigenous player being aggrieved.

stinger · Post: # 1323116Post **stinger** » Mon 22 Apr 2013 2:53pm

Viking3 wrote:Not sure if this was asked on any previous post, but has any heard anything about what was said?
Saad seems a very placid kind of guy but didn't appreciated whatever it was that Dempsey said.
I've heard it was racial and if so I'd be disappointed if the Club didn't take it further. If the shoe, or boot, was on the other foot I'm sure we'd hear about an Indigenous player being aggrieved.

well...he said something...maybe it was about his goal kicking style.....

Viking3 · Post: # 1323123Post **Viking3** » Mon 22 Apr 2013 3:01pm

stinger wrote:
Viking3 wrote:Not sure if this was asked on any previous post, but has any heard anything about what was said?
Saad seems a very placid kind of guy but didn't appreciated whatever it was that Dempsey said.
I've heard it was racial and if so I'd be disappointed if the Club didn't take it further. If the shoe, or boot, was on the other foot I'm sure we'd hear about an Indigenous player being aggrieved.
well...he said something...maybe it was about his goal kicking style.....

Wouldn't think so. If Saad didn't already know how funny it looks I'd be surprised. I'm sure Milney et al would be taking the pyss of of him regularly!!

SainterK · Post: # 1323127Post **SainterK** » Mon 22 Apr 2013 3:04pm

There were hints on bigfooty that he may of said something pretty ordinary, but you'd think an investigation would of been launched if true.

Dempsey should shut his mouth, Milne in some trouble for trying to shut it for him.

stinger · Post: # 1323131Post **stinger** » Mon 22 Apr 2013 3:06pm

Viking3 wrote:
stinger wrote:
Viking3 wrote:Not sure if this was asked on any previous post, but has any heard anything about what was said?
Saad seems a very placid kind of guy but didn't appreciated whatever it was that Dempsey said.
I've heard it was racial and if so I'd be disappointed if the Club didn't take it further. If the shoe, or boot, was on the other foot I'm sure we'd hear about an Indigenous player being aggrieved.
well...he said something...maybe it was about his goal kicking style.....
Wouldn't think so. If Saad didn't already know how funny it looks I'd be surprised. I'm sure Milney et al would be taking the pyss of of him regularly!!

that was a light hearted post...actually i would be really disappointed if it was a racial remark...as would all of us be.......

dragit · Post: # 1323132Post **dragit** » Mon 22 Apr 2013 3:07pm

Any suspensions out of the game?

There were some pretty poorly disguised jumper punches going on, wouldn't surprise me if a few get a week or 2.

SainterK · Post: # 1323140Post **SainterK** » Mon 22 Apr 2013 3:17pm

dragit wrote:Any suspensions out of the game?

There were some pretty poorly disguised jumper punches going on, wouldn't surprise me if a few get a week or 2.

Milne copped a jumper punch to the chin, I also saw what looked like someone kicking him where it hurts.

He also was doing strange pressure points to Dempsey though, not his best move.

Sobraz · Post: # 1323142Post **Sobraz** » Mon 22 Apr 2013 3:19pm

I thought Dempsey's antics throughout the game were disgraceful...

Seems like a real flog of a bloke...

Refuses to put his head over the ball to top it off..

dragit · Post: # 1323144Post **dragit** » Mon 22 Apr 2013 3:21pm

SainterK wrote:He also was doing strange pressure points to Dempsey though, not his best move.

I was on the other side of the ground, it looked bad enough from there, but golly.

we could see a few trhings cited, it was a pretty massive melee

i did notice BJ trying to get bombers players away from ours… def still has a saints heart

Old Mate · Post: # 1323147Post **Old Mate** » Mon 22 Apr 2013 3:24pm

We missed Bakes. He would've taken Dempster out of the game and likely a few more as well.

plugger66 · Post: # 1323149Post **plugger66** » Mon 22 Apr 2013 3:33pm

Old Mate wrote:We missed Bakes. He would've taken Dempster out of the game and likely a few more as well.

Cant see how that helps us.

SunburySaint · Mon 22 Apr 2013 3:35pm

Old Mate wrote:We missed Bakes. He would've taken Dempster out of the game and likely a few more as well.

Dempster was already out of the game...

stinger · Post: # 1323157Post **stinger** » Mon 22 Apr 2013 3:41pm

SunburySaint wrote:
Old Mate wrote:We missed Bakes. He would've taken Dempster out of the game and likely a few more as well.
Dempster was already out of the game...

you going to tell him...or should i.....

dempsey

SaintPav · Post: # 1323161Post **SaintPav** » Mon 22 Apr 2013 3:45pm

Old Mate wrote:We missed Bakes. He would've taken Dempster out of the game and likely a few more as well.

yeah might as well. we're going that badly. I like it a lot.

Old Mate · Post: # 1323183Post **Old Mate** » Mon 22 Apr 2013 4:09pm

I'm having a shocker

St Chris · Post: # 1323185Post **St Chris** » Mon 22 Apr 2013 4:11pm

Nath Wright had a fair crack for a young bloke. He might go into his third AFL game at a net loss for his AFL earnings!!!

stinger · Post: # 1323186Post **stinger** » Mon 22 Apr 2013 4:11pm

Old Mate wrote:I'm having a shocker

....no worries mate.....

Con Gorozidis · Mon 22 Apr 2013 4:13pm

Old Mate wrote:I'm having a shocker

Dont worry champ. I did the exact same thing on the weekend

Scollop · Post: # 1323188Post **Scollop** » Mon 22 Apr 2013 4:13pm

Yes if the Bombers are interested in a straight swap...oooops -that's not what this thread is about...sorry

bergsone · Post: # 1323199Post **bergsone** » Mon 22 Apr 2013 4:37pm

Scollop wrote:Yes if the Bombers are interested in a straight swap...oooops -that's not what this thread is about...sorry

Goddard for Milne......................then they can return to their former clubs

stevie · Post: # 1323201Post **stevie** » Mon 22 Apr 2013 4:42pm

I'm always baffled as to how two black dudes of whatever nationality can 'racially abuse' each other.

Like the Symonds/Singh thing.

SainterK · Post: # 1323205Post **SainterK** » Mon 22 Apr 2013 4:46pm

Milne gets one week, also a big fine.

Saad cleared

Youngsters enjoyed it

Nathan Wright, Tom Simpkin, Ahmed Saad, Jarryn Geary can all accept $1200 for a 1st offence for engaging in a melee.

saintbrat · Post: # 1323211Post **saintbrat** » Mon 22 Apr 2013 4:50pm

Patrick Keane‏@AFL_PKeane
Stephen Milne can accept 1 game for making unnecessary contact to the face of Courtenay Dempsey.

Patrick Keane‏@AFL_PKeane2
Nathan Wright, Tom Simpkin, Ahmed Saad, Jarryn Geary can all accept $1200 for a 1st offence for engaging in a melee.

Patrick Keane‏@AFL_PKeane
Stephen Milne can accept $3000 sanction for a 3rd offence for engaging in a melee.

Patrick Keane‏@AFL_PKeane
Tom Bellchambers, Michael Hibberd, Jake Carlisle can all accept $2100 sanction for a 2nd offence for engaging in a melee.

Patrick Keane‏@AFL_PKeane
Ahmed Saad cleared contact Courtenay Dempsey - panel said force used was below that required for a report.

there are three incidents going to extra invwestigation- I wonder if what was said to Ahmeed is one of those..Patrick Keane‏@AFL_PKeane
MRP – 14 charges laid from weekend and three other matters detailed for further explanation.

St Chris · Post: # 1323217Post **St Chris** » Mon 22 Apr 2013 4:58pm

How can Dempsey not get a fine for the melee?? Him bumping Saad after that shot for goal started the whole thing - without his actions there would have been no melee.

SainterK · Post: # 1323223Post **SainterK** » Mon 22 Apr 2013 5:07pm

St Chris wrote:How can Dempsey not get a fine for the melee?? Him bumping Saad after that shot for goal started the whole thing - without his actions there would have been no melee.

MRP is investigation 3 more things, it may not be the end of it

Dempsey v Saad

Dempsey v Saad

Re: Dempsey v Saad

Re: Dempsey v Saad

Re: Dempsey v Saad

Re: Dempsey v Saad

Re: Dempsey v Saad

Re: Dempsey v Saad

Re: Dempsey v Saad

Re: Dempsey v Saad

Re: Dempsey v Saad

Re: Dempsey v Saad

Re: Dempsey v Saad

Re: Dempsey v Saad

Re: Dempsey v Saad

Re: Dempsey v Saad

Re: Dempsey v Saad

Re: Dempsey v Saad

Re: Dempsey v Saad

Re: Dempsey v Saad

Re: Dempsey v Saad

Re: Dempsey v Saad

Re: Dempsey v Saad

Re: Dempsey v Saad

Re: Dempsey v Saad

Re: Dempsey v Saad