The Two Team Argument

[whiskers3614]

Reckon Stuart Trott belongs somewhere on the bench for lost souls.
Ultimate lost soul Srephen Rae...to Tigers and then became a White Maggot!

[mbogo]

Yeah - I was wondering about Stuart Trott - he did leave didn't he? Was it Hawthorn? Why did he leave - Jeansie?
This is kind ironic considering he was knocked out by Lethal in 71 GF - I guess he did not want to get smashed again from behind?
Rae? Yeah he could play for sure, always wondered why we let him go.
Both deserve a game ...
is there anyone else?

[mbogo]

FINAL SCORES
Saints 21 28
154
Hayes 1 2
Baldock 3 3
Riewoldt 2 6
McNamara 2 4
Young 5 1
Neale 2 5
Burke 1 3
Stephenson 3 3
Milne 2 1



Lost Souls 25 3
153
Guerra 1
Stewart 2 1
Winmar 3 1
Cazaly 3
Lockett 12
Everitt 2 1
Owen 2

[gringo]

If we go way - way back when - then which team would win?
Who would you include and why?

Saints vs Traitors

Saints

Howell Frawley Lawrence
Barker Fisher Griffiths
Jones Dal Santo Watson
Baldock Reiwoldt Loewe
Burke Neale Young


Smith Harvey Morrow

Int: Bray, Roberts, Ross , Oswald

Coach: Baldock




Traitors

Guerra Dawson Besanko
Thomas Perovic McNamara
Winmar Stewart Icke
Hall Cazaly Davis
Rice Lockett Everitt
Ball Smith Ditterich

Int: ??
Coach: Jeans/Lyon

Note: a bit unfair to Nicky W ... and a bit sad to see him here because of it.





Goddard?

offensive to the max

So your saying that Allan Jeans, club legend is a traitor
that Ian Stewart, dual brownlow is a traitor

think about your language, before you post

Why is it offensive to Max is that because he is a traitor too. Dirty collingwood premiership wielding turncoat.

[bobmurray]

Yeah it is a bit rough - isn't it - what else can I name the other team?
I know ... I will edit

Good one...it's so easy to rope in the do gooders...you scored a hit there with your traitor name

[mbogo]

Yeah it is a bit rough - isn't it - what else can I name the other team?
I know ... I will edit

Good one...it's so easy to rope in the do gooders...you scored a hit there with your traitor name

Well - very true, Bob - but to be honest I named the team before I realised that guys like Nicky and Stewie had to be in it - and both were ditched - as might Goddard - so it is pretty unkind - so the new name is better.

[Dave McNamara]

Why is it offensive to Max is that because he is a traitor too. Dirty collingwood premiership wielding turncoat.

... speaking of that sorta' behaviour... how could we all forget...?


into the Traitor's back pocket, and onto the coach's bench...



our (once very own) Mad Micky Milkshake...?






PS: Yep, I was wrong. Got Vic's game numbers with us and the Dreamons the wrong way around. Shoulda' known better. But I won't post this confession in the 'I Was Wrong' thread till Pluggs first owns up to falsely slandering my wonderful coaching record at the 'Monders... come on Pluggs, 'fess up...


PPS: 2 goals 4 behinds...? Mbogo, you forgot to mention they were all kicked from inside the centre square... against a 3-4 wind... with a broken leg... in three places... in the first 10 minutes... with a leaking heart valve... before I got tired...

[mbogo]

Dave - we were lucky to win - and the wind was fine - Plugger kicked 12 straight! 11 up til 3/4 time.
If it was not for that free just before the siren you would have got 1-4. It must have been a lucky kick.
Thank goodness for Harves and Lennie!

[Dave McNamara]

Dave - we were lucky to win - and the wind was fine - Plugger kicked 12 straight! 11 up til 3/4 time.
If it was not for that free just before the siren you would have got 1-4. It must have been a lucky kick.
Thank goodness for Harves and Lennie!

Yeh..., but by that time my leg was broken in 4 (more) places... I'd mitral valve repair surgery in the rooms at half time so I could see out the game (no anaesthetic, that stuff is for wooses)... that free you mentioned was-definitely-there... and you didn't mention that it was in our back pocket... and I was kicking into the wind which had just sprung up again and then swung around against us... and there was chewy on my boot.

You're a hard man to please mbogo...

[IluvHarvey]

It would be Interesting to see aa team of players we got from other teams.

[whiskers3614]

From:Hamill,Penny,Gehrig,Gram,Shneider,Dempster,Voss,Gardiner,Ray,Callery,Hunt,Pekin,Foschini,Morwood,King,Milne,Crow,Sheldon,Black,Fletcher,Fiora.

I know I've missed heaps!
Help me out with our foreign legion(post 1970's)

[mbogo]

Russel Morris, Ricky Nixon,
Milne never played seniors at Ess I think - so you gotta have some limitations.
You mean Vic VFL or AFL clubs?
I just remembered G Sidebottom - and B Duperouzel .. who maybe could have played with the Lost souls ....

[mbogo]

Was there a Scott FF from Hawthorn?
And Jezaulenko

[dragit]

Always liked Rod Keogh…
Heath Black & Spud Dawson could play both sides, or do we have another side with players who have come from another club and then played at another club afterwards?

[dragit]

Dale Kickett - 5 clubs no less

Was he a party animal when he was young or something?

[mbogo]

Patterson can coach - lol
and Billy Barrot had a stellar career with us in 1971 playing two games ! Billy can also play on both sides - Barrot on Barrot
Oh the Krakouer Bros - Phil and Jim ...
just realised Xavier Clarke and G McAdam could have played lost souls too .. and Goose

[IluvHarvey]

Craig O'Brien could a handy forward in the foreign legion team.

[wolfpup]

shouldn't malthouse be in the lost souls side?