Nearest the Pin/Crystal Ball

This unofficial St Kilda Saints fan forum is for people of all ages to chat Saints Footy and all posts must be respectful.

Moderators: Saintsational Administrators, Saintsational Moderators

Post Reply
User avatar
Animal Enclosure
SS Hall of Fame
Posts: 2364
Joined: Mon 04 Apr 2005 2:37pm
Location: Saints Footy Central

Nearest the Pin/Crystal Ball

Post: # 1259430Post Animal Enclosure »

I know there's already a few threads on trading & delistments, etc but lets see you all put your money where your mouth is & crystal ball what our list will look like come Xmas.

The draft picks for compensation are a guess & I haven't worried too much about the size of the list. It's just a bit of fun so don't bother with the old "we'll never get him for that".

List Changes- OFF
Retire
Jason Blake

Delist (incl Rookies)
Sam Crocker
Nick Winmar- to rookie list
Dean Polo
Brett Peake
Raphael Clarke
Daniel Archer (R)
Warwick Andreoli (R)
Cameron Shenton (R)

Elevate
Tom Curren
Jackson Ferguson
Sam Dunell

Retain
Jordan Staley
Darren Minchington

Free Agency
Jason Gram to Richmond for band 3 compensation (2nd round pick)
Brendon Goddard to GWS (Uncontracted player- received pick 13 & 20)

Trades
2nd round pick (#34) to WC for Mitch Brown
Adam Schneider & 2nd round pick #43) (compo pick for Gram) to Gold Coast for Tom Hickey
Clinton Jones to Freo for 4th round pick

Draft
#12- Mason Shaw (197cm key forward)
#13-Troy Menzel (187cm Midfielder/forward)
#20- Tanner Smith (194cm defender)
#53- Jackson Coleman (196cm forward)
#71- Dean Towers (189cm midfielder)
#73- Myke Cook (183cm midfielder)

Rookies
1- Kyle Hartigan (194cm defender)
2- Ben Duscher (186cm midfielder)
3- Michael Sikora (202cm ruckman)
4- Nick Winmar
5- Jordan Staley
6- Darren Minchinton

List ON-

Tom Hickey (201cm Ruckman)
Mitch Brown (195cm Defender)
Mason Shaw (197cm forward)
Troy Menzel (187cm Midfielder)
Tanner Smith (194cm defender)
Jackson Coleman (196cm forward)
Dean Towers (189cm midfielder)
Myke Cook (183cm midfielder)
Rookies
Kyle Hartigan (194cm defender)
Ben Duscher (186cm midfielder)
Michael Sikora (202cm ruckman)

That might just fix our height issues!


User avatar
White Winmar
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 5014
Joined: Tue 02 Jun 2009 10:02pm

Re: Nearest the Pin/Crystal Ball

Post: # 1259468Post White Winmar »

If you could pull all of that off AE, then I would gladly let Chris Pelchen go. Good moves and I largely agree, but it has a touch of the "Daryl Kerrigans" about it. Still, a very good try and close to my semi-realistic wish list.


I started with nothing and I've got most of it left!
User avatar
sax
Club Player
Posts: 976
Joined: Tue 29 Nov 2005 10:19pm
Location: Barossa Valley
Been thanked: 1 time

Re: Nearest the Pin/Crystal Ball

Post: # 1259481Post sax »

Animal Enclosure wrote:I know there's already a few threads on trading & delistments, etc but lets see you all put your money where your mouth is & crystal ball what our list will look like come Xmas.

The draft picks for compensation are a guess & I haven't worried too much about the size of the list. It's just a bit of fun so don't bother with the old "we'll never get him for that".

List Changes- OFF
Retire
Jason Blake

Delist (incl Rookies)
Sam Crocker
Nick Winmar- to rookie list
Dean Polo
Brett Peake
Raphael Clarke
Daniel Archer (R)
Warwick Andreoli (R)
Cameron Shenton (R)

Elevate
Tom Curren
Jackson Ferguson
Sam Dunell

Retain
Jordan Staley
Darren Minchington

Free Agency
Jason Gram to Richmond for band 3 compensation (2nd round pick)
Brendon Goddard to GWS (Uncontracted player- received pick 13 & 20)

Trades
2nd round pick (#34) to WC for Mitch Brown
Adam Schneider & 2nd round pick #43) (compo pick for Gram) to Gold Coast for Tom Hickey
Clinton Jones to Freo for 4th round pick

Draft
#12- Mason Shaw (197cm key forward)
#13-Troy Menzel (187cm Midfielder/forward)
#20- Tanner Smith (194cm defender)
#53- Jackson Coleman (196cm forward)
#71- Dean Towers (189cm midfielder)
#73- Myke Cook (183cm midfielder)

Rookies
1- Kyle Hartigan (194cm defender)
2- Ben Duscher (186cm midfielder)
3- Michael Sikora (202cm ruckman)
4- Nick Winmar
5- Jordan Staley
6- Darren Minchinton

List ON-

Tom Hickey (201cm Ruckman)
Mitch Brown (195cm Defender)
Mason Shaw (197cm forward)
Troy Menzel (187cm Midfielder)
Tanner Smith (194cm defender)
Jackson Coleman (196cm forward)
Dean Towers (189cm midfielder)
Myke Cook (183cm midfielder)
Rookies
Kyle Hartigan (194cm defender)
Ben Duscher (186cm midfielder)
Michael Sikora (202cm ruckman)

That might just fix our height issues!

Where did you copy the list changes from! Looks strangely familiar, order & everything!

I like your thinking, but we need to use 3 picks to elevate rookies.


Foundation Social Club Member No. 296
User avatar
borderbarry
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 6676
Joined: Mon 19 Apr 2004 11:22pm
Location: Wodonga

Re: Nearest the Pin/Crystal Ball

Post: # 1259497Post borderbarry »

2 points...... Are we not having the number of rookies reduced for all clubs this season?
2nd. Whoops.. Missed Blake retired. I thought you had more coming in than spots available. Anyway, Sikora is 206cm so he alone makes a difference to our average height. And I would prefer Mayes or O'Rourke to Menzel. Injury concerns for one.


3rd generation saint
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 4661
Joined: Thu 28 Dec 2006 8:34am
Location: Jurassic Park

Re: Nearest the Pin/Crystal Ball

Post: # 1259567Post 3rd generation saint »

Goddard will not go to GWS, if he goes it will be to a team that has a shot at success.
BJ is just too fierce a competitor to play for a team that will be lucky to win 3 games next year.


Except for the sanity nothing much has been lost.
User avatar
Sick Nal Danto
Club Player
Posts: 376
Joined: Wed 28 Sep 2011 3:00pm

Re: Nearest the Pin/Crystal Ball

Post: # 1259696Post Sick Nal Danto »

Just wanted to point out that the tigers have delidio and Houli who are much better kicks than Gram


Post Reply