Stkilda vs Carlton Match thread

[Solar]

Umpire just cheated gets the Blues with in two.

Your knowledge of footy is poor and that is kind. We have had the better of the umpiring. They got a lucky 50 and then Joey cracked it.

c'mon mate, seriously? I would crack it as well. Was a completely wrong decision and then to give another when the player cracks it after a year of rubbish by the umpiring department sums up the year from them. They think they are above the game and this is pushed from the top by the fact that no-one can challenge them. How margetts still umpires is a joke.

BTW any chance the blues can start to be penalised for the cheap shots behind play. BJ almost laughed when he was nearly punched earlier... joke of the situation.

[plugger66]

Umpire just cheated gets the Blues with in two.

Your knowledge of footy is poor and that is kind. We have had the better of the umpiring. They got a lucky 50 and then Joey cracked it.

c'mon mate, seriously? I would crack it as well. Was a completely wrong decision and then to give another when the player cracks it after a year of rubbish by the umpiring department sums up the year from them. They think they are above the game and this is pushed from the top by the fact that no-one can challenge them. How margetts still umpires is a joke.

BTW any chance the blues can start to be penalised for the cheap shots behind play. BJ almost laughed when he was nearly punched earlier... joke of the situation.

Bad decision. Have we had the better of the umpiring? Are you watching Milne?

[Old Mate]

Siposs taking his game to another level over the last few weeks. Plays like he's a 150 game vet.

I like Ledger's endeavour, can find the footy, however doesn't know what to do with it when in his hands.

Cripps seems to have found the pace of the game since the first half of the season. He has more awareness and uses the footy well.

At this point I'm liking our 2010 draft picks.

[Wrote for Luck]

if we hadn't coughed the ball up so bloody easily we would have polished these twats by now.

[bigcarl]

these umpire have lost control

[Solar]

Seen alot of cheapies not paid, milne has had a couple on th lead that perhaps are 50/50 and a few holding balls very a bit dodgy. But why allow them to take sqings (big difference to what milne has done) plus that double 50 is a killer.

[CURLY]

Umpire just cheated gets the Blues with in two.

Your knowledge of footy is poor and that is kind. We have had the better of the umpiring. They got a lucky 50 and then Joey cracked it.

Couldnt care less if weve had the rub the umpire cheated with that 50. By the way dont try the childish I know more than you routine youll only lose.

[bigcarl]

Umpires keeping them in this. Another gift goal to Carlton against Gwilt

[God_Nel]

I am honestly sick of this. Sick to death. I am sick of the sheer lack of consistency of the schizophrenics we call 'umpires' who seem to change markedly after half time on an all too frequent basis. Umpiring should ideally never have a large hand in the result/momentum in a game but I've seen it too many times. The rules committee/umpiring dept, instead of amending the rules every year should focus on interpretation/consistency. Yet nothing will ever been done about it because admitting there is a major fault in the system is simply too hard when you have your ego and pride buried in your arse with razor blades.

[Legendary]

Worst game Dal Santo has ever played for the club, easily.

He's a champion and I rate him higher than most, but he has been destroyed today

[ShanghaiSaint]

saints playing a true stinker... umps have nothing to do with it.

[bigcarl]

Another example of half-wittery from the umpires. Score review!

[sunsaint]

Umpire just cheated gets the Blues with in two.

Your knowledge of footy is poor and that is kind. We have had the better of the umpiring. They got a lucky 50 and then Joey cracked it.

Couldnt care less if weve had the rub the umpire cheated with that 50. By the way dont try the childish I know more than you routine youll only lose.

Curly besides being 100% wrong about stating that the umpires cheated
the 1st 50mt against Montagna satisfies section 18.1 b, e & g
the second sections c & d
its now up to you go learn the rules, or stop wasting bandwidth

[Solar]

hey sunsaint, can we get a breakdown of why the waite dive was a free also? Just curious.

[plugger66]

For a game that means nothing it is a great contest but for god sake dont get reported you brain deads.

[ralphsmith]

So much bitterness between the players of these 2 sides.

Very good to watch!

[bobmurray]

Who got subbed off for Newnes

[CURLY]

Your knowledge of footy is poor and that is kind. We have had the better of the umpiring. They got a lucky 50 and then Joey cracked it.[ /quote]

Couldnt care less if weve had the rub the umpire cheated with that 50. By the way dont try the childish I know more than you routine youll only lose.

Curly besides being 100% wrong about stating that the umpires cheated
the 1st 50mt against Montagna satisfies section 18.1 b, e & g
the second sections c & d
its now up to you go learn the rules, or stop wasting bandwidth

Dont talk bulls*** that is never ever 50. Carlton player throws the ball and makes contact StKilda player. I suggest you learn the rules.

[ralphsmith]

I'm astounded Milera hasn't played more games this year. That guy oozes peripheral awareness. See that spin just now?

[sunsaint]

Dont talk bulls*** that is never ever 50. Carlton player throws the ball and makes contact StKilda player. I suggest you learn the rules.

as I thought you have never bothered to learn the rules of afl

[bobmurray]

I think some posters are having a GOOD Sunday arvo tipple.

What other explanation is there for some of the crap that's been written on here today.

[sunsaint]

hey sunsaint, can we get a breakdown of why the waite dive was a free also? Just curious.

I will submit a full report after the game
but soft free kicks get paid

[CURLY]

Dont talk bulls*** that is never ever 50. Carlton player throws the ball and makes contact StKilda player. I suggest you learn the rules.

as I thought you have never bothered to learn the rules of afl

Yeah of course your right. The umpire made a mistake just admit it.

[ralphsmith]

This game is slipping away.

Not a bright future with our youth either.

[CURLY]

hey sunsaint, can we get a breakdown of why the waite dive was a free also? Just curious.

I will submit a full report after the game
but soft free kicks get paid

Unless your Milne.