Guess this weeks ins and outs

[Dave McNamara]

I know people havent been able to sleep waiting for this topic. Well i havent look at the time.
So here we go and a bit of a change this year. Reason for the changes but only if you want to. i would never tell people what to do or how they should think. Actually i think I do do that. Anyway back to the topic.


Ins tonight
Ross, Wilkes, Ledger, Simpkin
Out
Polo

Final
in Ross, need another mid. Ledger obviously fit this week or gods knows why he was out

Out
Polo, suspended Ray last in first out after a bad game.

2 mids for 2 older mids. Simpkin unlucky but Blake did well and we cant have 3 young guys all in at once.

Final Team
In: Ledger, Simpkin, Ross.
Out: Ray, Polo, Peake.

Agree it would be unfair to leave Blake out after last week.
Simpkin more than deserves a go, so for something different I'd put him in in Polo's place - he has and can play both forward and back as needed.
Agree re the possible risk of bringing in 3 younguns' at once, however maybe not such an issue this week against the Suns of Beaches - great chance to give Ross a run. (No, not that Ro$$.)
Similarly, since we are playing who we are, I'd love to have given Saad a run, but will bow to those who say he hasn't earnt it as yet.
Milera - full game - go you good thing!
Armo - I'd be dropping him, except, we've invested so much in him, I'd like to see him given 4-5 games straight (in the middle) to find out what he can or can't do for us going forward. I hope I'm wrong, but I'm starting to suspect the latter.
Sub - no idea...


Disclaimer:
These are views formed from the outside looking in. I'm more than happy to bow to the judgements of those who have some inside knowledge of who's where at the moment.

Actually, I really have little idea, but since I asked for this thread to come back...

[MCG-Unit]

Ins tonight:
Ledger, Simpkin, Wilkes

Out:
Polo (susp)

Ins Final:
Ledger, xxx- need in and under clearance types

Out:
Polo (susp) Ray or Peake or maybe even Cripps (unless they're going to give him more game time)

[gringo]

We are missing a link up kick to player who can set up the next link in the chain. No Gwilt, Gram or Raph what about Winmar?

[lefty]

INS: Tom Simpkin, Nicholas Winmar, Tom Ledger, Jack Newnes, Beau Wilkes

OUTS: Brett Peake, Dean Polo (Suspension)


I'd say Ledger is in 100%, which would take Peakes spot, not sure about who goes in for Polo, but I think Simpkin should.

Also, I thought Peake played ok last week tbh, Steven turned the ball over by foot far too many times, Ray is on the edge imo.
Bit strange about Sadd, might get him out of my Supercoach until he's ready as it looks like Milera is ahead of him?
I think Newness is still a bit young, however we are playing GC so who knows.
Nfi about how Winmar is progressing.

[westy]

IN: Wilkes, Winmar, Ledger, Newnes, Simpkin
OUT: Peake (Omitted), Polo (Suspended)

[plugger66]

IN: Wilkes, Winmar, Ledger, Newnes, Simpkin
OUT: Peake (Omitted), Polo (Suspended)

I think that will be close.

[Con Gorozidis]

Disclaimer:
These are views formed from the outside looking in. I'm more than happy to bow to the judgements of those who have some inside knowledge of who's where at the moment.

Actually, I really have little idea, but since I asked for this thread to come back...

DM - your views and opinions seem as valid as anyone elses. Dont believe the flogs who reckon they have inside info and their views are "more knowledgable" than everyone else. Flogs.

(except zebraman who is a legend).

[clarky449]

I guess we can have 3 young guys at once.

[saintly]

I know people havent been able to sleep waiting for this topic. Well i havent look at the time.
So here we go and a bit of a change this year. Reason for the changes but only if you want to. i would never tell people what to do or how they should think. Actually i think I do do that. Anyway back to the topic.


Ins tonight
Ross, Wilkes, Ledger, Simpkin
Out
Polo

Final
in Ross, need another mid. Ledger obviously fit this week or gods knows why he was out

Out
Polo, suspended Ray last in first out after a bad game.

2 mids for 2 older mids. Simpkin unlucky but Blake did well and we cant have 3 young guys all in at once.

It looks like we can!!!

in newnes, simpkin ledger

out polo, ray, peake