Do we have a culture problem?
Moderators: Saintsational Administrators, Saintsational Moderators
Do we have a culture problem?
And I don't necessarily mean just the players, I mean the whole club. Reason I ask is there a person at my work who used to work for the club a few years ago and lets just say she is not complementary about the place. Her words "St Kilda has a terrible culture, worst in the AFL"....
Not trying to bag the club here, just really interested if anyone can comment on this? Hopefully someone with actual exprience at the club who knows if we have a culture problem...
Not trying to bag the club here, just really interested if anyone can comment on this? Hopefully someone with actual exprience at the club who knows if we have a culture problem...
- Dr Spaceman
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 14102
- Joined: Thu 24 Sep 2009 11:07pm
- Location: Newtown Institute of Saintology
- Has thanked: 104 times
- Been thanked: 62 times
Re: Do we have a culture problem?
Just out of curiosity, has that person worked at any other AFL clubs in order to establish that the Saints are in fact the "worst in the AFL"saintlee wrote:And I don't necessarily mean just the players, I mean the whole club. Reason I ask is there a person at my work who used to work for the club a few years ago and lets just say she is not complementary about the place. Her words "St Kilda has a terrible culture, worst in the AFL"....
Not trying to bag the club here, just really interested if anyone can comment on this? Hopefully someone with actual exprience at the club who knows if we have a culture problem...
![Confused :?](./images/smilies/icon_confused.gif)
- SaintPav
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 18947
- Joined: Wed 16 Jun 2010 9:24pm
- Location: Alma Road
- Has thanked: 1587 times
- Been thanked: 1987 times
Re: Do we have a culture problem?
Did she work with Archie Frazer?saintlee wrote:And I don't necessarily mean just the players, I mean the whole club. Reason I ask is there a person at my work who used to work for the club a few years ago and lets just say she is not complementary about the place. Her words "St Kilda has a terrible culture, worst in the AFL"....
Not trying to bag the club here, just really interested if anyone can comment on this? Hopefully someone with actual exprience at the club who knows if we have a culture problem...
How would she know it's the worst in the AFL unless she has worked at every club?
Having said that, we have won one premiership in 138 years, so she might be on to something.
Holder of unacceptable views and other thought crimes.
- SaintPav
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 18947
- Joined: Wed 16 Jun 2010 9:24pm
- Location: Alma Road
- Has thanked: 1587 times
- Been thanked: 1987 times
Well that changes everything.saintlee wrote:Sorry, forgot to add, the person in question has worked at 2 clubs, the other being Hawthorn.
And yes, her comment that St Kilda has the worst culture in the AFL is a generalisation, but the question remains, do we have a culture problem?
Holder of unacceptable views and other thought crimes.
Re: Do we have a culture problem?
Not sure if Archie Frazer was there...was about 2 years ago that she was there.SaintPav wrote:Did she work with Archie Frazer?saintlee wrote:And I don't necessarily mean just the players, I mean the whole club. Reason I ask is there a person at my work who used to work for the club a few years ago and lets just say she is not complementary about the place. Her words "St Kilda has a terrible culture, worst in the AFL"....
Not trying to bag the club here, just really interested if anyone can comment on this? Hopefully someone with actual exprience at the club who knows if we have a culture problem...
How would she know it's the worst in the AFL unless she has worked at every club?
Having said that, we have won one premiership in 138 years, so she might be on to something.
- PaytonPlace
- Club Player
- Posts: 496
- Joined: Thu 23 Jun 2011 8:31pm
Re: Do we have a culture problem?
If you wanted to look at it through a very narrow prism where the negatives are all you think of, well....saintlee wrote:And I don't necessarily mean just the players, I mean the whole club. Reason I ask is there a person at my work who used to work for the club a few years ago and lets just say she is not complementary about the place. Her words "St Kilda has a terrible culture, worst in the AFL"....
Not trying to bag the club here, just really interested if anyone can comment on this? Hopefully someone with actual exprience at the club who knows if we have a culture problem...
West Coast: Drugs, captain leaves partly due to poor player behaviour, Chick punches Embley...
Sydney Swans: Star full forward punches players until he gets sacked, and something else you can find on Google
Collingwood: Swan vs Cleaner, Shaw vs Bookies, Shaw vs Lamp-post, Shaw vs Truth, Cloke vs left hook, Pendleburys 21st, Beams vs the law...
Geelong: Steve Johnson, David Johnson, Alleged Paul Chapman story, Coach leaves saying players don't learn the gameplan...
Mystery Un-named Victorian Club fails many, many drug tests...
I could go on. Point being: especially the last 4 all have "strong cultures" according to the press. Know why? They've won flags. We nearly did. And as long as it's nearly, in the media our culture will be derided I'm afraid...if we won one, the bubble would be the new black....
I don't know if your friend has something specific, I couldn't comment, but that's my 2c...
Becca
You can listen to Bristle tell you Carlton are still a massive chance at 28 points down with two minutes to go, you can listen to him tell you all about Lorne, or you can watch a monkey on a pushbike...I know which I prefer...
Re: Do we have a culture problem?
Yeah, I'm more or less aware of these sorts of player issues, its more the overall culture I'm interested in, that is the admin, management, professionalism etc of the place.PaytonPlace wrote:If you wanted to look at it through a very narrow prism where the negatives are all you think of, well....saintlee wrote:And I don't necessarily mean just the players, I mean the whole club. Reason I ask is there a person at my work who used to work for the club a few years ago and lets just say she is not complementary about the place. Her words "St Kilda has a terrible culture, worst in the AFL"....
Not trying to bag the club here, just really interested if anyone can comment on this? Hopefully someone with actual exprience at the club who knows if we have a culture problem...
West Coast: Drugs, captain leaves partly due to poor player behaviour, Chick punches Embley...
Sydney Swans: Star full forward punches players until he gets sacked, and something else you can find on Google
Collingwood: Swan vs Cleaner, Shaw vs Bookies, Shaw vs Lamp-post, Shaw vs Truth, Cloke vs left hook, Pendleburys 21st, Beams vs the law...
Geelong: Steve Johnson, David Johnson, Alleged Paul Chapman story, Coach leaves saying players don't learn the gameplan...
Mystery Un-named Victorian Club fails many, many drug tests...
I could go on. Point being: especially the last 4 all have "strong cultures" according to the press. Know why? They've won flags. We nearly did. And as long as it's nearly, in the media our culture will be derided I'm afraid...if we won one, the bubble would be the new black....
I don't know if your friend has something specific, I couldn't comment, but that's my 2c...
Becca
- PaytonPlace
- Club Player
- Posts: 496
- Joined: Thu 23 Jun 2011 8:31pm
Re: Do we have a culture problem?
I guess what I was trying to get at (if it makes sense) is that we live in a culture that values winners. From an outside perspective, the reason people would say we have a terrible culture is because we don't win flags, but it would turn on a dime if we had won one of two. Like Geelong in 2007, the day they were 2-3 a big double page spread appeared in the Herald Sun saying they were a joke and a rabble and ex players were wheeled out to say how hopeless the place is...saintlee wrote:Yeah, I'm more or less aware of these sorts of player issues, its more the overall culture I'm interested in, that is the admin, management, professionalism etc of the place.PaytonPlace wrote:If you wanted to look at it through a very narrow prism where the negatives are all you think of, well....saintlee wrote:And I don't necessarily mean just the players, I mean the whole club. Reason I ask is there a person at my work who used to work for the club a few years ago and lets just say she is not complementary about the place. Her words "St Kilda has a terrible culture, worst in the AFL"....
Not trying to bag the club here, just really interested if anyone can comment on this? Hopefully someone with actual exprience at the club who knows if we have a culture problem...
West Coast: Drugs, captain leaves partly due to poor player behaviour, Chick punches Embley...
Sydney Swans: Star full forward punches players until he gets sacked, and something else you can find on Google
Collingwood: Swan vs Cleaner, Shaw vs Bookies, Shaw vs Lamp-post, Shaw vs Truth, Cloke vs left hook, Pendleburys 21st, Beams vs the law...
Geelong: Steve Johnson, David Johnson, Alleged Paul Chapman story, Coach leaves saying players don't learn the gameplan...
Mystery Un-named Victorian Club fails many, many drug tests...
I could go on. Point being: especially the last 4 all have "strong cultures" according to the press. Know why? They've won flags. We nearly did. And as long as it's nearly, in the media our culture will be derided I'm afraid...if we won one, the bubble would be the new black....
I don't know if your friend has something specific, I couldn't comment, but that's my 2c...
Becca
They kicked 220 points against Richmond that day and started winning. The same people were in charge, same coach, same players doing the same things, just the on field performance improved. Our management and way of doing things would be a template and a standard if we'd won the flag: we lost, so it's all wrong....
Hope that makes sense anyway
You can listen to Bristle tell you Carlton are still a massive chance at 28 points down with two minutes to go, you can listen to him tell you all about Lorne, or you can watch a monkey on a pushbike...I know which I prefer...
- degruch
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 8948
- Joined: Mon 19 May 2008 4:29pm
- Location: Croydonia
- Has thanked: 146 times
- Been thanked: 237 times
Re: Do we have a culture problem?
Two years ago, we were smashing anyone that came near us...I guess that's what makes the comment interesting. I remember in 2008 there was a widely held view that St Kilda was a terrible place to play/work, when things weren't going so well. Never heard that from anyone in the club, of course.PaytonPlace wrote:I guess what I was trying to get at (if it makes sense) is that we live in a culture that values winners. From an outside perspective, the reason people would say we have a terrible culture is because we don't win flags, but it would turn on a dime if we had won one of two.
Re: Do we have a culture problem?
Yes, that's precisely what I'm getting at...my colleague worked for the Saints at a time when we going alright on the field, but she hated working for the club...it was really disappointing to hear, and wanted to see if anyone else had similar or different stories about it...degruch wrote:Two years ago, we were smashing anyone that came near us...I guess that's what makes the comment interesting. I remember in 2008 there was a widely held view that St Kilda was a terrible place to play/work, when things weren't going so well. Never heard that from anyone in the club, of course.PaytonPlace wrote:I guess what I was trying to get at (if it makes sense) is that we live in a culture that values winners. From an outside perspective, the reason people would say we have a terrible culture is because we don't win flags, but it would turn on a dime if we had won one of two.
- PaytonPlace
- Club Player
- Posts: 496
- Joined: Thu 23 Jun 2011 8:31pm
Re: Do we have a culture problem?
(I love these kind of arguments, so if I bang on, let me know!)degruch wrote:Two years ago, we were smashing anyone that came near us...I guess that's what makes the comment interesting. I remember in 2008 there was a widely held view that St Kilda was a terrible place to play/work, when things weren't going so well. Never heard that from anyone in the club, of course.PaytonPlace wrote:I guess what I was trying to get at (if it makes sense) is that we live in a culture that values winners. From an outside perspective, the reason people would say we have a terrible culture is because we don't win flags, but it would turn on a dime if we had won one of two.
But we didn't win a flag, and to the outside world, that means something is wrong with our culture and it's really lazy thinking (especially in PR circles and media outlets)
OK, I know a girl who worked at Collingwood doing the same job I do, but for them, media work, PR....all that stuff. She said it was horrible to work there, the only person who ever learned her name (and I apologize for this!) was Mick Malthouse, the department was utterly micro-managed, and it was full of petty inter office jealousies. But if I went to a party or conference and said "man, Collingwood, that has an awful culture" people would look at me strangely or at least debate the point. If I said the same things but substituted St Kilda into the conversation I guarantee one person would say "Yeah that's why they don't win Premierships"
And the strong culture would be the one with a long rap sheet, and a board that lost them 8 million dollars in bad pub deals and the weak one would be the one held ransom to a crazy teenager...could you extrapolate from that winners have strong cultures and losers have weak cultures as far as the media and the populace is concerned?
You can listen to Bristle tell you Carlton are still a massive chance at 28 points down with two minutes to go, you can listen to him tell you all about Lorne, or you can watch a monkey on a pushbike...I know which I prefer...
- desertsaint
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 10423
- Joined: Sun 27 Apr 2008 2:02pm
- Location: out there
- Has thanked: 187 times
- Been thanked: 705 times
not to worry - the exiting out of a former captain and quality individual, the recruiting of lovett, the sexual escapades with psychotic sixteen year olds, the naked cavorting, the sleeping pill parties...
all these cultural issues happened under the watch of a man of questionable ethics who has now beenn exited out.
our culture will improve.
all these cultural issues happened under the watch of a man of questionable ethics who has now beenn exited out.
our culture will improve.
"The starting point of all achievement is desire. "
- degruch
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 8948
- Joined: Mon 19 May 2008 4:29pm
- Location: Croydonia
- Has thanked: 146 times
- Been thanked: 237 times
Re: Do we have a culture problem?
Yes, granted...just because the office was a s*** place to work, doesn't mean the club itself has a 'bad culture'. Collingwood has a bad culture, but everyone might be having a blast at the expense of the rest of the world. Eddie may be Mr Scorpio for all we know.PaytonPlace wrote:(I love these kind of arguments, so if I bang on, let me know!)degruch wrote:Two years ago, we were smashing anyone that came near us...I guess that's what makes the comment interesting. I remember in 2008 there was a widely held view that St Kilda was a terrible place to play/work, when things weren't going so well. Never heard that from anyone in the club, of course.PaytonPlace wrote:I guess what I was trying to get at (if it makes sense) is that we live in a culture that values winners. From an outside perspective, the reason people would say we have a terrible culture is because we don't win flags, but it would turn on a dime if we had won one of two.
But we didn't win a flag, and to the outside world, that means something is wrong with our culture and it's really lazy thinking (especially in PR circles and media outlets)
-
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 6594
- Joined: Sat 11 Jun 2011 4:52pm
- Location: Here
- Has thanked: 1292 times
- Been thanked: 465 times
- Dr Spaceman
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 14102
- Joined: Thu 24 Sep 2009 11:07pm
- Location: Newtown Institute of Saintology
- Has thanked: 104 times
- Been thanked: 62 times
- Con Gorozidis
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 23532
- Joined: Thu 19 Jun 2008 4:04pm
- Has thanked: 100 times
- Been thanked: 78 times
-
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 12421
- Joined: Tue 24 Mar 2009 11:05pm
- Location: St Kilda
- Has thanked: 296 times
- Been thanked: 55 times
Jeezus we must be f***ed, a mate who follows the Hawks and knows some high up people there told me that the reason the Hawks rebuilt their list was due to some extremely problematic cultural issues at the club. He fully expected the club to have a major media incident that blew over. If we are worse than what I was told we may be in some serious trouble.saintlee wrote:Sorry, forgot to add, the person in question has worked at 2 clubs, the other being Hawthorn.
And yes, her comment that St Kilda has the worst culture in the AFL is a generalisation, but the question remains, do we have a culture problem?
- Winmar
- Club Player
- Posts: 922
- Joined: Tue 23 Mar 2004 11:52pm
- Location: Canberra
- Has thanked: 14 times
- Been thanked: 26 times
The culture thing bugs me more than a bit. It seems that those who are lazy of thought like to slap the "poor culture" tag on the club all the time, as if it's still 1985. I'm yet to hear any evidence that our culture is worse than that of other clubs now. Lots of AFL clubs have had players who have stuffed up (hello Campbell Brown), so Dawson and co breaking rules to go out for drinks is not in itself indicative of a wider problem.