Dal Santo v Judd

[Maklom]

I was just browsing over the stats on the AFL website and was looking at the top 10 for overall possesions. Judd is 8th and Dal is 10th.
Here are there breakdowns side by side:

Player K H D M HO CL FF FA T G B Ga

Chris Judd 269 304 573 61 0 143 29 27 134 13 15 21
Nick Dal Santo 308 254 562 72 25 107 23 10 113 13 8 21

Considering Dal has had more kicks, hitouts, less clangers and more accurate goal kicking, how does everyone think he will go in the brownlow considering everyone thinks Judd is a lock for the award?

I reckon Dals numbers stack up pretty well and on this years stats I would rather have him than Judd in my team.

[Maklom]

More marks as well.

[markp]

Judd's still miles ahead in the 'audible orgasms per possession' stat.

[shmic_s]

Looking at those:

Clearences
Judd 143 vs Dal 107

Tackles
Judd 134 vs Dal 113

To me shows that Judd is better in the packs. Dal prefers to kick (308 vs 269), and be in space.
Equal in goals scored though, would be intersting to see score involvements or I50's.

Imagine how good he'd be doing if we still had Lenny on the park?

Nick has had a great year and would be a good chance for the brownlow.
Polls well, uses the footy well but has he influenced enough winning games?

[Maklom]

Ah schweppes, I read CL as 'Clangers' not 'Clearances' my bad. Makes Judds overall rating look better however I think statistically there is no too much between them. I wonder which one talks back to the umpires more as Frees against is in Dals favour.

[busso mick]

Judd's still miles ahead in the 'audible orgasms per possession' stat.

I always wondered what the stats column heading AAPP stood for

Juddy is also miles ahead in the 'grimace when on camera stat' (while resting hands on hips).

[plugger66]

Judd's still miles ahead in the 'audible orgasms per possession' stat.

Think Dal does pretty well with the umps as. Stats can be rubbish and in this case probably are. Dal has had a great year and will win our B&F but Judd is a fair way ahead of him and everyone else in the AFL this year.

[Sainternist]

Dal will win the Brownlow.

There, I said it.

[Thinline]

Judd's still miles ahead in the 'audible orgasms per possession' stat.

Think Dal does pretty well with the umps as. Stats can be rubbish and in this case probably are. Dal has had a great year and will win our B&F but Judd is a fair way ahead of him and everyone else in the AFL this year.

Fair call on Judd.

Doesn't make him less of a pain in the arse.

[Maklom]

I'm not saying Dal will win it but what helps him is that he has clearly been our best midfielder (player overall) where as Judd will have votes taken off him by Murphy and Gibbs potentially.

Also Dal might sneak a vote or two in the close ones we lost:

Round 1 v Geelong - 30 touches
Round 6 v Adelaide - 29 touches
Round 7 v Carlton - 24 touches

[SainterK]

I'm not saying Dal will win it but what helps him is that he has clearly been our best midfielder (player overall) where as Judd will have votes taken off him by Murphy and Gibbs potentially.

Also Dal might sneak a vote or two in the close ones we lost:

Round 1 v Geelong - 30 touches
Round 6 v Adelaide - 29 touches
Round 7 v Carlton - 24 touches

Agree that Murphy will pinch votes, he is leading alot of the other media comps.

[Old Mate]

Dal will win the Brownlow.

There, I said it.

I give him a very good chance !

Murphy and Judd will take votes off each other (you'd think).

As far as mids for the Saints go they've all been relatively average except for Dal who has been exceptional.

[stevie]

Dal will finish in the top 5 I reckon.

At least he doesn't bite, eye gouge or scratch like some other midfielder

[Dan Warna]

Judd got 3 votes during carlton's bye.

[stevie]

Judd got 3 votes during carlton's bye.

Yep. He'll probably get votes in their first final too...