Did Kosi do enough to hold his place in the 22?

Dr Spaceman · Mon 25 Jul 2011 11:57am

SaintPav wrote:
longtimesaint wrote:Reece the plumber on one good leg would be better than a fit Kosi -everyone can see the logic in that!
Well, yes. that's right because Rys has so much form on the board doesn't he?

Kosi's last 3 games now have been promising/solid and he's the sort of player that will only improve with each consecutive contest.

All his possible replacements are either playing with less impact in a lower competition or unable to get on the park due to injury.

In fact this thread is so ridiculous you wonder how it could have possibly started

Oh that's right - TROLL!!!!!

Junction Oval · Mon 25 Jul 2011 2:35pm

I'll take the Premiership offer !!

Junction Oval · Mon 25 Jul 2011 2:38pm

More seriously, Kosi is at long last showing some good signs, so he must stay in.

I think that Rhyse still has a hammy problem.

I would like to see McEvoy rested this week, for Gardy. Freo and the Pies will be very big games for Macca and we ned to be at our best for both games.

Helen · Post: # 1110509Post **Helen** » Mon 25 Jul 2011 2:48pm

Maybe rest Kosi this week and bring Gardiner in. Let Gardiner do the bulk of the ruck work (say 70%), and McEvoy can do the other 30% and spend a lot of time on the bench.

Does that sound better??

Junction Oval · Mon 25 Jul 2011 2:56pm

Has logic to it, Helen, but I would continue to play Kosi while he is on the improve - it's a lot to do with his confidence being up, I think.

You would have to talk to Macca, to see where he is at, but from afare, he could do with a rest.

ausfatcat · Post: # 1110516Post **ausfatcat** » Mon 25 Jul 2011 3:01pm

Helen wrote:Maybe rest Kosi this week and bring Gardiner in. Let Gardiner do the bulk of the ruck work (say 70%), and McEvoy can do the other 30% and spend a lot of time on the bench.

Does that sound better??

What did Essendon pay for Mark Williams again?

Rosco · Post: # 1110556Post **Rosco** » Mon 25 Jul 2011 3:41pm

dons got williams + picks 24 & 33, gave up jay nash + picks 16 & 42

see the "trades" table here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2009_AFL_Draft

MCG-Unit · Post: # 1110574Post **MCG-Unit** » Mon 25 Jul 2011 3:54pm

I think it was a 3-way deal involving Ess, Port & Geelong...

Hawthorn traded #16 for Burgoyne from Port
Port picked Jasper Pittard with #16
Geelong took Vardy at #42

So Essendon lost majorly while the others would be very pleased.

gringo · Post: # 1110833Post **gringo** » Mon 25 Jul 2011 7:32pm

How's Brenttte stanton going anyway? Knights was a better coach than the character referee and the sandwich muncher put together. Lloydy must have pushed him out though white ant style, he is bigger than the team you know.

plugger66 · Post: # 1110843Post **plugger66** » Mon 25 Jul 2011 7:41pm

gringo wrote:How's Brenttte stanton going anyway? Knights was a better coach than the character referee and the sandwich muncher put together. Lloydy must have pushed him out though white ant style, he is bigger than the team you know.

Yep that makes sense. How would you know how good a coach Hird is? And even Knights. Thompson record suggests that comment is ridiculous.

Helen · Post: # 1111737Post **Helen** » Wed 27 Jul 2011 6:33pm

ausfatcat wrote:
Helen wrote:Maybe rest Kosi this week and bring Gardiner in. Let Gardiner do the bulk of the ruck work (say 70%), and McEvoy can do the other 30% and spend a lot of time on the bench.

Does that sound better??

What did Essendon pay for Mark Williams again?

Hey ausfatcat, your stupid comment above is something Joffaboy (Geoff) would say. Are you his alter ego??