In Your Opinion-- best 5 in player list

saintbrat · Post: # 1103775Post **saintbrat** » Tue 12 Jul 2011 8:30pm

everyone has differing opinions on many things and I just got to wondering how many variations on best 5 people have.

remembering that is it IYO and there is no CORRECT list

Best 5 In current ST KILDA player list for
Kicks

Goal kicking

Handballing( hitting the target player)

Tackles

Evasion..- the Dummy..

Marking (added late)

BigMart · Post: # 1103779Post **BigMart** » Tue 12 Jul 2011 8:39pm

Goddard

Goddard

Goddard

Jones

Dal Santo

Old Mate · Post: # 1103784Post **Old Mate** » Tue 12 Jul 2011 8:52pm

Goddard

Goddard

Goddard

Hayes

Hayes

dragit · Post: # 1103788Post **dragit** » Tue 12 Jul 2011 8:55pm

Dal Santo

Siposs

Goddard

Hayes

Dal Santo

BigMart · Post: # 1103801Post **BigMart** » Tue 12 Jul 2011 9:09pm

Is hayes counted.....i was assuming current team and len was injured

If so,

Lenny is clearly best tackler....and probably best evasive, or at least a tie..

Forgot about siposs....

But probably still take BJ under pressure.....then again....

Cjanged my mind...siposs at goal

Zac Attack · Tue 12 Jul 2011 9:46pm

saintbrat wrote:everyone has differing opinions on many things and I just got to wondering how many variations on best 5 people have.

remembering that is it IYO and there is no CORRECT list

Best 5 In current ST KILDA player list for
Kicks

Goal kicking

Handballing( hitting the target player)

Tackles

Evasion..- the Dummy..

Goddard

Kosi

Rarely do I see one of the top liners make errors during a game re handball

Hayes/Goddard

Dal Santo as Lenny doesn't do it as often.

Con Gorozidis · Tue 12 Jul 2011 10:34pm

Kicks

goddard/gwilt

Goal kicking

siposs

Handballing( hitting the target player)

dal santo

Tackles

len-dog/jones

Evasion..- the Dummy..[/quote]

len-dog/gram

philtee · Post: # 1103882Post **philtee** » Tue 12 Jul 2011 10:53pm

The people who've been doing the most to win us a game of footy
over the past few weekls -
Goddard
Milne
McEvoy
Riewoldt
Gwilt

...apologies to Jack Steven and Dal Santo.
Or did you want one name per category ???

saintbrat · Tue 12 Jul 2011 10:57pm

philtee wrote:The people who've been doing the most to win us a game of footy
over the past few weekls -
Goddard
Milne
McEvoy
Riewoldt
Gwilt

...apologies to Jack Steven and Dal Santo.

but in relation to the specific skills..? which player for which skill?

I always think later how I better should have posed the questions.

what about Top 5 in each skill?

Armoooo · Post: # 1103895Post **Armoooo** » Tue 12 Jul 2011 11:02pm

Kicks -
Brendon Goddard
Nick Dal Santo
James Gwilt
Nick Riewoldt
Aaryn Siposs

Goal kicking -
Stephen Milne
Jack Steven
Brendon Goddard
Nick Dal Santo
Leigh Montagna

Handballing -
Nick Dal Santo
Leigh Montagna
Brendon Goddard
Stephen Milne
Adam Schneider

Tackles -
Lenny Hayes
David Armitage
Jack Steven
Nick Dal Santo
Ben McEvoy

Evasion -
Nick Dal Santo
Brendon Goddard
Sam Gilbert
??
??

This was hard... I'm not even sure how much of it I agree with lol

Junction Oval · Tue 12 Jul 2011 11:03pm

Kicking - Goddard

Goal Kicking - Gamble

Handball - Fisher ?

Tackles - Jones

Evasion - Dal Santo

What about Marking - McEvoy

saintbrat · Tue 12 Jul 2011 11:06pm

Junction Oval wrote:Kicking - Goddard

Goal Kicking - Gamble

Handball - Fisher ?

Tackles - Jones

Evasion - Dal Santo

What about Marking - McEvoy

thanks JO will add it.

Ben would be just a head of Nick for this year but generally Nick may be top

Armoooo · Post: # 1103901Post **Armoooo** » Tue 12 Jul 2011 11:07pm

Marking -
Ben McEvoy
Nick Riewoldt
Brendon Goddard
Sam Fisher
Farren Ray

dcstkfc · Post: # 1103902Post **dcstkfc** » Tue 12 Jul 2011 11:07pm

Kicks

Goddard
Dal Santo
Gwilt
Siposs
McQualter

Goalkicking

Siposs
Goddard
Dal Santo
Steven
Milne

Handballing

Too hard, most hit targets most of the time, but McEvoy deserves special praise for his composure for such a big, slow man

Tackling

Hayes
Jones
Armitage
Eddy
Steven

Evasive skills

Dal Santo
Gilbert
Hayes
Milne
Ray

dcstkfc · Post: # 1103904Post **dcstkfc** » Tue 12 Jul 2011 11:09pm

Armoooo wrote:
Goal kicking -
Stephen Milne
Jack Steven
Brendon Goddard
Nick Dal Santo
Leigh Montagna

Montagna's career goalkicking: 93 goals 89 behinds

BigMart · Post: # 1103909Post **BigMart** » Tue 12 Jul 2011 11:13pm

Marking

Riewoldt.....best contested mark in the afl

plugger66 · Tue 12 Jul 2011 11:15pm

BigMart wrote:Marking

Riewoldt.....best contested mark in the afl

Based on what?

desertsaint · Tue 12 Jul 2011 11:18pm

Kicking - goddard
Goal kicking - milne
Handballing - dal
Tackles - lenny
Evasion - milne
Marking - goddard
Floaters - gram
Hospital balls - raph
Evasion (from making a tackle) - gram

BigMart · Post: # 1103915Post **BigMart** » Tue 12 Jul 2011 11:20pm

The fact he's taken more contested marks in the afl on average per game since 2008....is that difficult to believe....

I think you are confusing contested marking with one out marking....

Coisin jack is good, but does not make as many contests as big nick....who takes more than anyone

Munga · Post: # 1103916Post **Munga** » Tue 12 Jul 2011 11:22pm

I took this differently to everyone else and did top 5 for each category...

Kicks, I can't separate Gwilt and Goddard. Both deadly long accurate kicks on both sides. Maybe I'll give it to BJ cos he bags goals too.
Gwilt
Fisher
Dal Santo
Montagna
Goddard
(honorable mention to Peake)

Goal kicking. BJ from anywhere.
Goddard
Peake
Montagna
Dal Santo
Gamble

Handballing( hitting the target player). Hard to judge.
Gwilt
Fisher
Schneider
Dal Santo
Hayes

Tackles. Lenny.
Hayes
Jones
Gilbert
McEvoy
Armitage

Evasion..- the Dummy..There's a few good one's with the candy. For consistent success, Gram.
Gram
Gilbert
Hayes
Schneider
Dal Santo

plugger66 · Tue 12 Jul 2011 11:24pm

BigMart wrote:The fact he's taken more contested marks in the afl on average per game since 2008....is that difficult to believe....

I think you are confusing contested marking with one out marking....

Coisin jack is good, but does not make as many contests as big nick....who takes more than anyone

I would have thought we would have been talking either this year or at the most last year. This year he isnt in the top 40 and is at least 40 contested marks behind Cloke. He is behind Ben as well. last year due to injury he was no where near it. Surprised he would be ahead of Cloke since 2008 but even if he is that was 3 and 4 years ago.

And i am pretty sure what is a contested mark but thanks for twlling me what isnt a contested mark. By the way got some stats to prove what you say?

Munga · Post: # 1103919Post **Munga** » Tue 12 Jul 2011 11:25pm

I'd have Fisher for marking.

saintbrat · Tue 12 Jul 2011 11:27pm

thats as I thought it Munga just hadn't worded it right

BigMart · Post: # 1103926Post **BigMart** » Tue 12 Jul 2011 11:40pm

Arent i allowed to have an opinion???

Do i have to run it by you first....to make sure i get it right, because you right.....yeah

Do you agree with everyone else....Because i didnt see you question others....anyone would think you stalking me......people might talk

I tell you what.....whatever ever it is with your little obsession with me is, and it is rather flattering....try and get over it, get a grip.....

Im not you mortal enemy, dont even know you, and dont want to.....because you sound like a bit of a tosser and a touch weird....

Ill wait with baited breath whilst we ruin another perfectly good thread, because I say something and you have to find anyway you can to discredit it, much to the annoyance of heaps of other people..

Btw....ill check the stats

Spinner · Post: # 1103939Post **Spinner** » Wed 13 Jul 2011 12:02am

Um not sure what game ppl watch but Goddard is a woeful handballer. And by woeful its obviously in direct comparison to his elite kicking.

Never has been and probably never will be an effective handballer. A minor weakness.

In Your Opinion-- best 5 in player list

In Your Opinion-- best 5 in player list

Re: In Your Opinion-- best 5 in player list

Re: In Your Opinion-- best 5 in player list

Re: In Your Opinion-- best 5 in player list

Re: In Your Opinion-- best 5 in player list

Re: In Your Opinion-- best 5 in player list