odd stat Query- Reports/suspensions

saintbrat · Post: # 1096612Post **saintbrat** » Tue 28 Jun 2011 9:26pm

a small comment in another thread ( which I'd prefer not to bump)

But which current Saints players have
a) never been reported
B) never been suspended

and then
D) before Baker who has the next most reports/suspensions.

the comment was on Milney having missed a few games due to suspension But I can never remember him being suspended....

Eastern · Post: # 1096616Post **Eastern** » Tue 28 Jun 2011 9:41pm

C) Don't know the question therefore don't know the answer

D) Kosi, at a guess

stkildathunda · Tue 28 Jun 2011 9:49pm

Has Riewoldt or Dal Santo ever been suspended? Can never remember them doing anything to warrant it.

Also McEvoy, Steven...

plugger66 · Post: # 1096697Post **plugger66** » Wed 29 Jun 2011 8:28am

Milney got 2 weeks about 7 years ago for elbowing Scarlett I believe.

SunburySaint · Wed 29 Jun 2011 8:55am

Found this re Milne suspension.

Milne, Ling suspended
Posted Tue Apr 29, 2003 8:27pm AEST
Updated Tue Apr 29, 2003 8:40pm AEST
The AFL tribunal has suspended both St Kilda's Stephen Milne and Geelong's Cameron Ling for striking.

Milne was suspended for two weeks after being found guilty of striking Geelong's Matthew Scarlett, while Ling received a one-week ban for striking Saint Nick Riewoldt.

That's the last and only time he was suspended?

Beno88 · Post: # 1096709Post **Beno88** » Wed 29 Jun 2011 9:37am

stkildathunda wrote:Has Riewoldt or Dal Santo ever been suspended? Can never remember them doing anything to warrant it.

Also McEvoy, Steven...

Riewoldt and Dal Santo have both been reported for engaging in a melee / wrestling. However they've only been fined, not suspended.

stkildathunda · Wed 29 Jun 2011 9:58am

Beno88 wrote:
stkildathunda wrote:Has Riewoldt or Dal Santo ever been suspended? Can never remember them doing anything to warrant it.

Also McEvoy, Steven...
Riewoldt and Dal Santo have both been reported for engaging in a melee / wrestling. However they've only been fined, not suspended.

I reckon all our players that have been around for 5+ years would probably have some kinda small charge like that then.....

samwell · Post: # 1096717Post **samwell** » Wed 29 Jun 2011 10:39am

As posted above I rekcon Kosi would have to be 2nd behind Bakes.

Can't remember Raph, Mini, Blake, Gilbert ever getting suspended??

What about Lenny - can't remember him ever getting rubbed out - think he got reported againts Freo 5 or 6 years ago but got off (miracle!!!!)

stkildathunda · Wed 29 Jun 2011 10:43am

samwell wrote:As posted above I rekcon Kosi would have to be 2nd behind Bakes.

Can't remember Raph, Mini, Blake, Gilbert ever getting suspended??

What about Lenny - can't remember him ever getting rubbed out - think he got reported againts Freo 5 or 6 years ago but got off (miracle!!!!)

I reckon Blake has been done for tripping or something once... Dempster hasnt been since he has been at the Saints from what i recall.

Mr Magic · Post: # 1096725Post **Mr Magic** » Wed 29 Jun 2011 11:00am

samwell wrote:As posted above I rekcon Kosi would have to be 2nd behind Bakes.

Can't remember Raph, Mini, Blake, Gilbert ever getting suspended??

What about Lenny - can't remember him ever getting rubbed out - think he got reported againts Freo 5 or 6 years ago but got off (miracle!!!!)

I'm pretty sure Lenny was suspended for striking a few years back?

Life Long Saint · Wed 29 Jun 2011 11:13am

Mr Magic wrote:
samwell wrote:As posted above I rekcon Kosi would have to be 2nd behind Bakes.

Can't remember Raph, Mini, Blake, Gilbert ever getting suspended??

What about Lenny - can't remember him ever getting rubbed out - think he got reported againts Freo 5 or 6 years ago but got off (miracle!!!!)
I'm pretty sure Lenny was suspended for striking a few years back?

He got weeks for a forearm strike against the Lions in 2004...Kosi also got weeks for tripping in the same game.

Moccha · Post: # 1096729Post **Moccha** » Wed 29 Jun 2011 11:31am

Arryn Siposs hasn't been suspended

Beno88 · Post: # 1096753Post **Beno88** » Wed 29 Jun 2011 1:17pm

All St.Kilda suspensions since 1991.

Current listed players are in bold.

Justin Koschitzke - R13 2011 - 2 weeks for rough conduct
Steven Baker - R8 2011 - 2 weeks for striking
Leigh Montagna - R7 2011 - 1 week for misconduct
Zac Dawson - R6 2011 - 1 week for striking
Adam Schneider - GFR 2010 - 2 weeks for striking
Steven Baker - R13 2010 - 3 weeks for striking
Steven Baker - R13 2010 - 3 weeks for striking
Steven Baker - R13 2010 - 2 weeks for striking
Steven Baker - R13 2010 - 1 week for misconduct
Justin Koschitzke - R1 2010 - 3 weeks for rough conduct
Justin Koschitzke - R16 2009 - 1 weeks for striking
Zac Dawson - R16 2009 - 2 weeks for rough conduct
Steven King - R11 2009 - 4 weeks for rough conduct
Michael Gardiner - R10 2009 - 1 week for striking
Ryan Gamble - R4 2008 - 1 week for striking - playing for Geelong
Aaron Fiora - R19 2008 - 1 week for striking
Justin Koschitzke - R16 2008 - 1 week for striking
Steven Baker - R20 2007 - 7 weeks for rough conduct
Justin Koschitzke - R16 2007 - 1 week for striking
Steven Baker - R6 2007 - 1 week for rough conduct
Steven Baker - R6 2007 - 1 week for striking
Fraser Gehrig - R3 2007 - 1 week for striking
Steven Baker - R17 2006 - 2 weeks for attempted striking
Max Hudghton - R7 2006 - 1 week for striking
Michael Gardiner - R16 2005 - 2 weeks for striking - playing for West Coast
Fraser Gehrig - R6 2005 - 1 week for striking
Fraser Gehrig - R14 2004 - 2 weeks for striking
Brent Guerra - R14 2004 - 1 week for striking
Heath Black - R7 2004 - 2 weeks for striking
Lenny Hayes - R6 2004 - 2 weeks for striking
Justin Koschitzke - R6 2004 - 1 week for tripping
Steven Baker - R3 2004 - 4 weeks for striking
Aaron Hamill - R3 2004 - 1 week for tripping
Stephen Milne - R17 2003 - 1 week for striking
Fraser Gehrig - R16 2003 - 1 week for striking
Steven Baker - R14 2003 - 1 week for kicking
Stephen Mline - R5 2003 - 1 week for striking
Peter Everitt - R11 2002 - 1 week for striking
Jason Traianidis - R21 2001 - 1 week for striking
Barry Hall - R17 2001 - 3 weeks for striking
Steven Baker - R16 2001 - 1 week for striking
Brett Moyle - R19 2000 - 3 weeks for charging
Stewart Loewe - R12 2000 - 3 weeks for striking
Darryl Wakelin - R12 2000 - 2 weeks for striking
Barry Hall - R7 2000 - 1 week for headbutting
Barry Hall - SF 1998 - 4 weeks for kneeing
Darryl Wakelin - R21 1998 - 2 weeks for charging
Stewart Loewe - R16 1998 - 3 weeks for striking
Steven Sziller - R3 1997 - 2 weeks for striking
David Sierakowski - R18 1996 - 1 week for striking
Lazar Vidovic - R11 1996 - 3 weeks for striking
Darryl Wakelin - R6 1996 - 2 weeks for charging
Glen Coghlan - R17 1995 - 2 weeks for striking
Stewart Loewe - R2 1995 - 3 weeks for striking
Nathan Burke - R2 1995 - 2 weeks for striking
Nicky Winmar - R16 1994 - 3 weeks for striking
Lazar Vidovic - R16 1994 - 1 week for pushing foot into player
Dean Greig - R8 1994 - 4 weeks for striking
Tony Lockett - R7 1994 - 8 weeks for striking
Dean Greig - R3 1994 - 2 weeks for striking
Danny Frawley - R16 1993 - 1 week for wrestling
Dean Greig - R14 1993 - 2 weeks for charging
Tony Lockett - R3 1993 - 2 weeks for striking
Craig Devonport - R16 1992 - 2 weeks for tripping
Lazar Vidovic - EF 1991 - 2 weeks for striking
Brian Wilson - R6 1991 - 1 week for striking

markinUSA · Post: # 1096755Post **markinUSA** » Wed 29 Jun 2011 1:42pm

Thanks for all that research!
Much appreciated.

samwell · Post: # 1096756Post **samwell** » Wed 29 Jun 2011 1:57pm

so i get 28 weeks suspended for bakes - what's the record?? could he still do it by the end of the season???

Mr Magic · Post: # 1096759Post **Mr Magic** » Wed 29 Jun 2011 2:09pm

samwell wrote:so i get 28 weeks suspended for bakes - what's the record?? could he still do it by the end of the season???

I reckon that's more than either Big Carl or Mad Dog?

saintbrat · Post: # 1096761Post **saintbrat** » Wed 29 Jun 2011 2:15pm

well done Beno88 did you have a source for that information?

Beno88 · Post: # 1096775Post **Beno88** » Wed 29 Jun 2011 3:37pm

saintbrat wrote:well done Beno88 did you have a source for that information?

allthestats.com

Statistics from each round contain who was suspended, what for and for how long.

That was the only site I could find that had suspension info from seasons gone by.

saintbrat · Post: # 1096777Post **saintbrat** » Wed 29 Jun 2011 3:42pm

thanks for compiling then

stinger · Post: # 1096809Post **stinger** » Wed 29 Jun 2011 5:03pm

Mr Magic wrote:
samwell wrote:so i get 28 weeks suspended for bakes - what's the record?? could he still do it by the end of the season???
I reckon that's more than either Big Carl or Mad Dog?

c
mad dog notched up 22 weeks

borderbarry · Wed 29 Jun 2011 5:39pm

Yes but Mad Dog only played about 68 games. At that rate Bakes would have to be outed for aabout 66 games. And there was incomplete TV coverage at Bob's games.

Mr Magic · Post: # 1096836Post **Mr Magic** » Wed 29 Jun 2011 6:08pm

I was trying to make the point that both Big Carl adn Mad Dog were considered a tad 'unsportsmanlike' in their day adn yet Baker who nobody actually thinks of as a 'puncher' (in the same vein as Big Carl, Mad Dog etc) has surpassed them for games suspended.
Just highlights that he cannot get away with virtually anything, whether it's real or imaginary!

I refect back to a conversation I had with somebody at the Club who told me that the AFL had told us Baker was going to be scrutinized Matt Rendell had told the person I was speaking with).
This was after the 'Judd incident' when they decided his tactics were not what they wanted to see out there.
Cannot help but think much of what has transpired since seems to fit that scenario.