Team changes against Kangas

bergholt · Post: # 1093438Post **bergholt** » Tue 21 Jun 2011 10:25am

bigred wrote:Play the kids ffs.

The season is over. Get some games into them NOW.

if we want to, we could feasibly win five or six games of the next six. then we'd be in some sort of form and sitting in the lower reaches of the eight, with collingwood, sydney away, north and carlton to come. yes, there'd still be a task ahead of us, but it's hard to say the season is quite over yet.

FortiusQuoFidelius · Tue 21 Jun 2011 12:40pm

bergholt wrote:
SydneySainter wrote:Gilbert, in horror form. Isn't enjoying his footy and I doubt he's enjoying life at Seaford or in Melbourne in general. Send him on leave and only bring him back if he really wants to play for the Saints. Given what he's been through, I doubt he will. I think playing for a new club AWAY from Melbourne is what he needs.
from what i hear, his girlfriend is in melbourne and he's happy in this town - not being the sharpest tool in the shed.

but i wouldn't be at all surprised to see him in an essendon jumper next year (without any particular information on this) because i reckon they've got some stuff we could use and he could slot into their side nicely.

As I have posted in another thread, Gilbert will be in GWS colours next year and the compensation pick we get for him will go to Geelong in exchange for Hawkins.

saint58 · Post: # 1093813Post **saint58** » Tue 21 Jun 2011 10:23pm

stevie wrote:I know this will cause the usual arguments but I don't care!!

i suggested it weeks ago and I think its still valid:

Roo to CHB. He gets his mojo back. He would be a good matchup on Petrie;

Zac to FF. He's done ok there before, he gets his mojo back and doesn't have to worry about keeping up with big fwds;

If not Zac, Chips down fwd, or BJ.

At least try it against the Roos...

Dont know about roo at chb but like your thinking about Zack it would not disrupt the backline to much interesting.

joffaboy · Post: # 1093819Post **joffaboy** » Tue 21 Jun 2011 10:29pm

FortiusQuoFidelius wrote:
bergholt wrote:
SydneySainter wrote:Gilbert, in horror form. Isn't enjoying his footy and I doubt he's enjoying life at Seaford or in Melbourne in general. Send him on leave and only bring him back if he really wants to play for the Saints. Given what he's been through, I doubt he will. I think playing for a new club AWAY from Melbourne is what he needs.
from what i hear, his girlfriend is in melbourne and he's happy in this town - not being the sharpest tool in the shed.

but i wouldn't be at all surprised to see him in an essendon jumper next year (without any particular information on this) because i reckon they've got some stuff we could use and he could slot into their side nicely.
As I have posted in another thread, Gilbert will be in GWS colours next year and the compensation pick we get for him will go to Geelong in exchange for Hawkins.

If that happened, I would not be too cross.

Dr Spaceman · Tue 21 Jun 2011 10:39pm

joffaboy wrote:
FortiusQuoFidelius wrote:
bergholt wrote:
SydneySainter wrote:Gilbert, in horror form. Isn't enjoying his footy and I doubt he's enjoying life at Seaford or in Melbourne in general. Send him on leave and only bring him back if he really wants to play for the Saints. Given what he's been through, I doubt he will. I think playing for a new club AWAY from Melbourne is what he needs.
from what i hear, his girlfriend is in melbourne and he's happy in this town - not being the sharpest tool in the shed.

but i wouldn't be at all surprised to see him in an essendon jumper next year (without any particular information on this) because i reckon they've got some stuff we could use and he could slot into their side nicely.
As I have posted in another thread, Gilbert will be in GWS colours next year and the compensation pick we get for him will go to Geelong in exchange for Hawkins.

If that happened, I would not be too cross.

So that basically makes it a straight swap of Gilbert for Hawkins.

As disappointing as Sam has been so far in 2011, I think we'd be the loser in such a deal.

Don't rate Hawkins at all. A big lump of a kid who dominated at U18 level but has struggled when faced with opponents his own size.

Of course if it happens I hope I'm proven wrong!

ralphsmith · Tue 21 Jun 2011 10:42pm

Hawkins is an absolute dud.if he cant get a game with the supremely talented geelomg midfield putting passes down his throat how is he going to go with the likes of clinton jones kicking the ball over his head time and time again.

He would need a major penny dropping moment of discovery to turn his career around, dont think it will ever happen.

Teflon · Post: # 1093886Post **Teflon** » Wed 22 Jun 2011 12:28am

FortiusQuoFidelius wrote:
bergholt wrote:
SydneySainter wrote:Gilbert, in horror form. Isn't enjoying his footy and I doubt he's enjoying life at Seaford or in Melbourne in general. Send him on leave and only bring him back if he really wants to play for the Saints. Given what he's been through, I doubt he will. I think playing for a new club AWAY from Melbourne is what he needs.
from what i hear, his girlfriend is in melbourne and he's happy in this town - not being the sharpest tool in the shed.

but i wouldn't be at all surprised to see him in an essendon jumper next year (without any particular information on this) because i reckon they've got some stuff we could use and he could slot into their side nicely.
As I have posted in another thread, Gilbert will be in GWS colours next year and the compensation pick we get for him will go to Geelong in exchange for Hawkins.

God no Hawkins is a cabbage.

They are happy with Vardy/Menzel and co...thats why theyd want to off load their "plugger".

No tks.

saintbob · Post: # 1094102Post **saintbob** » Wed 22 Jun 2011 6:20pm

OUTS: KOSI, RAPH, GRAM, DAWSON, GILBERT

INS: JOHNSON, LEDGER, SIPOSS, SIMPKIN, BLAKE

Sobraz · Post: # 1094132Post **Sobraz** » Wed 22 Jun 2011 7:29pm

I'll spew if we go anywhere near Hawkins...

And Gilbo isn't going anywhere... All other talk is big noting bullsh1t...

InkerSaint · Wed 22 Jun 2011 7:39pm

We will keep trying to train it, improve it and filter talent through over the journey that can take us to a level of execution to allow us to win the games we want to win.

Ross Lyon's comment after last week's game.

If his words are worth anything it might be Dal Santo that we see in the twos. Clear turnover leader with 15, followed by Gram with 10.

However his other comment was Walsh was the only one who had put his hand up. So, pending this weekend's Sandy performance I'll say one change:

OUT Kosi (susp.)
IN Walsh

Con Gorozidis · Wed 22 Jun 2011 7:41pm

FortiusQuoFidelius wrote:
As I have posted in another thread, Gilbert will be in GWS colours next year and the compensation pick we get for him will go to Geelong in exchange for Hawkins.

I dont doubt that. I reckon thats a serious possibility.
Just dont tell my dad. He cant stand the tomahawk. He will spew if he hears this.

Con Gorozidis · Wed 22 Jun 2011 7:43pm

bergholt wrote:
SydneySainter wrote:Gilbert, in horror form. Isn't enjoying his footy and I doubt he's enjoying life at Seaford or in Melbourne in general. Send him on leave and only bring him back if he really wants to play for the Saints. Given what he's been through, I doubt he will. I think playing for a new club AWAY from Melbourne is what he needs.
from what i hear, his girlfriend is in melbourne and he's happy in this town - not being the sharpest tool in the shed.

but i wouldn't be at all surprised to see him in an essendon jumper next year (without any particular information on this) because i reckon they've got some stuff we could use and he could slot into their side nicely.

straight swap for jetta would be nice.

mad saint guy · Wed 22 Jun 2011 10:15pm

Out: Gamble, Gram, Gilbert, Clarke, Koschitzke (susp)
In: Siposs, Ledger, Lynch, Blake, Stanley

B: Gwilt, Dawson, Baker
HB: Lynch, Blake, Fisher
C: Peake, Steven, Montagna
HF: Schneider, Goddard, Riewoldt
F: Milne, Stanley, Siposs

Foll: McEvoy, Dal Santo, Armitage
Int: Ray, Jones, Ledger, Dempster

Dr Spaceman · Wed 22 Jun 2011 10:20pm

InkerSaint wrote:
We will keep trying to train it, improve it and filter talent through over the journey that can take us to a level of execution to allow us to win the games we want to win.
Ross Lyon's comment after last week's game.

If his words are worth anything it might be Dal Santo that we see in the twos. Clear turnover leader with 15, followed by Gram with 10.

However his other comment was Walsh was the only one who had put his hand up. So, pending this weekend's Sandy performance I'll say one change:

OUT Kosi (susp.)
IN Walsh

I reckon this game has been flagged for a while as the Tommy Walsh game and Kosi getting rubbed out doesn't hurt that prospect at all.

However given we've got a bye this week and Sandy doesn't it's pretty hard to guess any changes, because a lot will ride on performances on Sunday.

A bit of fun nonetheless.

mohannair · Post: # 1096073Post **mohannair** » Mon 27 Jun 2011 1:18pm

Having looked at the domination Petrie & Goldstein did yesterday we should have someone to counteract both.

I think the game was won by Kangas becasue of these 2 talls.

Macca should match up with Goldy but should nullify the impact of Petrie.

Last year Jonesy shut Harvey for his worst game of the season so I expect him to go to Harvey.

Who will get Petrie, Walsh any chance?

saintjake · Post: # 1096076Post **saintjake** » Mon 27 Jun 2011 1:31pm

mad saint guy wrote:Out: Gamble, Gram, Gilbert, Clarke, Koschitzke (susp)
In: Siposs, Ledger, Lynch, Blake, Stanley

B: Gwilt, Dawson, Baker
HB: Lynch, Blake, Fisher
C: Peake, Steven, Montagna
HF: Schneider, Goddard, Riewoldt
F: Milne, Stanley, Siposs

Foll: McEvoy, Dal Santo, Armitage
Int: Ray, Jones, Ledger, Dempster

Stanley in at FF over Johnson and even Walsh?
Riewoldt to a Flank and Goddard to CHF?

Junction Oval · Mon 27 Jun 2011 1:35pm

Petrie is experienced and playing well. We need to match him up with experience - Zac first, then Gwilt. Leave Fisher at HB.

Walsh kicked 3 for Sandy and played well. He should be a good chance for this week.

Dr Spaceman · Mon 27 Jun 2011 1:43pm

Junction Oval wrote:Petrie is experienced and playing well. We need to match him up with experience - Zac first, then Gwilt. Leave Fisher at HB.

Walsh kicked 3 for Sandy and played well. He should be a good chance for this week.

I think you mean Johnson kicked 3 for Sandy JO

saintjake · Post: # 1096086Post **saintjake** » Mon 27 Jun 2011 1:55pm

Might make Petrie the Captain on my Supercoach side this week.
Is in ripping form and I cant really find anyone on our list that could match him.

SainterK · Post: # 1096089Post **SainterK** » Mon 27 Jun 2011 2:01pm

saintjake wrote:Might make Petrie the Captain on my Supercoach side this week.
Is in ripping form and I cant really find anyone on our list that could match him.

It's pretty obvious that most of the kicks are going to him though, he is actually ranked the second highest inside 50 target in the comp this year.

A team effort should see him nullified surely?

Junction Oval · Mon 27 Jun 2011 2:02pm

Thanks Doc - yes you are correct, I was meaning Johnson.

It's called "pushing the send button before checking the message." Unfortunately, I do it all the time.

Con Gorozidis · Mon 27 Jun 2011 3:18pm

IN: Johnson, Ledger
OUT: Kosi (susp), Gram (om)

This also means Cahill can play Sandy Seniors this week.

Solar · Post: # 1096139Post **Solar** » Mon 27 Jun 2011 4:16pm

In: johnson, ledger

out: kosi, raph

sipposs very close and gamble needs to keep working his butt off to keep his spot. Zac on notice, walsh has to to ber very close.

dragit · Post: # 1096143Post **dragit** » Mon 27 Jun 2011 4:24pm

Do we know if Clarke is eligible to play this week?

attila_Siposs · Mon 27 Jun 2011 4:31pm

mohannair wrote:With Kosi gone for couple of weeks I think Sippos should come in (or may be Blake), Ralph may go & get in Simpkin.

What else?

Any chance Gardi will come in? Heard that he injured his knee in another forum, don't know if it is true. If not he should play for Sandi nthis week & come in straight for the game against Kangas.

In that case Macca can play forward along with Roey.

In short

OUT:- Kosi, Ralph & ????
In:- Sippos(Blake), Simpkin & Gardi

no chance of Blake. Poor bugga did his knee again yesterday playing for sandy. Did it in the first quarter

Team changes against Kangas

Re: Team changes against Kangas