Brett Peake - MRP - Accepts points

[markinUSA]

He accepted points for negligent contact with an umpire.

Did anyone see it? If you know when it happened, I could watch it on the replay on ESPN - available for another day or two.

Cheers,
Mark

[SaintSimmo]

he bumped into the umpire

[GrumpyOne]

he bumped into the umpire

I would assume that what "negligent contact with an umpire" means.

[SaintSimmo]

he bumped into the umpire

I would assume that what "negligent contact with an umpire" means.

yes it would

there wasn't much in it, i think its pretty self explanitory.

[kosifantutti23]

He accepted points for negligent contact with an umpire.

Did anyone see it? If you know when it happened, I could watch it on the replay on ESPN - available for another day or two.

Cheers,
Mark

Go to the AFL site. Under video there is an MRP section. You can watch from overseas.

BTW. I didn't think there were points involved, just money.

[Sainternist]

This rule is a bloody farce. I honestly can't remember a player delibrately running into an umpire, unless he played for The Filth reserves in 1985.

I haven't seen the Peake incident, nor did I even know about it until opening this thread. It seems most of the time players collide with umpires when the umpire is running backwards or strafing. Always seems accidental. What player in his right mind would want to go near a disease ridden anyway?

There was one thing I could see eye to eye with GT about and that was opinion of that umpires should only be seen and not heard (unless it's their whilstle).

I'm sure Plugger66 will disagree with on this one though

[Sainternist]

BTW. I didn't think there were points involved, just money.

yeah, the proceeds go towards umpires' end of year piss-up.

[plugger66]

This rule is a bloody farce. I honestly can't remember a player delibrately running into an umpire, unless he played for The Filth reserves in 1985.

I haven't seen the Peake incident, nor did I even know about it until opening this thread. It seems most of the time players collide with umpires when the umpire is running backwards or strafing. Always seems accidental. What player in his right mind would want to go near a disease ridden anyway?

There was one thing I could see eye to eye with GT about and that was opinion of that umpires should only be seen and not heard (unless it's their whilstle).

I'm sure Plugger66 will disagree with on this one though

I will totally disagree but as you havent umpired I will explain. The umpires come back in a line after a ball up. The players know that and if they happen to connect with the umpire it is their fault. You have to have that rule otherwise umpires could be cleaned up all the time. An umpire running back and not expecting contact, but receives it can really hurt and umpire. Simple for the player dont line up there or if you do avoid the umpire otherwise expect a penalty.

[Cairnsman]

This would never have happened under the old game plan. Seems even the umpires have been caught out with our intent to move it quicker.

[SaintPav]

This rule is a bloody farce. I honestly can't remember a player delibrately running into an umpire, unless he played for The Filth reserves in 1985.

I haven't seen the Peake incident, nor did I even know about it until opening this thread. It seems most of the time players collide with umpires when the umpire is running backwards or strafing. Always seems accidental. What player in his right mind would want to go near a disease ridden anyway?

There was one thing I could see eye to eye with GT about and that was opinion of that umpires should only be seen and not heard (unless it's their whilstle).

I'm sure Plugger66 will disagree with on this one though

I will totally disagree but as you havent umpired I will explain. The umpires come back in a line after a ball up. The players know that and if they happen to connect with the umpire it is their fault. You have to have that rule otherwise umpires could be cleaned up all the time. An umpire running back and not expecting contact, but receives it can really hurt and umpire. Simple for the player dont line up there or if you do avoid the umpire otherwise expect a penalty.

Have you umpired?

[plugger66]

This rule is a bloody farce. I honestly can't remember a player delibrately running into an umpire, unless he played for The Filth reserves in 1985.

I haven't seen the Peake incident, nor did I even know about it until opening this thread. It seems most of the time players collide with umpires when the umpire is running backwards or strafing. Always seems accidental. What player in his right mind would want to go near a disease ridden anyway?

There was one thing I could see eye to eye with GT about and that was opinion of that umpires should only be seen and not heard (unless it's their whilstle).

I'm sure Plugger66 will disagree with on this one though

I will totally disagree but as you havent umpired I will explain. The umpires come back in a line after a ball up. The players know that and if they happen to connect with the umpire it is their fault. You have to have that rule otherwise umpires could be cleaned up all the time. An umpire running back and not expecting contact, but receives it can really hurt and umpire. Simple for the player dont line up there or if you do avoid the umpire otherwise expect a penalty.

Have you umpired?

For over 20 years. In the Ammo's your club has to supply a seconds umpire.

[Cairnsman]

This rule is a bloody farce. I honestly can't remember a player delibrately running into an umpire, unless he played for The Filth reserves in 1985.

I haven't seen the Peake incident, nor did I even know about it until opening this thread. It seems most of the time players collide with umpires when the umpire is running backwards or strafing. Always seems accidental. What player in his right mind would want to go near a disease ridden anyway?

There was one thing I could see eye to eye with GT about and that was opinion of that umpires should only be seen and not heard (unless it's their whilstle).

I'm sure Plugger66 will disagree with on this one though

I will totally disagree but as you havent umpired I will explain. The umpires come back in a line after a ball up. The players know that and if they happen to connect with the umpire it is their fault. You have to have that rule otherwise umpires could be cleaned up all the time. An umpire running back and not expecting contact, but receives it can really hurt and umpire. Simple for the player dont line up there or if you do avoid the umpire otherwise expect a penalty.

Have you umpired?

For over 20 years. In the Ammo's your club has to supply a seconds umpire.

Did you do it live though?

[plugger66]

This rule is a bloody farce. I honestly can't remember a player delibrately running into an umpire, unless he played for The Filth reserves in 1985.

I haven't seen the Peake incident, nor did I even know about it until opening this thread. It seems most of the time players collide with umpires when the umpire is running backwards or strafing. Always seems accidental. What player in his right mind would want to go near a disease ridden anyway?

There was one thing I could see eye to eye with GT about and that was opinion of that umpires should only be seen and not heard (unless it's their whilstle).

I'm sure Plugger66 will disagree with on this one though

I will totally disagree but as you havent umpired I will explain. The umpires come back in a line after a ball up. The players know that and if they happen to connect with the umpire it is their fault. You have to have that rule otherwise umpires could be cleaned up all the time. An umpire running back and not expecting contact, but receives it can really hurt and umpire. Simple for the player dont line up there or if you do avoid the umpire otherwise expect a penalty.

Have you umpired?

For over 20 years. In the Ammo's your club has to supply a seconds umpire.

Did you do it live though?

No I am dead.

[Sainternist]

This rule is a bloody farce. I honestly can't remember a player delibrately running into an umpire, unless he played for The Filth reserves in 1985.

I haven't seen the Peake incident, nor did I even know about it until opening this thread. It seems most of the time players collide with umpires when the umpire is running backwards or strafing. Always seems accidental. What player in his right mind would want to go near a disease ridden anyway?

There was one thing I could see eye to eye with GT about and that was opinion of that umpires should only be seen and not heard (unless it's their whilstle).

I'm sure Plugger66 will disagree with on this one though

I will totally disagree but as you havent umpired I will explain. The umpires come back in a line after a ball up. The players know that and if they happen to connect with the umpire it is their fault. You have to have that rule otherwise umpires could be cleaned up all the time. An umpire running back and not expecting contact, but receives it can really hurt and umpire. Simple for the player dont line up there or if you do avoid the umpire otherwise expect a penalty.

Have you umpired?

For over 20 years. In the Ammo's your club has to supply a seconds umpire.

not exactly living up to your nickname, plugger. i thought you'd be the big guy in a player guernsey, waiting patiently to make a lead from the goal square, accepting a snort from someone's hip flask on the sidelines and chowing down on a sausage roll, until it was your turn to kick a sausage roll.

oh well, you're an umpire... YA WHITE MAGGOT

[SaintPav]

This rule is a bloody farce. I honestly can't remember a player delibrately running into an umpire, unless he played for The Filth reserves in 1985.

I haven't seen the Peake incident, nor did I even know about it until opening this thread. It seems most of the time players collide with umpires when the umpire is running backwards or strafing. Always seems accidental. What player in his right mind would want to go near a disease ridden anyway?

There was one thing I could see eye to eye with GT about and that was opinion of that umpires should only be seen and not heard (unless it's their whilstle).

I'm sure Plugger66 will disagree with on this one though

I will totally disagree but as you havent umpired I will explain. The umpires come back in a line after a ball up. The players know that and if they happen to connect with the umpire it is their fault. You have to have that rule otherwise umpires could be cleaned up all the time. An umpire running back and not expecting contact, but receives it can really hurt and umpire. Simple for the player dont line up there or if you do avoid the umpire otherwise expect a penalty.

Have you umpired?

For over 20 years. In the Ammo's your club has to supply a seconds umpire.

Did you do it live though?

No I am dead.

[MCG-Unit]

This rule is a bloody farce. I honestly can't remember a player delibrately running into an umpire, unless he played for The Filth reserves in 1985.

I haven't seen the Peake incident, nor did I even know about it until opening this thread. It seems most of the time players collide with umpires when the umpire is running backwards or strafing. Always seems accidental. What player in his right mind would want to go near a disease ridden anyway?

There was one thing I could see eye to eye with GT about and that was opinion of that umpires should only be seen and not heard (unless it's their whilstle).

I'm sure Plugger66 will disagree with on this one though

I will totally disagree but as you havent umpired I will explain. The umpires come back in a line after a ball up. The players know that and if they happen to connect with the umpire it is their fault. You have to have that rule otherwise umpires could be cleaned up all the time. An umpire running back and not expecting contact, but receives it can really hurt and umpire. Simple for the player dont line up there or if you do avoid the umpire otherwise expect a penalty.

Have you umpired?

For over 20 years. In the Ammo's your club has to supply a seconds umpire.

Did you do it live though?

No I am dead.

Lol classic, got the answer it deserved

[Enrico_Misso]

I honestly can't remember a player delibrately running into an umpire, unless he played for The Filth reserves in 1985.

Aaah - what a great moment that was

[Dr Spaceman]

I honestly can't remember a player delibrately running into an umpire, unless he played for The Filth reserves in 1985.

Aaah - what a great moment that was

And he's a Saints supporter

[Middo]

This rule is a bloody farce. I honestly can't remember a player delibrately running into an umpire, unless he played for The Filth reserves in 1985.

I haven't seen the Peake incident, nor did I even know about it until opening this thread. It seems most of the time players collide with umpires when the umpire is running backwards or strafing. Always seems accidental. What player in his right mind would want to go near a disease ridden anyway?

There was one thing I could see eye to eye with GT about and that was opinion of that umpires should only be seen and not heard (unless it's their whilstle).

I'm sure Plugger66 will disagree with on this one though

I will totally disagree but as you havent umpired I will explain. The umpires come back in a line after a ball up. The players know that and if they happen to connect with the umpire it is their fault. You have to have that rule otherwise umpires could be cleaned up all the time. An umpire running back and not expecting contact, but receives it can really hurt and umpire. Simple for the player dont line up there or if you do avoid the umpire otherwise expect a penalty.

Have you umpired?

For over 20 years. In the Ammo's your club has to supply a seconds umpire.

Now that explains everything ....lol

[Sainternist]

I honestly can't remember a player delibrately running into an umpire, unless he played for The Filth reserves in 1985.

Aaah - what a great moment that was

And he's a Saints supporter

do you mean enrico or the filth reserves player?

[Dr Spaceman]

I honestly can't remember a player delibrately running into an umpire, unless he played for The Filth reserves in 1985.

Aaah - what a great moment that was

And he's a Saints supporter

do you mean enrico or the filth reserves player?

I'm assuming enrico is

I met John Bourke a couple of years ago when Dean Greig brought him along to a Saints match at Etihad. Barracks for the Red White & Black.

Does hitting an umpire and barracking for the Saints neutralise the fact he played for the filth?

[Sainternist]

I honestly can't remember a player delibrately running into an umpire, unless he played for The Filth reserves in 1985.

Aaah - what a great moment that was

And he's a Saints supporter

do you mean enrico or the filth reserves player?

I'm assuming enrico is

I met John Bourke a couple of years ago when Dean Greig brought him along to a Saints match at Etihad. Barracks for the Red White & Black.

Does hitting an umpire and barracking for the Saints neutralise the fact he played for the filth?

i'd be a little perplexed if i were to discover enrico not being a devotee of the red, white and black.

but i am most certainly taken aback by your story of meeting john bourke being a saints man. i also feel quite embarrassed as i started a thread on the infamous incident in the opposition forum

are you mates with dean greig?

will never forget old greig's first game. 36 possessions in a team which walloped carlton by 9 goals. plugger lockett also went to town with a lazy 10. what a fun day out at the footy it was.

[Dr Spaceman]

I honestly can't remember a player delibrately running into an umpire, unless he played for The Filth reserves in 1985.

Aaah - what a great moment that was

And he's a Saints supporter  :D

do you mean enrico or the filth reserves player?

I'm assuming enrico is   

I met John Bourke a couple of years ago when Dean Greig brought him along to a Saints match at Etihad. Barracks for the Red White & Black.

Does hitting an umpire and barracking for the Saints neutralise the fact he played for the filth?

i'd be a little perplexed if i were to discover enrico not being a devotee of the red, white and black.

but i am most certainly taken aback by your story of meeting john bourke being a saints man. i also feel quite embarrassed as i started a thread on the infamous incident in the opposition forum  :oops: 

are you mates with dean greig?

will never forget old greig's first game. 36 possessions in a team which walloped carlton by 9 goals. plugger lockett also went to town with a lazy 10. what a fun day out at the footy it was.

Yeah, bump into Greigy every now and then at the Great Western or at the races (loves a punt )