Maybe a player that could have given us a supply as wellInkerSaint wrote: No point having more goalkickers if there is no supply!!!
And finally - to make a point about McQualter's game in GF1 - if he had not played we would not have had a second crack at it at all!
Maybe we woudn't have needed a 'second crack' if there was a player in the team that was effective in the 1st half.
Say Luke Miles on a HBF, Gilbert on the HFF earlier
I don't get your previous post as they're are clearly other factors beyond just tackling. And my point isn't just about the grand final. When his tackling and pressure dropped off over periods in the season he still retained his spot for the most part.
Ace - are you saying that we should reward mediocre performances in the seniors rather than the 1sts.
Wouldn't it have been better to make Andrew earn his spot back and give someone an opportunity to step up... what would we have lost?
Absolutely nothing and potentially may have gained something
By that logic Gwilt would seldom have gotten a game over the last 3 years. He's never been a super dominant VFL player. Getting games into him helped his devlopment though and when he got the opportunity he took it
Forgive me if I'm not mistaken but Andrew's game in the 2s wasn't particularly dominant either