Best and Worst

BigMart · Post: # 1006890Post **BigMart** » Sat 02 Oct 2010 6:39pm

Best
Dal Santo
Goddard
Hayes
Gwilt
Schnieder

Worst
Peake
Eddy
Milne
McQualter
Gram

Most of the rest were either average or below average....

Some player have really lost a lot of standing after the two GF's, some have been OK....Goddard, Hayes, Gwilt, Fisher - gain respect

perfectionist · Sat 02 Oct 2010 6:42pm

Did Montagna play? Easily the most overrated player in the AFL.

BringBackMadDog · Sat 02 Oct 2010 6:42pm

BigMart wrote:Best
Dal Santo
Goddard
Hayes
Gwilt
Schnieder

Worst
Peake
Eddy
Milne
McQualter
Gram

Most of the rest were either average or below average....

Some player have really lost a lot of standing after the two GF's, some have been OK....Goddard, Hayes, Gwilt, Fisher - gain respect

Dal was OK, but boy did he butcher the ball, He also got murdered in transition by all of his direct opponents.

sRaf · Post: # 1006899Post **sRaf** » Sat 02 Oct 2010 6:44pm

perfectionist wrote:Did Montagna play? Easily the most overrated player in the AFL.

Not overrated, but absolute tripe on the day.

Milne my worst, Goddard my best.

Good for Dal for improving after last week.

Saint4Eva · Post: # 1006904Post **Saint4Eva** » Sat 02 Oct 2010 6:45pm

Our bottom 6 are not good enough. Eddy ect. dont deserve a premiership medal. Their bottom 6 ( Brown, Mcaffer ect.) do coz they kept our better players quiet. I just dont no what to think anymore.....

BigD · Post: # 1006917Post **BigD** » Sat 02 Oct 2010 6:50pm

BigMart wrote:Best
Dal Santo
Goddard
Hayes
Gwilt
Schnieder

Worst
Peake
Eddy
Milne
McQualter
Gram

Most of the rest were either average or below average....

Some player have really lost a lot of standing after the two GF's, some have been OK....Goddard, Hayes, Gwilt, Fisher - gain respect

Don't let Riewoldt off the hook from this second group.

Missed several critical shots when it mattered and spent most of the day up field kick chasing. Never any where near home when we got it.

Another massive grand final failure and no excuses this time. Sorry but we should expect a lot more from a captain.

Lot to answer for IMO

borderbarry · Sat 02 Oct 2010 6:53pm

There are a number of our players who were far too slow!
Dempster, whenever he gets the ball taakes a fortnight to get rid of it. He often ignores players on their own and checks out all other options. By then that player is covered. He nearly always kicks to a contest.\
McQualter, always looks slow for his size, as does Baker nowadays.
Peake and Jones and Gram are supposed to be our fastest. Gawd help us.
When you think of the fast players that should make the team next year, like Miles, Stanley, Walsh, and perhaps Smith and Steven, there is still hope for us, but only if we bite the bullet.

saintbob · Post: # 1006942Post **saintbob** » Sat 02 Oct 2010 7:02pm

Best

1 Goddard
2 Dal Santo
3 Hayes
4 Gilbert
5 McEvoy
6 Gwilt

Worst

1 Milne
2 Peake
3 Eddy
4 McQualter
5 Dawson

cwrcyn · Post: # 1007000Post **cwrcyn** » Sat 02 Oct 2010 7:27pm

Peake and Eddy were poor in both games, with Peake costing us goals in both. McQualter wasn't far behind.

.

BringBackMadDog · Sat 02 Oct 2010 7:32pm

perfectionist wrote:Did Montagna play? Easily the most overrated player in the AFL.

Please stop posting, you are sounding more and more ridiculous very minute. Have you been drinking? Are you high? so far you have us sending Gilbert to the Suns and now you have Monty as overrated. FFS Shut the Hell UP!!

perfectionist · Sat 02 Oct 2010 7:35pm

BringBackMadDog wrote:
perfectionist wrote:Did Montagna play? Easily the most overrated player in the AFL.
Please stop posting, you are sounding more and more ridiculous very minute. Have you been drinking? Are you high? so far you have us sending Gilbert to the Suns and now you have Monty as overrated. FFS Shut the Hell UP!!

Abuse is such a strong argument. You need to think more and yell less.

BringBackMadDog · Sat 02 Oct 2010 7:40pm

perfectionist wrote:
BringBackMadDog wrote:
perfectionist wrote:Did Montagna play? Easily the most overrated player in the AFL.
Please stop posting, you are sounding more and more ridiculous very minute. Have you been drinking? Are you high? so far you have us sending Gilbert to the Suns and now you have Monty as overrated. FFS Shut the Hell UP!!
Abuse is such a strong argument. You need to think more and yell less.

I need to think more FFS take a look at the crap you're posting.

3rd generation saint · Sat 02 Oct 2010 7:43pm

Wouldn't put Dawson in our worse, he actually beat Cloke on the day so he did his job, one of our if any winners.

BringBackMadDog · Sat 02 Oct 2010 7:47pm

3rd generation saint wrote:Wouldn't put Dawson in our worse, he actually beat Cloke on the day so he did his job, one of our if any winners.

Yep, thought Zac did his job, in fact I think our defence did extremely well considering the amount of time the ball was locked in our defensive half. Gilbo, Blake, Zac, Chips and Jimmy battled manfully. Our midfield and half forward line were destroyed

SainterK · Post: # 1007080Post **SainterK** » Sat 02 Oct 2010 7:48pm

BringBackMadDog wrote:
3rd generation saint wrote:Wouldn't put Dawson in our worse, he actually beat Cloke on the day so he did his job, one of our if any winners.
Yep, thought Zac did his job, in fact I think our defence did extremely well considering the amount of time the ball was locked in our defensive half. Gilbo, Blake, Zac, Chips and Jimmy battled manfully. Our midfield and half forward line were destroyed

+1, our defence did amazingly well given the game was played up there so much.

widereceiver · Sat 02 Oct 2010 7:48pm

perfectionist wrote:Did Montagna play? Easily the most overrated player in the AFL.

+1
Cannot kick the ball. All Australian? Not for mine.

Dawson won his spot and Gram was clearly playing injured (again) and then concussed.

I don't know why they didn't play Milne in the midfield which is where we were losing it, the ball hardly got to him, so find it hard to be critical.

Enrico_Misso · Sat 02 Oct 2010 7:54pm

Montagna has had a fabulous season.
He was very good last week.

Agree he had a shocker today but don't denigrate his whole season.

RodKeoghsLoveChild · Sat 02 Oct 2010 7:55pm

Dal Santo?? Are you f****** kidding me??

Did this bloke actually hit a target...

Lazy outside player...

perfectionist · Sat 02 Oct 2010 8:02pm

Enrico_Misso wrote:Montagna has had a fabulous season.
He was very good last week.

Agree he had a shocker today but don't denigrate his whole season.

His game last week was poor. He wasn't in the top 10 as nominated by Saintsational members, and yet he is supposed to be a "gun". He has never played a good finals match. Games against the bottom eight count little in my book. He is nowhere near the class of Lenny Hayes or Brendon Goddard.

Enrico_Misso · Sat 02 Oct 2010 8:03pm

perfectionist wrote:
Enrico_Misso wrote:Montagna has had a fabulous season.
He was very good last week.

Agree he had a shocker today but don't denigrate his whole season.
His game last week was poor. He wasn't in the top 10 as nominated by Saintsational members, and yet he is supposed to be a "gun". He has never played a good finals match. Games against the bottom eight count little in my book. He is nowhere near the class of Lenny Hayes or Brendon Goddard.

Monty had 11 tackles last week !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

stmac35 · Post: # 1007316Post **stmac35** » Sat 02 Oct 2010 8:55pm

Eddy ect. dont deserve a premiership medal

The guy broke his arm... cut him a little slack there...

VietNam_Saint · Sun 03 Oct 2010 7:34am

I reckon Fish did a pretty good job of it

Best and Worst

Best and Worst

Re: Best and Worst

Re: Best and Worst