Henderson to Geelong for next years round 1 pick...got to admire Cats for how they get things done. Um, are you serious? Henderson is an absolute spud. Have you watched any of his games this year or asked any Carlton supporters? Carlton have won that big time. Geelong paid way overs, time will prov...

I'd be very happy to have younger Weller at the club

Further to my earlier post, I am confident that whoever goes at pick 5 will be a better player than Carlisle. Mathieson sounds like a taller version of Joel Sellwood. Francis sounds like BJ 2.0 and Parish sounds like an elite line breaking mid with skills. I see JC as a possible bonus if we can get...

Thread revival, On another note, why does St.Kilda not follow Hawthorns path when it comes to players. Key player in mind is Taylor Duryea. That guy was BOG against the Dockers and was the reason they got to the MCG in the first place. This is a guy that was... 1. Drafted in 2008 2. Drafted at pick ...

7 News has reported that carlton has cooled on carlisle as they look to the draft more then trade ( not to mention bolton isn't keen on the money over long period that carlisle is looking for) Carlton offering: 500k for 3 years St kilda offering:700k for 5 years we are now in the box seat so I ask ...

G-Train

Top 10 - 2012 Jobe Watson - 551 Dyson Heppell - 310 Dustin Fletcher - 256 Brent Stanton - 240 Ben Howlett - 232 David Zaharakis - 214 Courtenay Dempsey - 208 Stewart Crameri - 198 Patrick Ryder - 195 Michael Hurley - 177 Top 10 - 2013 Brendon Goddard - 431 Jobe Watson - 382 Dyson Heppell - 336 Mich...

Of all those you mentioned as people you would delist before every one of them in the last two years have played more AFL then all of the delistings ... Geary is one of the first picked Every week Gilbert when fit is one of our most reliable defenders and is now becoming versatile around the ground...

Strange de-listings... I would of kept Sipposs over Saad. Lets face it, he won't make it unless he finds his form when he first stated his AFL career. I would of also kept Markworth over Shenton. I also don't rate Minchinton at all. I'm 50/50 with Geary, his puts in 100% every time, but turnover mer...

I read a post on here last week that if we trade Billings for Carlisle St Kilda should fold....I agree that if we did this trade then we should fold. Now I'm hearing Newnes for Carlisle. I'll say it right now. If St Kilda trade Newnes for Carlisle then St Kilda may as well fold. But you are happy t...

Hickey > Longer

Ross needs to stay

I won't loose too much sleep over Geary + Gilbo

And I'll burn the club down if they offload Newnes...

Honestly don't care about Carlisle, Aish is OK but hasn't shown anything to make me go wow...

Teflon wrote:nothing a jab cant fix....

For the next 10 years?

I'd spit it if we traded our first round pick on the bloke.

Essendon **** us over with Lovett, we need to stand strong... we are in the better position.

Doesn't Carlisle have a degenerative back condition ???

I'll spew if we get either, or both of Carlisle & Bennell. Stick to the draft Saints... we don't need either, we are not in contention for the flag for next year. Its not the 'missing' part we need - like it was with the Lovett situation. Do not give up pick 5 saints. Pick up a midfielder, we se...

Not sure about this to be honest

Hasn't set the world alight and I never get when midfielders from the VFL never actually play midfield in the AFL, and take a spot on a forward flank :/

Good on Lenny. Guys, any of our players, would need to choose different clubs to join and learn from first. He isn't able to offer any other ideas and thoughts, because he's only ever learnt from the one club. He and Harvey need to learn as much as they can from different clubs/roles, and then one d...

How would the Blues get pick 2 for Kruzer?

I don't get it, Pick 2?
He's barely played the last 3 or 4 years... seems like Dal Santo at pick #25 or whatever we got, was crap.

Booing because you were upset with Goodes on Saturday night over a certain decision or some acting doesn't mean you are even slightly racist. Booing from the start to the end of the game for no apparent reason either means you are racist or have no compassion for another human as people were asked ...

I'd keep him, he has terrific overhead marks, and is versatile.

Meh, not that I'm an expert but I'd... Delist Michington - Trade Murdoch - Trade Geary - Trade, turns the ball over too much Shenton - Trade Saad Pierce Schneider Keep Markworth - 1 more year Sipposs - 1 more year Lee - 1 more year Simpkin - 1 more year White - 1 more year Ray - 2 more years, still ...

Booing does not mean your are a racist. Booing indicates a form of displeasure. There's multiple reasons why people can be annoyed/upset/angry about another. This can be from actions the player has taken, from past and present, among other things. Grouping everyone who boos into one big, you're all ...

I hope a shitload goes to the VAFA.

I'd like to see proper umpires, especially in the reserves.
Some of the facilities are very poor and outdated

I think the AFL is fine, but its got to look after the every day person that plays the game as well, there's not enough done.

Suprised Markworth didn't get selected, seems in good form to me, give the kid a go for crying out loud.

I think Ray is fine to be honest. I think he's a pretty good player, and still has plenty to offer.

I'm more concerned with Geary, constantly turns the ball over.

I'd rather trade Longer than Hickey.

Honestly, Longer is so slow, watching today was very eh.... its not just his running, its when he gets the ball, there's no quick handball, everything is slow motion.