100% easily Geelong.

I hate Scarlett + Mooney + Johnson with a passion.

Richmond supporters are the worst of the lot in terms of supporter behavior/crowd. They simple boo every free kick paid against them, even when it is clearly there. They are a massive joke.

I'm thinking more and more that we should cut all ties with this Carlisle piece of filth. The embarassment he will cause to our club is far greater than any financial loss. Though you would hope there must be escape clauses in his contract that allow us to exit with reduced financial damage for his...

We wouldn't go for J.Simpkin as he doesn't fit our age bracket. He could however be a good fit for someone aiming to finish top four, like North, Freo, WC etc. Sad about T.Simpkin, full respect for that guy, was one tough nut. Alan just never seemed to play him which was disappointing. I really like...

Darren Minchington?????? Incredibly annoyed if delisted him very handy player and will be in our best 26 in years to come also question over: nathan wright,murdoch,lee,curren,delaney delaney lee and curren strong depth lee could be handy wright and murdoch are als very handy Don't see Minchington t...

Dempster is a legend.

Went from fringe to AA. He's committed, gives 150% every game, and just gets the job done and an absolute legend.

Carlisle is nothing compared to Dempster and has a lot of work to do to gain the same status.

So if heppel nominated the saints when he iis out of contract we don't look at it? Cmon Yes, I don't give a rats whoever it is, good or not. I don't want to ever deal with Essendon again. Enough is enough, that was two first round draft picks, the first time we got bent over, and its 50-50 for the ...

Its like KB said, you drink and drive you're fired, if you take drugs, its "oh you'd be surprised how many do it" like its normal.... until s*** goes wrong and that wanker causes a head on crash killing two innocent people travelling in the other direction. Luke Hodge, Matt Janesch, Jeff ...

Brayshawa not soft ill give em that but dawes, watts, petracca etc are ans will never change. Hence why we pummel them easily. We were, in a rebuilding phase, the NUMBER 1 contested efforts team!!?!? Thats amazing. And exactly whatvyou want to build a flag team on. Get excited forget the media BS. ...

bigred wrote:Someone that can kick.

This.

Everyone becomes experts at draft time. I hope the club looks for a gun midfielder. We stupidly lost #5 which would of landed us a very good player. Anything after 10+ is not the same. Its more luck.

I'm more worried about his knee The drug stuff is everywhere in society Big whoops. You'd be surprised if you heard the millions of stories about people doing stuff that's not socially acceptable You'd be surprised about who does what at your place of employment Some people have some serious blinke...

Jaxon, we getting Weller or what?
Please be true so I can at least feel somewhat happy after the Carlisle crap.

Needs to come out and make a statement asap. If he kneiw this was floating around and didn't tell us then he's an asshole. This will probably blow over pretty quickly esp if he says its a prank but its a bad start. bratty has posted that he has "flatly denied" through his manager of takin...

eh.. @Brian_Speaking says "Just heard from a close source Carlisle may have the shortest career at St Kilda ever." FML.... I knew Carlisle came with issues, ffs better not be true believe that guy at your peril It angers me that these f'wits get paid mega bucks and find the need to take d...

eh..

@Brian_Speaking says "Just heard from a close source Carlisle may have the shortest career at St Kilda ever."

FML.... I knew Carlisle came with issues, ffs better not be true

Hate to admit it but the cheats have done very well. Traded out two possibly ineligible players and now have picks 4, 5, 23, 24, 25 in the draft. Five in the top 25. Swans now have 24 and 25. Essendon have 4, 5, and 23. Saints 14 and 44. Why would Sydney.... Give St.Kilda Pick 14. Give Essendon a P...

I want Weller 100x's over Carlisle its not funny.

Do It Do It

Here you go, here's another theory.. Sydney's first-round pick has become the latest bargaining chip in negotiations between Essendon and St Kilda over Jake Carlisle. The Swans would be prepared to help the deadlock if it would allow the club to turn their No. 14 pick (worth 1161 points on the draf...

Why next years and not this years?

I don't feel comfortable trading future picks, lets say the club finishes last.

The only hope supporters get is getting new talent through the draft, but trading that away the year before leaves that year pretty meh

:/

Ok so 5 and 63 for Carlisle, 23 and 25. Feasible but ridiculously the hardest to believe. 23 and 24 to GWS for 8. Also feasible and I learnt tonight they need the academy points. They must fear that Hopper will go at pick 3 and they are trying to keep 27 or that Carlton will take a crack at him. 23...

Carlisle can come via the PSD, and we keep our Pick #5. Dodoro will look like a fool. All Carlisle needs to do is state "I don't want to play for anyone but st.kilda". There will be clubs that will say they would take him, but they won't, just like what happened to Luke Ball. The end. Ess...

Don't cave in Saints! Hawks won't match the $$$ offered by us. Boy, I'd rather do what the Hawks do, and have a "team" on even cash for the top players, not one or two on the highest dollar. I don't think Carlisle is that kind of person tbh. I think he's always been chasing the cash, which...

Carlisle can come via the PSD, and we keep our Pick #5. Dodoro will look like a fool. All Carlisle needs to do is state "I don't want to play for anyone but st.kilda". There will be clubs that will say they would take him, but they won't, just like what happened to Luke Ball. The end. Esse...

Don't care.
I'd rather get Weller's brother.

We are desperate for midfielders.

I have no idea why we want to trade Hickey, he is 10x's better than Longer.

Oh and Collingwood can GTFO from Acres.

They can take Saad, as much as I like the guy, I don't think he'll regain that form, happy to be proven wrong, but I'd rather have Markworth on the rookie list.

FWIW, I don't think out list is remotely close to being a premiership list. Still a lot of building to do. It gets tempting to recruit dudes at this time of year, but we still need another good year at the National Draft or two. Well lets see if we have premiership list. See how many player names y...