What does it matter, seeing its not us nothing will happen.

What about silly Sam, firstly picking WC to win tonight, and then when he realised the game is a TD he changed his pick. Has any one told him we beat them in WA already?

I also noticed Sam made no comment on the decision, usually he has an opinion on everything.

I tend to agree Joff, and I will be doing the same, should the club not exhaust all avenues to right this wrong. We must be the laughing stock for the rest of the competition...there they go again bending over, sticking it to their members. The most contriversal tribunal case all year.........dimwit...

Is there a way other cheer squads would assist with their banners being directed at the injustice this verdict is?

Will wait and see how the club is going to handle it, if once again they are going to bend over and again let their members down, i will cross over to the BLue and White.

GO MELBOURNE VICTORY

We really now need to back our club with this one.

I think the Saint's QC is trying to bore the tribunal into submission.

G-Train09 wrote:fev 4 kosi?

No bloody way!!!!!!!!!!1

I am starting to get very nervous.... I am really hoping that the longer it takes the better the result will be... Dont be, Rb is there i can see this going further if we fail, this will be his time to stand up :wink: Hopefully you are right saintsrus, and the emails we sent to the club will be hee...

Really what have they got to offer?

Saints still haven't finished giving their arguments. A little worried though, if we have gone in trying to use the argument Baker told the truth. Thats what convicted him in the first place. The onlything that will make them take notice is if it goes to a real court where standards are generally m...

Saints still haven't finished giving their arguments. A little worried though, if we have gone in trying to use the argument Baker told the truth.

Thats what convicted him in the first place.

aussiejones wrote:"what Gia did wouldnt be allowed this year "

That would be right f$#@#ed both ways !

Apparently the AFL changed the rule this year due to the above incident. Therefore, why wasn't Whelan's block on Ball, causing sever head problems to Ball, found to be reckless and rough play.

n1ck wrote:I read that our QC was looking at bringing in evidence from the Kosi / Gia clash to support Bakes...

He can try, but it will not be allowed. For reason only the AFL understand no new evidence is permitted.

cowboy18 wrote:

Perhaps he's moved on and wants to do more positive things.

Looking at him in the Toyota add he looks like he is doing a lot of positive eating.

A trip to the Big Man Clothing Store wouldn't be a waste of time either.

doggerel wrote:On the strength of that letter you would have to give Farmer the Class Act of the Week award. Top stuff.

Probably worried about the next time they meet, should Bakes cop 7 weeks.

Freo put him up to it and I will bet my left one that they new it could not be used.

mcadam05 wrote:

Behind Play wrote:Problem is, it cannot be used tonight..........wonder if Freo new this.

it is for tonight

According to Moron, it is not admissible at the appeal. Only evidence which was brought up last Tuesday can be used at an appeal.

Problem is, it cannot be used tonight..........wonder if Freo new this.

Can any one tell me if any one from the AFL made a statement, especially Andrew..........he seems to always have an opinion.

Haven't heard a thing all day.

Stephen Theodore wrote:Dan Warna wrote:
he has avoided st kilda functions, even those honoring him.

But Why ?

Because he is a selfish toss. Thank good they got the pig off the ground when they did, Plugger was salivating.

Have any of the AFL hierarchie made any statements yet? Would be very interested in hearing their spin on this.

It really is times like this you need a president like eddie........would the filth let them get away with it.

The Giansiracusa incident may have been within the 5 meter perameter, and i am certain that Giansiracusa did not deliberately mean to fracture Kosi's skull.....just as Bakes did not mean to break Farmer's nose, but why wasn't Gian. charged with a reckless act. His block caused Kosi and sever injury....

I have been thinking and reading about tonights decision by the tribunal on one of ours again. I have decided that if the St Kilda football club lays down and does nothing on this occasion, as they have previously, it is time for me after 40+ years to give the club and the game away. I really cannot...

Hope the club grows some balls and fights this all the way. This is garbage.