ahh, given we clearly can't afford to have Baker, Blake, Max and Zac in the same backline, Max and Zac play the same position, Max came in for Gilbert and the coach mentioned our problem was movement of the ball from defence are we not all skirting around the obvious here?

Stanley is incredible. Covers the ground like Ryder but as raw as can be. Picture the polar opposite of McEvoy. They should make a great combo for 10 years. On McEvoy, I saw him pull up lame just before 3/4 time. Did he come back on in the last quarter? I am interested because I heard Lyon say King ...

Did Fergo or X play? How did Howard do? Edit: looking at the VFL sportingpulse results page the following played: L Fisher Raph Howard Birss Milne Rix Fiora Haretuku (first senior VFL game?) Steven Miles any thoughts about the above? Interested to see how Miles looks... ok you may want to ask the g...

how many kicks did he get? 6 (4 free kicks) how many handballs? 2 how many tackles? 0 how mnay 1%ers? at a guess, 0. what did Ross want him to achieve? To be tagged out of the game by a 5 foot 6 fatty? did he achieve this? You bet! Mate, nobody is doubting his talent but did you see him today? It w...

how many kicks did he get? 6 (4 free kicks) how many handballs? 2 how many tackles? 0 how mnay 1%ers? at a guess, 0. what did Ross want him to achieve? To be tagged out of the game by a 5 foot 6 fatty? did he achieve this? You bet! Mate, nobody is doubting his talent but did you see him today? It w...

how many kicks did he get? 6 (4 free kicks) how many handballs? 2 how many tackles? 0 how mnay 1%ers? at a guess, 0. what did Ross want him to achieve? To be tagged out of the game by a 5 foot 6 fatty? did he achieve this? You bet! Mate, nobody is doubting his talent but did you see him today? It wa...

Dal hardly sighted Looks like a few more weeks playing reserves football then Most of the senior boys there, saw Rock & Drain but didn't see Lyon. Went to the Carlton game, otherwise he wont get a chance to see the Blues play live until we play them, due to them playing next week Sat afternoon ...

But really how good was the list that [Ross Lyon] was given? Good enough for 14 wins with a dud coach. It can't have been that awful. Great answer. Explain that. Also we had as many injuries as last year and 3 times the amount of this year, And did you really think thay about Dal, Kosi, X and Gammy...

saintsrokk wrote:Anybody know scorps best players and goal kickers?

Casey Scorpions
Goal Kickers: C. Gardiner 2, M. Rix, S. Garrubba, J. Gwilt, J. Wall, D. Armitage, B. Howard, K. Matthews, A. Silvagni
Best Players: J. Gwilt, D. Armitage, K. Matthews, M. Rix, S. Garrubba, B. Howard

I thought I had quite succintly, dodgy What does Drain do? What does he bring to the table? What is he accountable for? Only one poster has attempted to answer these. Have a peak at this champ: http://www.realfooty.com.au/news/news/unsung-often-unknown-coachs-righthand-man-is-a-key-player/2007/09/0...

I thought I had quite succintly, dodgy What does Drain do? What does he bring to the table? What is he accountable for? Only one poster has attempted to answer these. Have a peak at this champ: http://www.realfooty.com.au/news/news/unsung-often-unknown-coachs-righthand-man-is-a-key-player/2007/09/0...

I think we should sack 1 person at random from the club after every loss just to appease the angry people on this forum. That will get everyone on their toes. Further, we should sack RL and replace him with Genghis Khan. Now there was a hard task master. Seriously though, injury management has clear...

5-Ball 4-Hayes 3-Blake 2-Harvey 1-Gardiner Can you give negative votes to Milne and Dempster? Milne cost us 3-4 goals and was still jumping out the way in the last few minutes when we had a chance. Dempster was either getting murdered or murdering the ball all night. Schneider would also fit into th...

Point is......with 6 picks in the top 50 of the SUPERDRAFT.....wasn't difficult...have a look at how the hawks went, cats went, eagles went... For every good selection - I can find a bad one.....same at every club.....there are NO geniuses... Well the Hawks took Elstone at #20, Ladson at #16. WCE t...

In round 7, 2006 against Geelong in front of a near full house at the Telstra Dome, Harvey broke the all-time games record for the St Kilda Football Club (set by Nathan Burke) with 324 games. To celebrate this, the Saints wore special guernseys with Harvey's sillouhetted image in the centre. Unfortu...

1989 v Carlton at Moorabbin. Plugger booted 10 and we won by 4 points from memory. Banger played that day too. Couldn't agree more. Plugger kicked 10 on Silvagni, was our second win from 2, we slipped behind with a few minutes to go and Jason Daniels cleared a 30 meter handball to Winmar who someho...

Just had a look at our 2006 results because I thought I was going crazy and had a bad perception of us back then with the comments from GT and others on this forum and in the press. We played 11 times against other finals teams for 3 wins and 8 losses. We beat the Doggies (who finished 7th and we al...

[It depends on what you class a good game if getting cheep kicks in the backline and basically staying away from the contest, giving half efforts and wimpy tackles , being flat footed at almost every stoppage and then butchering the ball every time you kick it then yeah grammy had a blinder Rolling ...

Port beat us by about 10 goals over there in the wet last year didn't they? I have been trying to repress the memory for 12 months now.

"tbh i think armitages early form reminds me a bit of caydn beethams early form. big build, strong, beautiful kick of the ball. another player he reminds me a bit of goddard when he first came to st kilda, although armitage looks much stockier." Comparing him to Beetham is frigging harsh. ...

[raph has shown a fair bit of talent, its just injury and discipline he needs now.] Raph was the most talented 15 year old you will ever see but playing Under 18 championships for 4 years was not too good for him. He became lazy and developed some shocking habits. This coupled with injury issues ser...

can you guys talk me through Geary, I didn't see much of Springvale but he was considered something of a steal in the rookie draft. Also, I wouldn't be too concerned about Armitage. Inside mids who rely on tackling and contested footy always take longer to emerge than outside guys who can get by wit...