It IS only a fantasy

Judging from the levels of hatred directed toward the Catters on here, I have the feeling that this scenario may be enjoyed: 2007: The Cats defeat Port Adelaide by four goals this Saturday and are crowned premiers after 44 years of hunger. 2008: After a tough season in which only percentage separate...

saint58 and Rodger. If you go back to 04 and judge the season AS A WHOLE then Chapman was not all that far off. The Cats beat Saint Kilda at Skilled Stadium. Geelong finished in the top four (just ONE win behind the Saints) and, like the Saints, narrowly missed out in the PF. You can argue with me.....

Rodger..calm down!!! No need for the abuse my friend. You disagree with me..fine. Just cut out the personal stuff eh?

Rodger and N1ck You can dress it up any way you like but Paul Chapman has been proved right ultimately. Their list has taken them to the verge of a flag, and they will win it, nothing surer. BTW if you tell me you would not have Chapman in the saints side, then you are not being honest the guy is a ...

P Chapmans words about having a better list have proved to be true. The cats are a great team this year and deserve to be where they are though this forum seems the wrong place to be pumping thier tyres up jigger!
you cant be that generous?

The lack of a premiership (in spite of mega bucks spent on football dept.) at Collingwood coupled with the sight of North Melbourne contesting a prelim this week (on the back of the worst facilities in the comp!) Bring into question the simplistic(?) arguments of Messrs. Westaway and Burke at "...