I didn’t notice any apparent Sydney bias in his commentary.

Thought he was actually getting excited by our comeback.

Big Clubs don't lose good players to small clubs Even if we gave them 2 top ten draft picks this year ( assuming Battle goes and that we get massive compo for him) plus next year's 1st rounder...they still wouldn't do it So how did get we get Hamill from Carlton? It’s not about us being a small clu...

Why do so many instantly play the victim card as soon as some criticism is pointed our way? We're 15th!!! The competition is as even as I can remember Last year was similar to this year in that after Rd 16 ... 15 sides had % above 92 We have played 15 games and have lost 6 games under 10pts and won...

What this thread proves to me is that you can recruit players despite seemingly being in a worse onfield position. Yes...As long as the recruiting manager isn't overruled...and as long as the talent scout manager isn't overruled by Silvagni or Lyon I still wish Finnis had had the nuts to overrule T...

Okay, fair point. But of the four you mentioned, three are from our last three draft years. Before that - Cripps, Billings, Dunstan, Acres, McCartin, Goddard, Gresham, Long and Coffield.

We need to execute all reasonable endeavours we can to keep Battle. Letting him go and hoping for a good compo pick is just another Goddard or Dal Santo situation waiting to happen. He’s a fierce competitor and one of few on our list who actually gives me the impression that he has that fire in the ...

I admire your passion and I mean that with all sincerity. I wish I had it.

Obviously, I’m incredibly resentful about what our club has been allowed to become. But, no use rinsing and repeating.

Great post Jigster!

While I haven’t been as a big a King basher this season as some, I certainly don’t think he’s now absolved for all criticism.

His form this season has been mediocre at best.

This injury may explain his poor output last match, but it doesn’t explain a seasons worth.

Thread closed due to stupidity Truth hurts Teflon. Are Port such a good team that it’s realistic that we haven’t beaten them at our dungheap since 2010 and in Adelaide since 2011 (unless the count the fake COVID season). Why is it that their players, despite no Dixon or Pepper to name a few, can ra...

Thread closed due to stupidity Truth hurts Teflon. Are Port such a good team that it’s realistic that we haven’t beaten them at our dungheap since 2010 and in Adelaide since 2011 (unless the count the fake COVID season). Why is it that their players, despite no Dixon or Pepper to name a few, can ra...

He will definitely leave You have it on good authority? Of course he’ll leave. He’s been committed through two failed rebuilds and now we’re beginning another. He’s being courted by teams with a future, so why wouldn’t he leave. So Saints have no future? Not during his career they don’t.

I thought we beat them in the COVID year under Ratten in Adelaide? Correct. The only win against them since 2012. It was at the Adelaide Oval and none of us in Victoria could attend because we were all lockdown at the time. Shortened quarters and we were playing in an interstate hub. Not a real sea...

Devilhead wrote: ↑Sun 30 Jun 2024 6:27pm

B.M wrote: ↑Sun 30 Jun 2024 6:25pm He will definitely leave

You have it on good authority?

Of course he’ll leave. He’s been committed through two failed rebuilds and now we’re beginning another.

He’s being courted by teams with a future, so why wouldn’t he leave.

The Fireman wrote: ↑Sun 30 Jun 2024 7:13pm Every loss we have against them is one game closer to a win

Loser talk.

Yeah yeah, stand by your ideology of supporting mediocrity without question.

Watch Hinkley in tears after that win. If anyone was going to save his career, it was us.

Relish in irrelevance if that makes you feel like a “true supporter.”

We’re ultimately to blame for how depressingly ordinary this club has become. The years of tolerating sheer mediocrity - Richo, Finnis and Lethlean, re-signing Ratten and then doubling-down by bringing in Ross Lyon. The fans tolerate it and laud it, because at least these administrators are apparent...

Steele is definitely not enjoying his footy at the club

Yeah, let’s let our second best defender walk.

A first round compo pick? We have such a great track record with first round picks of the last decade. We can nab the next Tom Lee

Interesting thing about Hinkley is that unless you count the COVID “stop-gap” season, he’s yet to suffer a loss against us.

If Barrett is correct and he’s a goner for 2025, this could be our last chance to beat him.

Isn’t one of the common reasons for asking for a trade is to get more opportunities? Another is to move interstate Commonly, yes. But, I know in my field of work (plus any others) there are those who every 6 to 12 months are always on the lookout for a new job - whether it be opportunity, they’re b...

The wrong question is Would you like to relocate or merge? Because the unanimous answer would be no The correct question - for Fitzroy and South Would you rather merge/relocate or cease to exist? I’ll tell you two things South were never going to become the juggernaut that Sydney became And Fitzroy...

If the Saints merge or relocate I'm out. Me too mate, but it ain't going to happen and the OP has been exposed as a f****** troll. :twisted: No, just a supporter who isn’t afraid to say that club has had decades of poor management and that I’m skeptical the club can recover. We have yet to recover ...

If the Saints merge or relocate I'm out. Me too mate, but it ain't going to happen and the OP has been exposed as a f****** troll. :twisted: No, just a supporter who isn’t afraid to say that club has had decades of poor management and that I’m skeptical the club can recover. We have yet to recover ...

I would think that you should keep your shitty Sydney comments in the equally shitty Harbour city. The brions played off for the cup last year and if it wasn't for a cheating maggot and his laughable 50 metre penalty , we may well have won last night. Grow up. Are we incapable of debating this at a...

You all need to take a chill pill.

Either ban me for suggesting what you're clearly incapable of hearing, or be an adult and discuss like an adult.