by far the worst disposal ???????? I think you will find when it comes to brain fade clangers one Jason Blake takes some tossing . Certainly i wouldnt class max as worse than him. And thats not taking anything away from Blake because he is an honest trier who gives his all . Whilst i agree that Bla...

what kind of fuckwitting twat would start such a thread as this? You monkey... I won't repeat what everyone else said about how good Max is as a footballer, because it would be adding nothing. But another thought: Zac Dawson has been good compared to what we expected of him. If you look closely at ...

And still the best thing he did all night was his sublime blind turn, side step and goal off a spillage. The kid has got skills but has sacrificed his game for the good of the team. Hopefully all ofhis skills and flair doesn't get coached out of him. I think if you look at some players, making them...

mini's game on saturday night could be close to his best for the club. he was playing for his spot, which is great to see. i have always been a little skeptical of whether he can cut it at this level, but his performance on the w/e suggests he can. he's at the bottom of every pack, and is a tackling...

i disagree with 90% of whats been said. I am a culprit of this negativity, and its got nothing to do with my life outside footy, my job, or my self esteem. What a joke I love the saints as much as anyone, but i hate losing, and even more than that, i hate mediocre performances. I understand the nee...

on a personal level, i'm ridiculously optimistic about the team - the way only a one-eyed supporter can be. at qtr time i even said to those i was with "if they can get that far up in one qtr, we can make up the difference in one qtr". i am all for the players to have a positive outlook an...

i disagree with 90% of whats been said. I am a culprit of this negativity, and its got nothing to do with my life outside footy, my job, or my self esteem. What a joke I love the saints as much as anyone, but i hate losing, and even more than that, i hate mediocre performances. I understand the need...

Centre. Half. Back. too slow.....football smarts are lacking IMHO.... would get turned inside out.....lacks agility etc football smarts are lacking? did you notice how many times he centred the ball instead of mucking around with it around the 50. or how many times he kicked long, forward of his te...

Koswell played the perfect game last night. his first quarter ordinary..... did no touch it....oppenent ran off many times. is slow..... showed glimpses but a perfect game NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO agree with original post showed glimpses?!?!? he SINGLE HANDEDLY brought us back into the game in the second q...

BIggest disappointment for me in selection is that X. Clarke is yet again missing. Why? What's wrong with him now? he isn't up to it is what's wrong with him. i assume he's injured (as always) but even if he's fit, cast your mind back to his performance in the qualifying final against the cats last...

i thought of the three other youngsters mentioned that Simpkin looked the best of them.

My thoughts. Most of the players didn't impress me to be honest Goose looks a step behind play and most of the others didn't get a lot of it. Raph looked a cut above but occasionally took too long making decisions. Lynch was the best performed St Kilda player for mine... he ran to the right places ...

saintDal wrote:I don't suppose someone could PM me what this is all about?

and me too??

Who is the potential tall that we are going to pick up in place of Kosi, no-one is answering that? exactly right, trade kosi for what? until a reasonable suggestion is made as to what could possibly be a worthy trade, its all just rubbish.... that being said, its rubbish anyway. he shouldnt be trad...

Steph, the problem with Eddy and the marking contest, but the guy who kicked so high and slow and Eddy had to stand under it. Eddy did nothing wrong, he didn't pull out of the contest, what more was he to do. jump off one foot for a start. he looked like a cheerleader jumping off both feet, arms to...

lenny is a star, invaluable member of our team, however if we are to be objective about him, the thing that sets him apart from the elite mids of the competition IS his disposal and that he doesnt kick enough goals this rubbish of "could you do better?" is just childish and ridiculous. the...

As for your comments suggesting i one of those calling for BJ to carlton and Lenny too slow, thats just ill informed and insulting and i wont bother justifying myself. lol, missed the point I meant, ppl have a tendency to expect too much from kids and write them off quickly BJ, Hudghton and Hayes (...

lol Eddy and Mini are just kids and have been promising all year... stupid to write them off Fiora is a different kettle of fish... I think RL has given him quite a few chances this year because a) he's a senior player b) he works his butt off I'm hoping that it's nice try not good enough for him (...

Great analysis, agree with most and very refreshing to see someone not wanting to trade half the list However: I think you've been harsh on Montagna, for mine he's been our second best mid this yr behind Lenny Also, too harsh on Gilbert, I admit he needs to work on his disposal, but is going to be a...

and he'd duck his head as he was flying through the air

Eddy, Mini and Fiora Unfortunately, we can't win preliminary finals, with these 3 in the team Regarding Mini and Eddy, the kids bust their guts, they run hard, they follow instructions and give it their all. But at the end of the day, they just aren't up to it. The hawks and the cats don't have play...

JeffDunne wrote:http://www.afl.com.au/News/NEWSARTICLE/ ... wsId=67936

ST KILDA
Nick Riewoldt (captain)
Luke Ball
Sam Fisher
Jason Gram
Lenny Hayes

Personally I think Harv's should be given an invite out of respect.

aren't all previous winners automatically invited?

Who for Nick and Kosi???? Croad obviously will have one of them........who is the other....Murphy???......Birchall???........Campbell Brown??? For their guys we have Max 191 Sam 192 Blake 191 Gilbert 194 even BJ at 191 to take their turn on Buddy 196 and Roughie 193 Brown has been named forward i t...

Out of the paper..... about Dal Santo has finished in the top five of St Kilda's B&F four years in a row highlighting his consistency despite being just 24 years of age. He is one of the competition's best inside midfielders. In the past three seasons Dal Santo has averaged 22 disposals per gam...

ozrulestrace wrote:How about one toddler and a new baby and coaching pressures which means he's buggered.
The hat didn't help either.

he's got 3 kids..