That reasonable offer might just be pick 9 alone.

Pick 9 alone for Judd, surely you jest??

They will want a damn sight more than that!

No thanks, totally unreliable and a bit of headcase IMO....

No chance what so ever....we won't give up enough to meet what WCE would want If they play too hard ball, however, don't they run the risk of him ending up in the PSD (see Port Adelaide and Nick Stevens) and they end up with nothing for him. I doubt it, they can get plenty for him, particularly fro...

Neither are a big loss, especially Raymond....

No chance what so ever....we won't give up enough to meet what WCE would want

morrabin

I think you mean moorabbin

And there is no chance Judd will be at st kilda next year....

Threatening employees in the carpark is not a good look....

Caro just loves this board turmoil stuff doesn't she?

She's such a rumor monger.....

Can't happen quick enough and hope that the club can finially move forward as a united force

Agree, its about the only thing I am sure of in this board challenge saga

Can we have a third column: 'undecided'

Personally, I need more time to consider the pros and cons of each group...plus not enough of the details are available yet....but the new ticket looks quite impressive to me

Hawthorn

sasaint wrote:Bring on the spill. Bring on Westaway. If it be done let it be done quickly.

Agreed, quickly and painlessly I hope!

I doubt there will be any changes in coaching staff, with the possible exception of Ken Sheldon if there is board change....seems there are a few unhappy with his performance

Little comfort when your not playing in September! What a strange comment. :? Our total attendances mean little if we arn't playing in September. We don't play footy to get people in the gates, other wise the Power and the Roos have failed this year despite both still being in the running for the f...

Another retirement, Vanders just announced he's had enough:

http://www.news.com.au/heraldsun/story/ ... 88,00.html

Good result, more than i had expected given our year wasn't great

Nice post, agree with virtually every line Jones, Clinton (R) Playa poor game….and then a very good one….but then did his collarbone. On resumption he struggled. Whether he will be retained or not will largely depend on how much weight Ross pays to his pre-broken collarbone game. If retained obv...

We should go all out for him I think, would be in or entering his prime as a ruck and partnered with Gardiner would be an awesome combo....also would allow Kosi to play FF permanently

http://www.realfooty.com.au/news/news/thomas-hits-saints-with-legal-action/2007/09/05/1188783319891.html Nothing about Bedwell being involved. GT is continuing to make trouble. The challenge continues to sound highly credible. It sounds like Butterss is going to have to be dragged out kicking and s...

Otiman wrote:The proposed training facility that was shut down by the kingston council was about the only expenditure outside of regular football expenses.

Speaking of which, what is the latest on the training facility? does anyone know?

Repeated Failure to run out a game . string of lost final quarters. ALSO ...... badly need more goal kicking training / practice . In 2008 minus Gehrig ......who will deliver ? Agree, fitness levels must improve for 08, cost us a finals spot no doubt...I'm sure RL will be making them work very hard...

No profits are not enough. It is only an accounting concept although it is an indicator of the health of the finances of an organisation. However it is not the be all and end all. Enron had massive earnings and huge bottom lines, however it was all done through off book liability hiding, and mark t...

I'm with you Mr X, RB's comments were fine, there was no need to make rash statements of any kind when he was interviewed....was a good decision to let the dust settle and then announce a course of action at a later time....some people clearly dislike RB no matter what he does, I personally think h...

Disagree completely. What he did and said was entirely correct...people always make rash statements or do stupid things in the height of the moment. Better to wait until the following morning when the passion has dissipated, and then re-evaluate the situation. RB would have been coached on that and...

Life Long Saint wrote:Fair call...his action could have ended Bell's career.

Could have paralysed him! Definitely fair call for mine