Marshall has currency, and funnily enough, when Campbell was in the ruck out midfielders seemed more assured. Wouldn’t be the worst idea to cash in if he wants out. There’s an opinion from many that ruckman are the most overrated position. Agreed. If Marshall wants out which I doubt is true and we ...

The_Dud wrote: ↑Thu 20 Jun 2024 11:04am #learntherules

As we've seen they're just rough guidelines.

I’m with The Dud on this. Watching the game, I felt it was going to be a 50 before it was played. He wasn’t in the marking contest and he ran to completely the wrong spot. They might have directed him to run 5m back to the actual spot, but It was open to them to interpret his action as deliberately...

If Norf hadn't blown a 50-point lead, it wouldn't have been a factor. They put themselves in that position. Stuff them. 14-2 FREE KICK count from half time has that effect. OK, so why did the umpires cheat for us against Collingwood? 30/16 frees and the sealer kicked by Higgins was clear cheating b...

ctqs wrote: ↑Wed 19 Jun 2024 3:55pm If Norf hadn't blown a 50-point lead, it wouldn't have been a factor. They put themselves in that position. Stuff them.

14-2 FREE KICK count from half time has that effect.

I’m with The Dud on this. Watching the game, I felt it was going to be a 50 before it was played. He wasn’t in the marking contest and he ran to completely the wrong spot. They might have directed him to run 5m back to the actual spot, but It was open to them to interpret his action as deliberately...

Ok, we get it Curly. - AFL instruct umpires to cheat to ensure Collingwood win. - AFL instruct umpires to cheat against Saints every week. - The AFL is corrupt and had a vendetta against the Saints. How many threads do you have to initiate on the topic? Were the threads titled Umpires & Windhag...

I’m with The Dud on this. Watching the game, I felt it was going to be a 50 before it was played. He wasn’t in the marking contest and he ran to completely the wrong spot. They might have directed him to run 5m back to the actual spot, but It was open to them to interpret his action as deliberately...

I’m with The Dud on this. Watching the game, I felt it was going to be a 50 before it was played. He wasn’t in the marking contest and he ran to completely the wrong spot. They might have directed him to run 5m back to the actual spot, but It was open to them to interpret his action as deliberately...

Ok, we get it Curly. - AFL instruct umpires to cheat to ensure Collingwood win. - AFL instruct umpires to cheat against Saints every week. - The AFL is corrupt and had a vendetta against the Saints. How many threads do you have to initiate on the topic? Were the threads titled Umpires & Windhag...

Clear and blatant 50 and correctly paid, the time of the game should be irrelevant. How many different umpiring threads to you need to start? No it wasnt he didnt enter the protected area he was already in it and stepped back to where he thought the mark was. No interruption in play no warning no c...

Max King gets a late free to kick a goal and StKilda beat Gold Coast. The free yes while being soft is and has to awarded as he was infringed. AFL come out and say while yes he was infringed we prefer that no to be paid. Result StKilda win v an AFL franchise Gold Coast. AFL not happy We now see a cl...

spert wrote: ↑Tue 18 Jun 2024 8:00am Yet another intercepting backline player gets in the votes against- a big issue for Lyon is forward-half defensive work

Sinclair had 32 the most on the ground.

Windhager's problem wasn't that he came through the area. It was because he was about 3m in front of where the ball was marked and only took half a step back which made it pretty obvious he was over the mark. I don't think that is paid every time without a warning but he gave the umpire the option ...

Windhager's problem wasn't that he came through the area. It was because he was about 3m in front of where the ball was marked and only took half a step back which made it pretty obvious he was over the mark. I don't think that is paid every time without a warning but he gave the umpire the option ...

Showed the 50 against Windhager on AFL360 and what a f****** disgrace.

He was in the area and stepped back to take the mark he never ran into the area at all.

It was a blatant error or cheating to gift Brisbane a goal.

Butters suspended but only a week who’d have guessed.

... The 50m penalty against Windhager was the one that was not umpired in the spirit of the game. All night they gave warnings and gave instructions to players to go back 2 metres. That killed our momentum I'm not sure that the 50 against Windhager was because he went over the mark. He came from be...

... The 50m penalty against Windhager was the one that was not umpired in the spirit of the game. All night they gave warnings and gave instructions to players to go back 2 metres. That killed our momentum I'm not sure that the 50 against Windhager was because he went over the mark. He came from be...

The free against Marshall was just poor umpiring. Sebs two kicks were horrendous Jones 50 was another umpire gift Was exactly the same as the one Higgins got in the last. Seb’s possession is just too costly. You seriously aren’t saying Marshall and Higgins frees were identical??🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️ Marshall he...

... The 50m penalty against Windhager was the one that was not umpired in the spirit of the game. All night they gave warnings and gave instructions to players to go back 2 metres. That killed our momentum I'm not sure that the 50 against Windhager was because he went over the mark. He came from be...

Love The Dud to justify it. Clear view no other possible reason not to pay 50 other than bias. Now turn your hearing aids up for this one Curly… ready… the umpires made… a mistake! Believe it or not they do it every game! Maybe the umpire was gun shy due to days of sooks whinging about correct 50m ...

we got stiffed...it happens..it happens to all clubs..look at some of the crucial decisions that buried the Roos today. I get it..we get it...for fear of ruining your apparent life long ambition to totally abolish umpiring maybe you need to relax and have a good rethink on your crusade I've told yo...

Love The Dud to justify it.

Clear view no other possible reason not to pay 50 other than bias.

Yep Windhagers 50 was 💯 correct according to usual umpire apologists on here. Gets paid every time. North player takes a mark 65 out two Collingwood players chase and charge at him at least ten meters over the mark. Umpire nothing to see. It’s diabolically bad the biased and favouritism ti some sides.