Well it is quite obvious that people rate players according to their own idiosyncratic criteria. For example people rate X and Ralph very highly, but in my books they had a shocking season, though X opened the season well, I believed he was very inconsistant overall and Raph just does not have the ...

Saints Premiers 2008 wrote: Huzzad wrote: mizuno wrote: Long time lurker here... But how can Gilbert be an Achiever Plus, what has he done? Perhaps you missed the 18 games he played this year... wow...18 games he has a whole career ahead of him...anything could happen Yep, and if he keeps going lik...

Long time lurker here... But how can Gilbert be an Achiever Plus, what has he done? M Gardiner should be NA, you cant achieve if you don't get out on the park. Id put Milney in the same class as Blake. He does the best with what hes got. Im pretty sure Saints management got rid of all the under achi...