Rix has had his chance IMO.

Surely Xavier is due for a call up to the seniors this weekend. With Milne out with his cheekbone injury, Xavier would definitely be the most likely and suitable candidate for his position. And if the argument of he is still not %100 fit to play comes into discussion, well it's a small forward posit...

Always gets the second biggest man but also plays some attacking defensive football, pretty safe in that backline position i think.

Roo and Fish would have to be certainties IMO. Milne has had a good but inconsistent year and i think Johnson definitely deserves a spot ahead of him.

B: S. Fisher - M. Scarlett - L. Hodge HB: G. Johncock - C. Bolton - T. Harley (VC) C: S. Thompson - S. Mitchell - M. Richardson HF: M. Pavlich - N. Riewoldt (C) - B. Harvey F: S. Johnson - L. Franklin - B. Fevola Foll: D. Cox - G. Ablett Jr - J. Bartel Int: A. Sandilands - S. Black - A. Cooney - J. ...

Leave that to Kosi. MUST be given a game in the two's to see where he is at, to big of a risk first up in the firsts IMO.

Great mark that was made even better due to the circumstances. Lloyd will be hard to beat though.

Pilgram wrote:g'day nathan -- Sgt. here LOL

No Fiora is no forward line player in my mind. A pure wingman and that is it, doesn't have the thinking brain to be a small forward.

Gherig must be given another opportunity if fit enough. Why? Give him a go in the two's and make him perform first. It's the most crucial part of the season and we can't afford for him to come back and play a s*** game. He must prove at Casey that he is fully fit and motivated before given a chance...

Should be included if fit. Some players just don't perform in the VFL because it's a change of speed and other things, he is one of them i would think. Is a good match up for Leon Davis or maybe Scott Pendlebury, can help us alot on the weekend IMO.

Lacks of lot of confidence of late in my opinion. Seems to be afraid to keep running with the flow, stops and props to much. Hopefully seeing as though he had a decent game today he builds off that.

If you have your own made image you'll have to upload it to a photo storage site like http://www.photobucket.com then just get the url code of that and stick it in the avatar link space at the bottom of your profile. If you are just using an pic of google or something just right click the image and ...

5. Gram
4. Goddard
3. Montagna
2. Ball
1. Blake

They did the job against Kangas didn't they. I think Armo and Geary being dropped has been fair as they were low on form. Yet when you have Geary knocking up 40 touches in the two's you have to bring him in. Just like i'd be expecting Armo in this week after a good game for Casey.

And they have all been dropped more then once apart from Eddy, who i think has been great since being included in our firsts. Maybe not drop Milney this week, but if the game is on the line next week and he does nothing once again i would consider it.

We play better against the top teams. Have use doubters not forgot how terrible Collingwood are playing as well. To me they look like a bottom 4 team after watching there last 3 matches. We should beat Collingwood, and if not we don't deserve to secure that top 4 position anyway

It's a suggestion. He has had more then one bad game for the year.

To me Milney was a bit disappointing today. I'd push either X, Bakes or Armo in for Ball. And consider another one of them 3 for Milne.

my guess in: M.gardiner, Hayes, schneider out: mini, eddy, gardiner eddy and mini are stiff and if schneider doesn't work his butt off both along with birss and baker will push for selection in following weeks Close to the best team for awhile. Agree with bigcarl, allen must stay in and continue hi...

I think Judd is the way to go, he has always kept him to low possessions or at least meaningless ones. I could also see him maybe playing on Eddie Betts as he does run with the small forwards fairly well.

i more so ment that xavier can be one of our elite midfielders when he is playing his very best football, thats my thoughts.

xavier has had a lot of bad luck through injury, he is still a very young player and when on song i think he's one of our elite midfielders, he is also good enough to play up forward to which is very valuable for us when milne isn't on song. xavier has alot of courage which seems to of only develope...

would be great to see them both get nom'd. armitage would be my preferance, he's tough young player and thats what the judges like to see e.g selwood. my pick for the award would go to kreuzer, i see him playing most games and that raps on him are huge.

i didn't watch or hear the game so this post is helpful, thanks. kosi is a huge key this year, he needs to just be stuck at full forward and he will have a great year and will hopefully help us lift that extra notch we need.