It is a bit early, but I imagine comparisions with Geelong will be drawn with respect to their game with "OUTS" against Brisbane. If we win this one, the next three will be relatively easy. The only question in my mind is: Can our forwards kick a winning score? Gardiner will play permanen...

We need it to be undecided. Gardiner and Kosi should play down there all day and they along with Gwilt with really stretch the likes of Schoenmakers and Gilham. Our midfield is the thing thats really hurting now. No Lenny and Monty hurts big time and they have the upper hand for sure. Luke needs to ...

I think Riewoldt will play.

OUT: Hudghton, King

IN: Dawson, Gardiner

Thats a sensational article and i'm so glad it has been published. Already Milney has equaled his personal best amount of tackles in a season, he's averaging 2.5 a match and his pressure is immense. He is a big part of the reason for where we are now. Why is he not being considered for All Australia...

We will never make a grand final with this group.....suck it up and accept it once and for all.....it isnt going to happen. At the moment we are a middle of the road team and if we dont make wholesale changes..we will be there for the next 10 years. Schneider? Purleeeese! (reject from Sydney?) M. G...

He looks like he could be a pinch hitter like Goddard, and i think he needs to be capable of doing that as well as i'm not sure he's as valuable in the backline as Gram, Fisher, Raph, Goddard, Dawson, Blake and Max. He is not a big guy so it's not as if we would be too top heavy with him Roo and Kos...

Great to see how Hird rates Riewoldt. That's how he should be rated by everyone.

Ablett (senior)
Carey
Harvey
Voss
Riewoldt
Brown
Judd
Lockett
Dunstall
Hird

IN: King, Schneider.

OUT: McEvoy, Eddy.

I think max will still be another week.

I think it's a good idea to rest a player or two if your in Geelong or St Kilda's situation. Yet only if they are showing signs of tiredness or a mild injury. I wouldn't do what Geelong did against Brisbane, unless they were actual injuries, yet i would allow for two or three players a week to be re...

It is a good thing most of the time. If Luke is around a pack it's not often you see a team break away from that pack very easily.

Not like Luke Ball he doesn't. I never see Judd throw his body in head first into a pack like Luke, i am not calling him a receiver, he does get his own football for sure yet does not recklessly throw himself into packs like Ball.

You will never see Judd throw his body into the bottom of a pack like Luke Ball. Luke fits into our team better then Judd would. We could not just rely on Lenny to get every in an under ball for us, Luke is vital to our team plan. We have two fantastic runners of the ball in Monty and Dal already, i...

Can't have Riewoldt in there.

Dal
Monty
Gram
Goddard
Gardiner

So whos in?

I must say, in 48 years watching the Saints, I have only seen one better, from a St Kilda perspective anyway and few better games from any perspective. This was better than the 2004 game because the opposition was better. Despite what morons everywhere will say, Geelong could not and have not playe...

OneGram wrote:how are all the gronks going over at 121gronks.com Nathan?

Great thanks Slouch.

I'm getting onto the site fine.

They are fantastic photos Trunch.

Our forward line match ups have the North game written all over it. Kosi and Nick will be far too strong for there opponents, Kosi should kick a few goals this weekend IMO.

Every fan base has idiotic supporters. I am sure the level headed Geelong fans are excited about the change and interested in the outcome just as we are.

Does anyone know that actual announced team? I missed the show.

Oh, i am so sorry. Should i be banned? I didn't notice cowboy18's post so i thought i was replying directly underneath Sam23's post.

I was replying to Sam23's post.

Violent Stool wrote:

nathan000 wrote:He's kicked 2 bags on Max, 7 and 8.

Huh?

I was talking about Neitz.