The_dud... Just as the best kick from outside 60 doesn't make the best FF, neither does the best kick at goal. Does it take into account the pressure he is under while taking shots at goal too? Considering where we are on the ladder and considering the lack of other forwards we have he is under mor...

Personally i'd think a KPP is better than a midfielder, even if that is Judd. So if i was you i'd keep kosi and your first rounder. I dont think you guys could fit him in the salary cap even if you wanted too (including trading kosi). The fact we are the frontrunners could come down to 2 things. 1. ...

The_dud... Just as the best kick from outside 60 doesn't make the best FF, neither does the best kick at goal. Does it take into account the pressure he is under while taking shots at goal too? Considering where we are on the ladder and considering the lack of other forwards we have he is under more...

If he dont stay Trade him for Fevola and pick 2? I agree with your fellow saints fans. That that trade would never happen. Partly because we dont have pick 2 and partly because there is no way would would trade a coleman medalist and a top 3 pick for a player who has potential, but is injury prone.

how old is Teague? Teague is 26. Unfortunately Teague is a KPP player stuck in a short mids body. He is too slow for todays modern game. He was allowed to play on this year, knowing that he would not get a game because of the great example he sets amongst the club and what a great leader in the ant...

what about whitnall? with doc clarke gone we will be missing an inanimate carbon rod for 08 unless rix can step up to the plate. sadly rix has shown to be effective at tackling, chasing and showing endeavour, and throws himself at the footy as opposed to the supersized tripple whopper. he would lik...

Would want him he is a bloody accurate kick (something we need) but the price would be far too high to get him. lol, this post is hilarious, because fev is actually one of the WORST, if not the worst, kick for goal out of all the full forwards This is pure crap and can be attribute to people lookin...

If Kosi genuinely wants to go to Carlton, they don't have to give us anyone, do they? Yes. Richmond would have first dibs at him in the draft if we didn't trade him. True, but it is possibly to strike up a deal that Richmond are unable to match due to salary capo restrictions. Say that Carlton has ...

It's all hypotheticals and I agree Fev isn't moving and we aren't in a position to meet demands in any case. It's interesting the thought processes that go on though. "you've got to give something up to get something in". Example was put to me last night, to which I answered no on both co...

It's all hypotheticals and I agree Fev isn't moving and we aren't in a position to meet demands in any case. It's interesting the thought processes that go on though. "you've got to give something up to get something in". Example was put to me last night, to which I answered no on both co...

I logged on today to post a thread re: Fev, then saw this thread and came to post the same. IF we can fit him in the salary cap, and IF we can get him for a decent price (probably draft picks + a okay player) then we should go for him. However, don't trade Goddard for Fevola. Personally i wouldn't ...

How about....Brendan Fevola? He is on the market (in a secretive 'off the market' kind of way). Would you take him? I've asked a similar question before about who would be your next FF and the answer i got seemed to be either Brooks/Watts. Now call me naive, but wont you be struggling if they are yo...

Don't want to spoil you party here, but Pagan was pretty positive he had the goings on at Carlton under control too. Always confident we'd 'turned the corner' and all those other cliches. I value his opinion re the saints, but he was Paid 600k to be positive about the blues. The question is Ive hea...

Don't want to spoil you party here, but Pagan was pretty positive he had the goings on at Carlton under control too. Always confident we'd 'turned the corner' and all those other cliches. Pagan was basically forced to fire Mulkearns and Elshaug as it was a power move by the club who had to be seen t...

Many rumours about Mitch and what is happening with him at years end. Yes him and Pagan didn't get along. Yes that was mainly from Pagans end as he did have a sook that Mitch nearly stole his job. As a result he was dropped as an assistant and remained in a 'player development role' or something equ...

TBB, there are a number of reasons why Carlton get a better deal at TD. Several clubs including St Kilda believe Carlton received preferential treatment. The AFL certainly do if you look at their annual distributions to clubs. Unless someone releases the contracts then talking about break even crow...

If you ever start feeling sorry for Calrton scum, just think back these things : - Carlton voting at a creditors meeting to send us to the wall - Carlton attempting to set up a rival compeition to get rid of a few clubs including us - John Elliott's "who would want to go to that rabble" w...

The agro round here is a real put off. Saintsationalism gone mad. Next we'll be sending TBB to cyber detention camps. He's obviously a terrorsaintist! TBB was quite diplomatic and civil. His articulate posts made interesting reading. The fact he managed to string 5 or more coherent words together t...

johnpeterbudgefanclub wrote:

Answer me this question. What is Pendlebury's actual position.

Huh?

Serious question. I have many arguments about that.

Yeah I reckon he is going ok.....same with Scott Pendlebury. Goldsack wasnt a bad late pick up either. Three NAB rising star nominations this year baby booze, I will take that. See for us baby booze there is an era post Buckley, Burns, Wakelin and Licuria. :wink: Yeah but dont you feel bad by tanki...

HSVKing wrote:

TheBabyBlues wrote:Well currently we only have as many #1 picks as you.

He's a collingwood fan mate...

D'oh.

In that case...How is Dale Thomas (the tank engine) going?

I would piss myself laughing if Gibbs doesnt make it. Crikeys how many number one picks do u guys need. I mean fair's fair. I mean u have a guy like Andrew Walker who has been in the system for 4 years (?) and still turns the ball over like my mums pancakes. Josh Kennedy? Pfft. Murphy has been ok b...

stinger wrote:flower off......

You just cant take no for an answer can ya.

Gimme a hug stinger

In comparison... Saints are relatively strong off field at present. Fan base is ok at present but may drop if performance does. Performance is on the way down too. So we have more potential room to grow then you . oh ffs ...go away you annoying little person......you talk utter crap.......our perfo...

I think it's a fair comment to say that the Dogs and Kangas would be at the head of a re-location drive. Not sure about the Saints and Hawks though. Can't even imagine the Saints being moved from Melb. Especially since they have improved their financial status and member numbers. Hawks I don't know...