Hilarious! To have his management conducting good faith contract extension negoatiations with St Kilda - to who he was contracted - while speaking to another club behind closed doors, and (despite his assertions to the contrary) lying to the players... how could any spin on that involve dignity? Get...

It's not so much whether he left or got pushed, just that he was my favourite player by a street and then out of the blue one day before school the papers were saying that he'd left and gone to Hawthorn. I didn't realise that such a thing could even happen let alone to my idol - my dad tried to expl...

I haven't felt this shattered by a defection since Russell Greene left all those years ago, and I was only a tacker then... Just the level of trust that has been betrayed, I know footy is a business now but it seems like there's no place for integrity in the sport at all. I honestly miss the old day...

That was a correct decision and not doing any legal stuff here would also be the correct decision. Why? Why even bother having contracts at all if you aren't going to enforce your rights in the case of a breach? Let's all live in fairy land and do everything with a handshake, don't want anyone to b...

The passionless proles who sit around me would stand up to fart in the bath! So you have to carry on like a brainless moron to have passion? God, you're a wet blanket. If you don't like the movie fine, but don't be such a condescending jerk. Doubt you even know how to spell fun let alone have it...

If he did leave who's out there? Pretty much leaves us in the lurch...

He probably said that to him and Bally said i have a flag and i also see that supporters on SS cant get over me leaving and write threads on me every week even though I have as much to do with the Saints as Chris Tarrant does. He then probably laughed and said I look forward to another 5 threads th...

prediction: 5 mins to go in the last we are up by two goals and dominating a puffed out collingwood (LOL) milne kicks his first for the game, breaking the record and 20 thousand muppets run on to the ground to touch him and tell him that he is the greatest momentum gone pies win by a goal :roll: :t...

If I didn't have 35 years invested in following the Saints and an intense tribal desire to see us win the flag I'd walk away from the AFL in an instant and focus on watching club footy. The AFL is a disgrace with its contrived inconsistencies and (barely) hidden agendas. Seriously, try and explain t...

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/boyd-gives-thumbs-up-to-target-tactic/story-e6frf9io-1226097271727 They showed footage On The Couch of Boyd taking cheap shots at Harvey's broken thumb - isn't this exactly the same thing that Bakes did to Johnson and later (from video footage) got reported and ...

I vaguely recall Commetti after a break saying, "The Eagles by 43 points... sorry, that's wishful thinking, the Saints by..."

I made the number up, but I'm sure I heard that because I remember being incredulous at the time that he would be so brazenly one-eyed....

As I said in another thread a few days ago, I used to pretty much live for the St Kilda games on the weekends, but now I start wanting to leave many of their games half way through the third, when they go into this mode, even though we're in front. There are about a million other better things to d...

Seriously it's a football forum on the Internet. Get over it, being judgmental and condesending is extremely unbecoming...

Next time we play the filth I urge every supporter to pay attention to the Collingwood ferals around them, and every time one of them sledges Milney, Joey, Roo, Sam or anyone else about anything non-footy related, give them two warnings, carry on like an idiot, and then ring the authorities and hav...

Next time we play the filth I urge every supporter to pay attention to the Collingwood ferals around them, and every time one of them sledges Milney, Joey, Roo, Sam or anyone else about anything non-footy related, give them two warnings, carry on like an idiot, and then ring the authorities and have...

Next time we play the filth I urge every supporter to pay attention to the Collingwood ferals around them, and every time one of them sledges Milney, Joey, Roo, Sam or anyone else about anything non-footy related, give them two warnings, carry on like an idiot, and then ring the authorities and have...

Club functions are an embarrassment when compared with professional outfits like Carlton. The member is treated like an intruder into the private sanctum of admin staff and players. I know, I've been to a few. Always leave with a sour taste in my mouth. Barrack for Carlton then. Seriously... This w...

If Gilbert has kept these images against the direct request to delete them then I'm afraid he should be sacked from the Club. Incredible. Some people's minds work in bizarre ways... You think there was any malice in this? The guy made a mistake - kept a photo of his mates mucking around on holiday ...

why on earth would you keep pics like that on ya lappie what a rather large pratt unreal if he sports a black eye and a crooked nose at the next training session he'd deserve it idiot I reckon it is pretty obvious and I will say what maybe some are thinking. To show girls the captains dick when the...

Oh FFS get a grip The two will be prickly with each other, but if you think that all players have to love each other as brothers, you haven't been around too many sporting clubs. Aker was absolutely hated in Brisbane and they won three flags. Edwards and McLeod, Williams, and Rhys-Jones, just off t...

on 882am she has confirmed she has other photos of players from other clubs- up to 8 other clubs. apparently collingwood confirmed. Why is the disgusting harlot targetting us then? I thought a Collingwood player ended up being responsible for her pregnancy? Although it seems that would be an educat...

5am. Go home, boys. Dumb. Why? They're on leave... What other job resricts your movements in your private time? There's no hint yet that they instigated anything, as far as I like they can do whatever they like in their own time... I feel so sorry for footballers in this day and age, they deserve e...

Fair call. I live up north so usually only get to see the seniors play these days. I remember thinking his skills seemed okay, but like you said they were hardly pressure-cooker environments...

Does anyone have any information on the rationale behind this delisting? I too thought he showed a lot of composure in those two games he played late in the year, and he obviously has pace, so why wouldn't he be worth a lower list spot? Very strange... Was looking forward to seeing how he went this ...

I'm genuinely interested to know this: if that ball had bounced up for Milney in GF1 and we'd snatched the flag and were about to embark on season 2011 with the premiership crest on our jumpers, would everyone still be predicting such doom and gloom? Not saying you're wrong, but we were so close to ...