King did us a lot in the 09 GF didn't he. Ottens was barely a pinch hitter in the 09 finals,he was a cripple. Blake was there ruckman,and a poor one at that We've had a good history trading for ruckman. What did we give away for Brooks again? That was full of win. Imagine if those trades had of bee...

what did judd say?

Once again the AFL expect the players to be doctors. He was not in the hands of the trainers so is fair game. Disgrace! So you had no problem with what Brisbane players did to Rooy. Joey was an idiot and should have focused more on getting clearances than bumping an obviously injured player. Yes, i...

I am not a kossie basher and love it when kossie fires...but that handball to dal when he was running onto his rightfoot to the boundry knowing that he had to get past the guy on the mark was not a smart move by kossie.
The should have split up...good players should have a feel for that...

well played saints....just a few minor changes eg mini and raph gone..cant carry them need to deveolp. This is the first time i've been overly negative toward raph but he has been at the club for a very long time and is just a shell of a player who is way out of his depth. If he was new I would hope...

He was a better ump that night than Hayden Kennedy (#7) who was for richmond (against us (Gave them everything)) than the umps were for gold coast last night.

I wonder if the local resident wank p66 could see a bit of bias from the umps last night Gold coast - brisbane?

Halfway through 2009 we were kicking everyones asses full on forward pressure we were laughing at the opposition playing into our hands kicking backwards (now their laughing at us). We then got lazy and reverted back to our slow defence and not quick offence...still miffed how we made last years gra...

All full backs get bags kicked on them. Max was absolutely smashed a few times. lake has had bad days, Scarlett etc. we need the mids to stop quick release from the centre. Our lack of hit outs and first use of the ball is the cause for our defective backline. It comes in so quick we can't set a zo...

Dawson is a dud and only gets a game because of his height.....

Has no weapons and gives us nothing...wish he played for the opposition every week...he gets totally lost and we must not rely on him going forward....must develop simkin/walsh and if they are not up to it than we will be no worse off...

Forget Polo, along with gamble and many many others...wasted draft picks further reducing positive future.

thank god this is the last yr of the carlton social club appropriately called channel 10

I was reliably informed on here that our disposal is far from bad... Nothing is reliable on this forum. Our disposal has always been ordinary - in 2009 and 2010 it was average. it is just shown up even more because our pedestrian pace wont allow us to break a zone and our switches are so slow. We a...

If only zac was playing for adelaide...he has no idea where he's palyer is or the ball...a 9 yr old has better judgement He's one out on a big opponent who has the ball spitting at him at a hundred miles an hour because we are kicking to THEIR advantage and excepting Armo our midfield refuses to ta...

If only zac was playing for adelaide...he has no idea where he's palyer is or the ball...a 9 yr old has better judgement

I take it back..if p66 thinks he was good I've obviously got it wrong

defacto wrote:he cant keep up with the game. he has been a great player for us, but the time has come. he needs a send off game, towards the end of the season.

Baker good tonight

Beno88 wrote:Spot on. This is half the reason we look slow, because players have to jump or stop to receive a handball.

The othe reason is because we have no leg speed to run and not hurry the disposal

Game made for an armitage type...slippery track suits slow solid movers
Not sure if he's up to the required level...big fish small pond??

Another drafting gem

They look so unfit they only last a 10 minute effort before collapsing, the humidity should screw us more too. We did do this a lot last year as well. Try and shut down games, and it backfires when opposition teams just run through us. We don't get far enough in front to crush opposition teams spir...

noob wrote:dawson lay a tackle properly

dawson gives one effort (awkward) then thats it....he makes me nervous when blakes not there to cover his deficiencies

BACKWARDS WITHOUT A THOUGHT OF ATTACK..THEY ARE GOING NOWHERE....SHTTTT

You guys have short memories. The previous system was called ChookLotto for a reason. At least this system has a verifiable process it follows; the contention is with the classifications from which the penalty is derived, not some arbitrary number of weeks plucked from the chairman's backside. I do...

Stephen Theodore wrote:A fit Everitt in 97 would have delivered us a premiership IMO.

If everitt did not get injured we would not have made it to the gf.
Against brisbane at waverley he was being flogged then got hurt..Loewe then moved into the ruck and dominated the final

I think only 5 sandy players played last week...lourey and dore the other two... Ferguson named in best.....do you think that list was accurate.... Btw it isnt 5 or 6...... I am sure they will take a conservative approach, given how precious our players are.....that is the whole point.....they shou...

Well if we kicked one more point we would have won so I say we lost the GF by a point and not 50 points. I totally agree with that p66. One more point in GF1 and GF2 never happens. But now I'm a bit confused. People say Collingwood lost by a point in 1966. Would it be more accurate to say they lost...