Whilst I like Ben McEvoy and I'm sure he'll be a good long term ruck man, YOU DO NOT USE A FIRST ROUND PICK ON A RUCK MAN, UNLESS THEY'RE A FREAK LIKE NATANUI. . while our drafting of kids has been poor Ben from what was know at the time was a good vaue pick...and is proving to be so. Now picks lik...

we have a lot of average footballers in that side...long way from premiership

PJ wrote:

Finally someone who calls it how it is, this bloke is embarrassing and if he wasn't RL's lovechild would struggle to get a game in the VFL.

My nomination for today's f###wit is........saintbob come on down

I nominate you..f###wanker

childish isn't it!

A textbook case for why football games aren't played on stats sheets. Zac is a liability down back, he trailed cloke by the length of the flemington straight all night. The pies just didnt kick it to cloke last night.[/ Finally someone who calls it how it is, this bloke is embarrassing and if he wa...

How long has dawson played the game....worse player in the side with the ball.

What a desperate, retarded thread.....attention seeking now.. Oh dear, using words like retarded, from a teacher as well :D Look at me, look at me... Oh the dripping irony..... Pathetic really.. The smug threads by you and plugger after a win are simply stupid.... Oh dear, seems like someones infla...

What a desperate, retarded thread.....attention seeking now.. Look at me, look at me... Pathetic really.. The smug threads by you and plugger after a win are simply stupid.... Its like you want supporters to eat humble pie after a win.....we would prefer to enjoy it and be happy that ross was right...

Why dont you "play the kids" like you did earlier this year? Remember back to those great days when we had one win from the first seven games. Now you have stopped playing them look at our form. What good is 6 wins out of 8 games when we need to play kids. Wouldn't it be better to have ke...

When are some of you halfwits going to learn proper grammar and language skills? When I read the incorrect use of there, their and they're or see could of, would of & should of instead of could have, would have & should have I sometimes feel I'm reading a Collingwood forum rather than a St ...

Maybe we should only receive half of what collingwood get from tv rights as like the draw we have less than half the viewers so they should not be disadvantaged. Who cares about the comp. Why do a few of you p66 etc infer that makes no difference if we play westcoast at docklands or perth..if you're...

where's p66 - he'll explain it for us - a wealthy comp is far more important than a fair one - so we need to take it up the arse for the good of all! That's exactly Dimwit's view - and very eloquently put :D Got I wish I had your negative attitude. It must be so much fun thinking everything is corr...

Why would you want to flick one of the few run and carry players we have...our side is very short on this type of player. We should be looking at his positives not creating these negative perceptions on one of the few players we have wanting to take the opposition on and carry the ball forward...sic...

Max was like Sos, an arm pulling jumper holder that was perfect in his era but may have struggled with frees against these days. Not sure if people remember Max was pretty slight and not a hulking full back. He seems to have been remodelled in memories as Mick martin. That was always my concern wit...

InkerSaint wrote:Had a good first quarter, had a poor second, how many goals did Cloke kick in the third?

Dawson is a dud and if we don't develop someone for he's position fb we will be seriously up against any climb up the ladder 2012

Dawson won't play close

All I see in this clip is how far Zac gives his man....what did max do wrong other than running his butt off and not getting a free.

If Jack steven learns to stay on his feet will be another N.Burke....but if he keeps falling over will be just another gop. Does he need to learn to play in different boots?

Is Ledger really that quick..I've not seen much of him but he appeared to be one paced, be good to think he had other gears

Plugger 66, do you think one day you can make a post without I repeat, without having to make some negative personal attack against the person making a comment? Plug is a very positive person ugh...you will now be in his self opinionated no idea no ideas book...what a wank our p66 is.. Cannot belie...

whinging at the whingers again plug.

Umps have been corrupt since the beginning of sport..

Like commentators some a bias

Our trading and drafting of recycled players has generally been poor. There have been some successes, Ray is a win, Dempster/Schneider is a huge win but then it goes back to Penny, Fraser and Hamill for any unqualified successes. Gardiner has been good when he has played but he has missed far more ...

Our forwards/midfield/rucks/backs all not up to it... How did we make the grand final and what have we been drafting/trading... Who what have we done with our 1st 3 draft picks each year over the last several yrs??? sick of trading no one gives away a potentail gun unless given more than their worth

Bad trading/drafting nothing delveloped players like eddy/maqualter etc allowed to string together many bad to average games...

We now have to draft develop without much error for margin to get back up there before our good senior players are aged

The future is not bleak at all. This year's gone, baring a miracle, but plenty to look forward to next year. Some good kids coming through this year and the core of experienced guns will still be there and Lenny will be back. So how are we off for tall backs/forwards rucks midfielders quick forward...

More point.... Our admin is weak as piss, and almost incompetant.......and the defense of our players.....right back to gehrigs tummy tap, kosi's trip to the three baker debarkles to the whispers in the sky have all been typically amatuerish and laughable.. Yes all the precedents are set with our p...