Kosi was good tonight...3 goals, and crashed the packs to spill for 2 others that I can remember, rucked OK too....waddya want?

I also thought the aggression was well worth it, we need some mongrel.

The source is v.good and they are pretty much MS words...I'm not saying thats what happened, Harvs no doubt has his own recollection, but that is apparently,pretty much MS....the whole story was ready to be written in a column but got pulled at last minute.

I have it on v. good authority that the end of game confrontation is a bit different to what we al thought. I don't know what exactly was said during the game but apparently Harvs was bagging Bartel sayig he was overrated etc, and the Geelong players had a crack back at Harvey saying he was too old,...

Better than Mini, good mark, finds space and makes things happen.

Armitage or Steven in for Gwilt too

The only other pryk to do that to Banger was Ben Cousins 06....I did, however, note that in the next game they played, at the end of the game Cousins jogged about 100m to shake Bangers hand.

Good call Eastern...I'm actually watching it with my wifes Grandfather at an old folk's home in Kew....He's a die hard Sainter, used to be on the board in the 80s actually....God I hope they can win it this year, he aint got long til he's watching them from heaven!

Good discussion....I can't understand why he doesn't get more of the ball...he is very fit and athletic, with great hands. In a couple of pre-season games he looked great. I think Mart is right about structure though, the endless mtpl opponents on Roo seems to abate when Kosi and CG are in the fwd l...

Must have just been me , but I thought he showed a bit more this week than the last few!

He as a revelation in that first game vs Adelaide where he played on the ball and forward.....today's the first time since then he's been tried in the same role! He is not a defender, but might be a pretty handy fwd/ rotating midfielder.

Loved his spoil, gather and run in the last Q. Massive bonus if he can miraculously start to deliver on his potential.

Reminded me of '05 with our relentless pressure and hunting in packs...2nd and 3rd quarters we were unstoppable.

Well done Eddy and Clint Jones to put pressure on with footspeed and gutsy running.

A well coached win...finally putting the players in their right positions. Gwilt is dangerous and much more comfortable playing wing to HFF...really starting to hit players and hurt them with his body bulk. Gilbert played very well today as did Birss i thought, a good in...can mark and kick for goal...

Has reached the next level....loves a goal, and needs to be in the fwd line more often.

Maybe Freo will be interested in him come the trade period.

Last week was a shocker, every right tp feel gutted after that game. Played better today, but we need to be able to win when we are favourites not just the underdog. We looked very good in the 2nd half but BTW it was Freo, and that doesn't count for alot in credibility terms....they make us look con...

Must have 5 or 6 clear BOGs this year and thats 15 -18 votes he can count on.
Even though Boomer Harvey and Ablett jr are the obvious favourites, I'm surprised Reiwoldt gets no mention.

Had some good games in losing sides an might snaffle a couple of 1 and 2 vote games.

If we can't win today what is the pioint of making finals?

Lose to WCE, Collingwoods U19 team and the shockers....of course we will win today, what team would allow a true club champion to bow out in such embarassing circumstances?????

Kosi and the Clarke brothers are the tragedy of that list...should have been part of the first tier of players, and now are shadows of their potential, with not much hope of really turning it around.

Fair enough, but can't see both Clarkes staying.

Who does everyone think will step up from the long list of young fringe players we have?

I reckon Steven, Eddy, Armo and McEvoy...the rest will go by the wayside.

I reckon we have to take a big draw from the draft this year, or have a youth policy in the trades 22 or under....This is the year we'll give up some talent for early picks.

Fisher not as good as last couple of years, but still a walk up start....I've alays seen his defensive side as good, and a very good mark from opposition kicks...anticipates them very well.
Will finish top 5 again this year in B&F...can't trade him away...15 clubs would be v. interested.

I'd keep Dal...he is the most talented member of the team and having an ordinary year...I still question whether he has issues with RL because he looks depressed. Kosi...whether thru injury or confidence just cannot produce at this club. His stocks are still good enough to get a good trade...and yes...

Leave Max of that list!

Seeing as we're clearly not that serious about playing finals we may as well give him another farewell game vs Essendon or Adelaide....couldn't do less than Kosi did last night.

If it wasn't for Rob Harvey's dignity....we may as well tank this year and officially rebuild. We have a very long tail of average to below average players...reminds me of when we were living in hope that Daniel Wulf or Ben Walton and co would some how come good...we have to be realistic and make to...