The decision was a joke. Pressure???

If I was playing and 40m in the clear, now I'd run to the goal line, wait for an opposition player to approach and step out for a point.... 'under pressure'.

Carr had plenty of time and no Saint around him. Bizarre.

Ross' only concern at the moment is if an elimination final is played in the wet. Skills tonight were appalling.

And Kosi needs contact lenses. He can't be that unco, surely.

Is it me or do we look slow?

MRP = Circus. Spin the wheel see where it lands...

The system is Bizarre. A joke.

Anderson or someone in AFL House - maybe drag Dimetriou away from counting his millions (Bizarre again!!) - NEED to investigate the lack of consistency and bizzarreness.

Very similiar to the Sirengate match - where the AFL instructed the club to justify why we should get the points. Why is there an assumption that Saints need to make a complaint?????? This is a matter for the AFL to investigate. Shhhesh. It's been all over the media this weekend, the allegations hav...

Some of the posts are a bit harsh. He was drafted by a club that plays the majority of its games on the most unsafe surface in the AFL - totally r00ting his groin. Had he been drafted by West Cost we would have been lamently Juddy's shoulder - shattered by the endless crashing into the Docklands con...

The apology is nice. But I would suggest that the family friendly and politically correctness aware AFL will take a dim view of any alleged vilification - no doubt the nature to be uncovered during the investigation.

Any more sweeping under the carpet will push the lump over the height of Everest.

How many of the 17 were clear chances? Probably 6-7 same as our points. Hoy many of their misses were shots under pressure, from 50 out or from tight angles. They chose to go via the boundary and with the rolling zone flooding back through the corridor the majority of their attempts would always be ...

Herein lies another test case for the 'new' tribunal system.

According to the new rules, a head high hit when the player chooses not to contest the footy will result in weeks.

If he dosen't get at least one week then another example of the 'bizarreness' and inconsistency of the system.

Think it should be like 4 weeks at Jenny Craig. Is he the fattest going around?

Unfortunately for Davis - in this age of family friendly football - he had the option of going for the ball but chose to 'bump' and make head high - albeit accidental - contact. Should get 2 reduced to 1 - whch seems to be the norm these days for that type of hit.

What did Baker get? 7?

Just as well Josh Kennedy was not Steven Baker.

Plugger {can't do the reposting of messages} The last thing we wanted Kosi to do was go the ball as he would have cleaned up his team mate who was taking possession. My point is the farcical and bizzare system where penalities and decisions vary depending on the mood of the reviewer. IMO Kosi should...

My two cents. How could anyone sanely see the Kennedy incident AND read the Review Panel's assessment of that incident POSSIBLY even think that Kosi could get weeks?????? What Anderson has put in place is the most bizzare and confusing system. One week its ok to run pass the ball and inflict a broke...

Had to laugh when Walls and Darcy both called Geary Milne. Even after the replays Walls still named Milne when 14 was clearly visible. I'm finding when Ch10 has a pre-game 'story line' - last night it was the Dogs GF drought - the call becomes farcical and the bias towards the story evident in order...

Thought watching last night Kosi was testing a lower script contact lens. All will be good in Round 1 when 20/20 vision restored.

We need to move on. Although his commitment could never be questiond, we have the inside word on his skills and stamina. At 250k on the saints list would have been expensive. Gets mill over two years and can't wait til Monday after round 1 when a pie mate says, "500K! The bloke can't kick"...

They'll soon realise their great 500k a year get when he cannot make the distance from 30m out, runs out of puff after 5 minutes and continually misses targets. Not Saints Footy so its good bye, good luck and thanks for for your 100% effort, 100% of the time.

Luke's decision probably gets him another 150 games as majority will be on the G and not on the concrete OP killer Dome surface.

Ah yes. "Unduly rough play." "Contact between Carlton’s Kade Simpson and St Kilda’s Brendon Goddard from the first quarter of Friday’s match was assessed. The panel said that Simpson tackled Goddard and pinned his left arm. Simpson’s head was positioned behind Goddard’s back...

Was deemed reckless, low impact and high contact.

Looked like the contact was across the shoulder. Should at least challenge the contact rating from 'high' to 'body' and reduce from Level 2 to 1.

Kosi - I must see it at least one time each game - bloke with arms extended overhead taking a mark with an opponent giving him one behind the ear. Commentators invariably calling 'Gee- they made him earn that one!". Now - after (16 * 8) 128 like incidents over the season - the MRP decide to cal...

Dirty dog all right. Twice pushed Kosi into a marking contest, one - Gardiner almost killed him.

He's the modern day Silvagni. Gets away with murder. The only defender still allowed to chop arms and push fowards in the back.

Also the one in the second when standing on the top of the square, ball coming in and Kelly takes him out over allowing fellow cat an uncontested mark. Milne gave the ump a filthy look and moved on.