funny how early in the season banfield was being bagged as crap by some folks after he made some comments critical of st kilda's treatment of casey in 07. (predominantly due our injury situation) now he has the use of some quality (andrew thompson, gwilt, watts, brooks (who seems to be the most info...

Really good s**t-stirring, tongue in cheek opening post Dan. I'm disappointed that nobody picked up the bait: I guess either because they didn't get your point, or else through choice because they wanted to post something serious about Casey. Anyway, I just wanted to let you know that i appreciated...

we weren't 16th for according to final siren for hitouts or clearnances. I can't find the clearance stats as they were posted to me, however our hitout stats saw us 13th in 06, with collingwood, kangaroos and essendon (hille lol) below us) even in 2007 we are not 16th on hitouts. pro stats have us o...

Its a hard one. in 97 if spider was fit we would have beaten adelaide. on a crystal blue cloudless afternoon on a perfect pitch 7 out of the 10 tallest players were adelaide. the just had 2 people on loewe and despite us winning so much of the ball in the middle, loewe was just dragged to the gound ...

Should the club conduct a review of the services it provides to members at the end of the year? If so, should they try to involve as many member groups as possible (incl Moorabbin Wing & Saintsational? What would we like to see them do better than they do now? What do they do well now (eg. Age ...

its expensive, very few clubs do it.

also there is the core product issue.

well IMO while its great to see casey resurrect itself from its basket case season earlier on, but st kilda first IMO.

St Fidelius wrote:Is it Yes, they are finished...

OR

Yes, they have a role in 2008

lol yeah, reading down people have interpreted it differently

36 - Robert Harvey................yes 34 - Andrew Thompson..........no 34 - Matthew Clarke...............no 31 - Fraser Gehrig..................yes 30 - Aaron Hamill...................yes 29 - Michael Gardiner.............yes 29 - Brett Voss......................no its scary to view at the amount o...

people are answering this differently, some folks are putting yes for 'they are finished' and others are putting 'yes' that the can go on.

LAWLS

perhaps RL needs to instruct the reserves to play 'his' brand of football. frankly I dont like it, but if it wins games then so be it. we should have 1 philosophy to give RL a fair go. i dont think its the right philosophy but if the players in casey are play Y brand and the seniors are playing X br...

perhaps they are good players under game plan X but not under game plan y? perhaps RL needs to instruct the reserves to play 'his' brand of football. frankly I dont like it, but if it wins games then so be it. we should have 1 philosophy to give RL a fair go. i dont think its the right philosophy bu...

i dont care. I want him to win games as coach. even Timmids ridiculous press conferences never bothered me. criticise him for on field stuff, off field i have my opinions about him, but if he can turn the saints around then I dont give a rats how he presents to the press. frankly i think most of the...

or can they play a role in 2008???? Yes or No answers 36 - Robert Harvey................he can play a role 34 - Andrew Thompson..........he can play a role 34 - Matthew Clarke...............GONE 31 - Fraser Gehrig..................Can play a role see below 30 - Aaron Hamill...................Can pla...

lol 2 weeks to brown for lying at the tribunal

oh mr burns what have you done!

well I assumed they were friends from prior to 98/99 from being around st kilda in the 80s together as well as all the rhetoric about having coffees, being neighbours and GT recruiting butterss to the board and supporting his run for the presidency.

do the crime do the time.

with WCE name tarnished and Judd being about the only good thing at the club of course the AFL wanted to stick their head in the sand.

I notice no legal action from braun to date...and the AFL destroyed (allegedly ) samples taken from players previously...

nope, nothing wrong. no one has committed crimes, no one has done drugs, no one has cheated on teh salary cap etc. and two old men are carrying on like a pair of bull elephants fighting over the herd. stupid behaviour and it reflects poorly on st kilda. between 2002 and 2006 we were a well oiled mac...

doc clarke wont be playing next year at st kilda.

he seems like a geniunely nice bloke and comes across as thoughtful, i dont know if that means intelligent.

would be interested to see how he goes as a ruck coach.

I guess for 25 odd years they were the best of friends.

now its gone sour they are splashing it all over the place like a pair of drunken bull elephants.

JD discuss the issue wth joffaburns, joffa boy etc, most of them can argue a point wether you agree with them or not. I dont always agree with mr magic, nick, JBoy JBurns, and less and less so on this board, but B4E and teffers are just unwell at the moment. i think if GT died of a slow and painful ...

well Im certain we dont need this shyte from GT, RB, St Kilda or anyone else.

its much more fun when we can lambast carlton, melbourne, freo etc for their actions.

fair call JD

I dont listen to SEN generally so I am taking what folks here say as truth.

either way, i wish it would all go away and we can win games

same here. sick of the revisionist history about his coaching by those have an agenda. sick of GT being a idiot in the press, on the radio and his fights with St Kilda. I wish for the sake of us, his family and the club he pays his debts, pays of his house and gets a good job. I think if he got the ...