Longmire is a proven coach. Sydney have never bottomed out. I think they have only had 2 top 5 picks in the last decade! Sydney's consistency isn't only on Longmire, it started with Roos. Ironically if Longmire had gotten the Saints job in 2007 (he was short listed with Lyon & McKenna). Lyon pr...

I can’t defend King anymore As someone said he made Zerk Thatcher (who was dropped a couple of weeks ago) look AA His stats from yesterday were frightening 1st quarter donut 2nd 3 handballs all outside F50 4th 1 disposal inside F50 His first 4 games (before suspension were ok) since then he has ave...

He’s clearly playing as instructed, as nothing is changing, and there are no repercussions, so I just think he doesn’t fit in a Ross Lyon defensive low scoring system. Get something for him while we still can. Do you honestly believe Lyon wants him to play the way he's playing? Funny how Marshall h...

Pou's stats from the weekend:

31 disposals
14 kicks
17 handballs
6 marks
9 tackles
9 clearances!!
2 goals

140 AF

OUT: Campbell

IN: Sharman

Garcia in as Sub.

Second year blues (I know its technically his third), he's getting more respect from opposition.

samuraisaint wrote: ↑Mon 01 Jul 2024 12:37pm I was there yesterday, and I can tell you that Josh Battle is an absolute star and should be kept at all costs.
He is one bloke we cannot f**** lose.
Bloke is a jet! EOFS.

Yes he is a star, the best third tall defender in the competition. How much do you pay for a third tall defender?

Battle for pick 19 would be a(nother) list management disaster for us. It won't happen. We offered him the $800k early in the year, we've since offered him more. So if Hawthorn beat our offer, which they need to, we get band 1 compo. Our decision is simple, what's the maximum you pay for a third ta...

B.M wrote: ↑Sun 30 Jun 2024 6:47pm Time to bring him in now, his confidence is high

Out Wilson, Dow, Campbell

In. Phillipou, Ross, Sharman (into 22)

In as Sub
Garcia

Not yet, just a few more dominant games for Sandy.

Personally, I think taking Rory Lobb would be great for St Kilda. It's going to solve 2 issues. Firstly, it'll help RoMa...and secondly it's going to help Max King. At the moment we don't have anyone as experienced or as good as Lobb who can fulfil the role of a forward who is also handy as relief ...

B.M wrote: ↑Mon 17 Jun 2024 10:34am That’s one person’s narrow view

There are thousands of Ex Fitzroy supporters that follow Brisbane

Have you actually met any?

B.M wrote: ↑Mon 17 Jun 2024 8:41am Seriously

Some respect for a 9 times B&F and 3 times Brownlow medallist

You’re a fool

And the fact is that the Club he was a champion for, no longer exists.

I read today that Hawthorn are right in to Battle, but he has strong relationships at St Kilda. So it would appear the only way we lose him is if we try to low-ball him. We shouldn't and I doubt we will low ball him. On the other hand you don't want to pay an inflated amount for a third tall defend...

I don’t think anyone on here can speak for South/Fitz people Kevin Murray loves Brisbane Lyons Bob Stilton loves the Sydney Swans To survive and keep their history- they had to relocate I haven't met a Fitzroy supporter thrilled with the merger or enthused by Brisbane. To them, their Footy team is ...

I saw the look in Rossy's eyes when Brisbane kicked their seventh in the last few seconds of the quarter. He was seething. There were a fair few F bombs in his quarter time address and fair enough. Our decision making had sometimes descended into supreme idiocy, our back six were been slaughtered in...

I read today that Hawthorn are right in to Battle, but he has strong relationships at St Kilda. So it would appear the only way we lose him is if we try to low-ball him. We shouldn't and I doubt we will low ball him. On the other hand you don't want to pay an inflated amount for a third tall defend...

Is this thread a troll? Merge or relocate, no longer the St Kilda Football Club and I'd be out and so would many others. Brisbane have got nothing to do with Fitzroy and Sydney have got nothing to do with South Melbourne. Exactly! And what did moving get them!? Wait...ummm Whoops Grand Finals GALOR...

It appears that The Pou is building nicely.

Is this thread a troll?

Merge or relocate, no longer the St Kilda Football Club and I'd be out and so would many others.

Brisbane have got nothing to do with Fitzroy and Sydney have got nothing to do with South Melbourne.

I’m watching Swans v Cats Swans are frightening…their skill and execution is sublime The commentators just said “it’s like they can choose mid quarter the gears they want to use/go to and pull it off…sometimes fast …then slow ….rarely turning it over the whole time… Cats doing a lot right but the c...

For those that have watched the presser would’ve seen an honest appraisal of where we are by the coach , make no mistake this guy is switched on. All the armchair experts on here are banging on about our Forward set up and inability to kick goals. Our coach knows this and is trying to work out ways...

The Junction, St. Kilda. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Slx8w6pn_KU I was at this game Me too. I saw myself in the crowd. It was a great win. A very high scoring and entertaining game. Yes, I remember Grant Thomas having a good game, kicked a goal from close to the centre, with a torpedo on the ru...

King wasn’t leading (or even trying to lead) he was jostling to get over the back. If he just turned and did a hit up lead he would’ve had an easy uncontested mark and shot at goal That play fully encapsulates his issues And one other play, the one where he gave away a clear push in the back free. ...

5: Battle
4: Sinclair
3: Steele
2: Wanganeen-Milera
1: Windhager

samuraisaint wrote: ↑Sun 09 Jun 2024 11:31am The Junction, St. Kilda.

I was at this game