desertsaint wrote: ↑Wed 20 Apr 2022 7:30pm B: Baker Hudgton Dempster
HB: Goddard S.Fisher Jones
C: Dal Santo Hayes Montagna
HF: Kosi Riewoldt Schneider
F: Milne Gehrig Hamill
R: Gardiner Harvey Steele
INT: Ball Steven Marshall Thompson

Very Good effort.
No Membrey?
I'd argue he'd be ahead of Kossie and Hamill as a player.

Quick google search shows there are 641 listed TAC cup players across 12 teams. Not inclusive of lower age sides. Search also shows on average 45 kids are drafted from the TAC cup each year. So loosely 7% of TAC cup players are drafted each year. There well maybe kids outside the TAC cup as good or ...

B: Dempster - Hudghton - Baker HB: Gilbert - Fisher - Jones C: Goddard - Hayes - Montagna HF: - Reiwoldt - Dal Santo F: Membrey - Gehrig - Milne Foll: Marshall - Steele - Steven Int: Harvey - Koschitzke - Ball - Ross Emerg: Blake - Thompson - Voss - Armitage Ruck - hardest to choose Everett - B&...

The_Dud wrote: ↑Wed 20 Apr 2022 2:22pm Coach?

Easy...Watty Scotters

Yorkeys wrote: ↑Wed 20 Apr 2022 2:03pm Blake and Peckett? or outside the criteria?

I had Peckett on the bench and didn't include Blake.

To the best of my knowledge we haven't seen a TOC since the end of 1999. I thought it would be interesting to look at one from 2000 onward. Criteria I have used: - Minimum 50 games - All Australian automatic inclusion I have excluded Burke & Loewe who played many more seasons prior to 2000 than...

BTW Bontempelli is sucking the umpires off, while Jack Reiwoldt is telling it how it is Funny that WB are the most looked after team in the comp statistically and the tigers the most penalised ! That can't be correct! Aren't we the club the umpires are most biased toward? Isn't there conspiracy?

I must say I hadnt heard of him before now. https://central.rookieme.com/afl/player/sam-sturt/ I just went looking for his WAFL stats, he has hardly played the entire time he has been there. When he did play he averaged 13 possessions and a goal a game. He was taken at pick #17 in the 2018 draft, I...

https://resources.saints.com.au/photo-resources/2019/11/27/a5c5d021-d9ad-40ba-868a-3b98975bbf72/ovnMWRss.jpg?width=1904&height=1184 Not sure Brereton has it in for the Saints or King. I think he dishes it out to all clubs fairly evenly, and I don't think the challenge he's put before King is un...

spert wrote: ↑Tue 19 Apr 2022 10:17am

longtimesaint wrote: ↑Mon 18 Apr 2022 7:33pm The most punchable of all!

Does that include their supporters?

And former coach?
Old prune face here.

I think not. Watching them play Hawthorn, I detest them more than anyone else, even Carlton. In a word No Selwood Hawkins Dangerfield Cameron Myers Additional punchable heads: Tuohy Rohan You forgot the 3 sissy looking head band 200cm boys who need a good head punch. Blicavs Stanley De Koning

Jones has a history of soft tissue injuries so unless he is cherry ripe IMO not worth the risk . Who comes in or out will depend on who matches up better against the opposition . I'm not sure if we need to make too many changes unless it's to give they young blokes a bit of rotation to keep them fr...

To the best of my knowledge we haven't seen a TOC since the end of 1999. I thought it would be interesting to look at one from 2000 onward. Criteria I have used: - Minimum 50 games - All Australian automatic inclusion I have excluded Burke & Loewe who played many more seasons prior to 2000 than ...

Seb has been maligned on this forum for years and I don’t get it . There are guys who have been VFL standard who escaped bashing while multiple calls for Seb to be dropped or traded. He is a solid B grade AFL footballer and will probably notch 250 games. Not a bad return for an early 2nd round pick...

What’s with the persecution complex?

Bruce G McAbee wrote: ↑Sun 17 Apr 2022 11:43am Has Jack Higgins become the new Stephen Milne for us?

Great comparison.

On Kayo Dermot talked of how he plays like a mini KPP with leading patterns and getting to drop of ball.

Joey chimed in with the Milne similarity.

Sainter_Dad wrote: ↑Sun 17 Apr 2022 9:38am Are you talking Sam Sturt?

or

Blacres??

Definitely not Acres

I believe we are right into a Freo forward who would play wing at St Kilda should he return home next season. Big talent but injury prone to date. Great left foot kick, very good over head and quick. Younger version of Mason Wood in size and style. Perhaps or perhaps not one of the ITK can confirm/ ...

VFL Jones 28 Bytel 27 and a goal Owens 26 Max Heath 28 ho, 16poss, 3 goals, 4 tackles Connolly 21 Some encouraging signs Allison 15 and a goal Kent 15 and goal Sharman 14 Adams 9 Joyce 7 GC had quite a few high draft picks and good players playing - so good win Yep, Hollands, Sharp & Bella coul...

Seb has been maligned on this forum for years and I don’t get it. There are guys who have been VFL standard who escaped bashing while multiple calls for Seb to be dropped or traded. He is a solid B grade AFL footballer and will probably notch 250 games. Not a bad return for an early 2nd round pick. ...

WellardSaint wrote: ↑Fri 15 Apr 2022 11:38pm

Yorkeys wrote: ↑Fri 15 Apr 2022 11:20pm Climate change
Russian investors
Coolangatta airport
Titans
Retirees
White shoes
Membrey

Far too many tall buildings, concrete jungle, which makes the GC much hotter

Fake tits
Fake lips
Tattoos
Bikers

And that’s just the females.……

SunnyErnie wrote: ↑Tue 12 Apr 2022 8:57pm I will be calling the club tomorrow and demanding that we take Legal Action against the AFL.

Hi Ernie, how was the call to the club this morning?
Can you provide details?
What was their response to your demand?

Two Hawk goals (both frees) in the first minute and two goals to Hawks (one from free) in last minute. Only six goals to 22 in the time in between. Incidentally I just watched the 15 minute mini package of the game on foxtel where they usually show all or most of the goals . They showed ALL of the ...

I will be calling the club tomorrow and demanding that we take Legal Action against the AFL. Let us know how that works out for ya champ :lol: :wink: :wink: Hopefully Ernie will offer his services to the club Pro Bono, I'm guessing he'd be a QC. Oh and Ernie, before you look it up I'm pretty sure P...

SunnyErnie wrote: ↑Tue 12 Apr 2022 8:57pm I will be calling the club tomorrow and demanding that we take Legal Action against the AFL.

Let us know how that works out for ya champ