I’ll let your mental capacity digest that But keep your criticisms of all St Kilda players, administration and Football Department coming 24/7 on this site We do understand that from your perspective St Kilda is a rubbish Club which would be better served by being under your exclusive control But wh...

The game is at Docklands, so a “fast surface”

Noting we have played Campbell there once this season which I would not have done

Takes one to know one, hey BM? Clark is all class as he is demonstrating in his managed minutes - and vital to St Kilda In regards the VFL, he left the field in his first game back early with a knee issue then cleared to play the next week on managed minutes Given his absence, this was why his retur...

No one lives with the benefit of hindsight.

You make decisions for the reasons you do and you move forward.

That is life.

OUT Caminiti (injured)

IN Phillipou (Recovered)

No one at VFL level today put their hand up.

The opportunity was there but it was not taken.

On the basis of the VFL game today, neither Heath or Keeler are options to replace Caminiti.

In fact, basically all players in the VFL side today failed to press the opportunity. button.

So maybe Phillipou (recovered) for Caminiti (injured) is the only change.

Hopefully Hill is fit.

From watching a very, very poor performance on TV, I would suggest that the players to be de-listed were on show in this game starting with Hall, Allison, Hayes, Bonner, Campbell, Cordy and Paton None of these players impacted today. Granted no players were impressive, showing AFL skills at VFL leve...

Yes, maybe some should listen to the Senior Coach. No 2 weeks are the same, hence the competition we see in 2024 where how do you pick winners? Simply, all sides prepare for the OPPOSITION. And all opposition (including St Kilda) respond, or attempt to respond. In terms of the opinions attributed to...

Here we go again!

NO player is going to win every contest they are in.

Witness Lockett and Riewoldt - for starters.

And I would add that St Kilda has just one class player with over 200 games experience being Bradley Hill.

Compare that to the sides being seen as contenders.

To this side you can add Windhager, Crouch, King, Henry and Phillipou. Plus who we are developing and who we recruit. If you look at games played by each player there are gaps starting with Sinclair missing Round 1, a narrow loss to Geelong at Geelong (along with a number of other narrow losses). Re...

Yes, on the advice of my GP I and the rest of our family have had 6 doses of the ever emerging vaccine I rely on professional advice from educated people in the medical field Not the uneducated advice of a right wing nut job One of the uplifting events of recent days is the response of the British p...

The one issue those who put that we require 3 years to be competitive overlook is the equation of those we will lose over that period versus who we Draft (noting that in the normal course you only have 1 first round selection in any year) We have Hill over 30 years of age then some core players in t...

Just a question How many offering opinion actually attend games? And how many offering opinion rely on TV coverage The reason I ask is that in my opinion TV coverage does not inform on all aspects of the game because it focusses on the ball You do not see the positioning including the defensive runs...

In regard Long, the former coaches' children had Long's number on their attire - having had Cyril's at Hawthorn IF Brett had dropped Long he was in for some pay back at home. Further, on a pre-season training block in the top end, Long set the cultural program for that training block. His decision t...

Bruce was useful at best - noting the contribution at WB (where he kicked 10 against a bottom side on one occasion but not much else)

I seem to recall WB put him back to defence where he started out

And all is now revealed - Vottex is Donald Trump!!!

In terms of constructing a List, name one Club which has not recruited players from other Clubs To put that absolute reliance should be on players drafted is not tenable Noting also that you get one chance a year to Draft a player at First Round status (in the normal course) From there second rounds...

I take exception to those presenting that we are in rebuild phase Simply, all Clubs seek to improve their List year on year That is the competition The likes of King, Clark, Owens, Windhager, Phillipou, Wanganeen- Milera, Wilson, Henry and even Caminiti and Byrnes would rightly take exception to reb...

I take exception to those presenting that we are in rebuild phase Simply, all Clubs seek to improve their List year on year That is the competition The likes of King, Clark, Owens, Windhager, Phillipou, Wanganeen- Milera, Wilson, Henry and even Caminiti and Byrnes would rightly take exception to reb...

I take exception to those presenting that we are in rebuild phase Simply, all Clubs seek to improve their List year on year That is the competition The likes of King, Clark, Owens, Windhager, Phillipou, Wanganeen- Milera, Wilson, Henry and even Caminiti and Byrnes would rightly take exception to reb...

The criminal justice system includes rehabilitation Because sentences of life being the remainder of the offenders life time are rare The upshot is, having done the time you resume in society - hence the focus on rehabilitation And in many instances there is no time in custody so sentences of good b...

Bonner has played every game apart from 1 due to injury With some luck, the draw coming from where we are now, some astute Drafting adding to our Round 1 side aka the likes of Wanganeen-Milera Phillipou and Wilson and improvement among our youngsters I would expect a pleasing result in 2025, replica...

Bonner has played every game apart from 1 due to injury With some luck, the draw coming from where we are now, some astute Drafting adding to our Round 1 side aka the likes of Wanganeen-Milera Phillipou and Wilson and improvement among our youngsters I would expect a pleasing result in 2025, replica...

Garcia who was the unused sub

So then who becomes the sub?

Given there are no injuries

I thought Bonner played well and positioned well

Byrnes also worked and played well

Someone is going to be unlucky given last week’s win

One swallow a spring is not made My opining is that King will add to our forward potency What we have had over recent weeks is a greater contribution from our mids where Clark impacts and now Jones and Phillipou are contributing so more options than we have had over the recent past Add to this Wanga...