Byrnes started very well.

Can't wait to hear Dimmas excuses.

Our only opportunity to add A grade talent is to either unearth talent that has struggled for opportunity at another club, Steele and Membry fit this bill, or through the draft. Both these strategies should remain central to our permanent culture at the club and only look at FAs when we have proven...

Our only opportunity to add A grade talent is to either unearth talent that has struggled for opportunity at another club, Steele and Membry fit this bill, or through the draft. Both these strategies should remain central to our permanent culture at the club and only look at FAs when we have proven...

A debut infront of friends and family next week could be the go?

Trade Philipou? Seriously. We wouldn't get 4th rounder based on his last half dozen games. Saints need to work out a strategy to move up the ladder. A basket case of inability to develop young players. Throw the kitchen sink at free agents. Is not going to work. Meanwhile.. Gresham staring with ess...

It's frustrating to see Byrnes back: he tries extremely hard, but just isn't AFL quality IMO. i'd have rather seen Paton selected in the starting 18 ahead of Byrnes and have Stocker or Garcia come onto the bench. Sharman made the best of his brief appearance last week, and has earned his spot. I st...

What this thread proves to me is that you can recruit players despite seemingly being in a worse onfield position.

Hopefully we're the ones grabbing the next Caldwell over the next two off seasons.

Hill
Ryder
Butler
Steele
Membrey
Crouch
Wood
Higgins
Howard
Henry (!!!!!!)
Jones


This narrative of no one will come to St kilda is getting tired. Yes you don't get them all- 17 other clubs are having a crack too.

As is the one about Ross. Plenty of star players rave about him.

Scollop wrote: ↑Fri 05 Jul 2024 11:56pm Big Clubs don't lose good players to small clubs

Yes. Best to give up and complain.

Surely we make plays for both of them. Out of contract. Not free agents so have to trade but being out of contract they would be cheaper than otherwise.

CURLY wrote: ↑Wed 03 Jul 2024 11:21am

The Fireman wrote: ↑Wed 03 Jul 2024 10:49am Heard that he injured his knee

Reported by jay clark herald sun

https://x.com/ClarkyHeraldSun/status/18 ... 4349560838

Yep suggest a few people STFU

My opinion on his efforts throughout the year remain.

Out: Caminiti (inj), Dow (inj) In: Howard, Garcia B: Wilkie, Howard, Webster HB: Sinclair, Battle, NWM C: Hill, Steele, Wood HF: Higgins, King, Garcia F: Butler, Marshall, Sharman Foll: Campbell, Windhager, Owens Int: Bonner, Clark, Schoenmaker, Garcia Sub: Wilson This is probably right. With the p...

Howard no longer on the injury list.

Comes straight back in.

B.M wrote: ↑Mon 01 Jul 2024 6:10pm What’s he ever done that was good?

Numbers??

GWS player on the fringe. Young talent.

If all you're after is sure things, that cost little you're going to continue to be disappointed BM.

I had read somewhere he was a free agent.

Got that wrong.

Regardless as an out of contract player- he is the next best thing.

Good read.

Confident we have the right duo in Bassat and Lyon in their respective posts.

Is this like last year when you named like 15 changes that were guaranteed to happen but was just your opinion?

Agree it looks like that is what is happening. Not sure it is 100% though

Think he's got to heavy. He also gets the second best lock down back each week. The downfall of Membrey hasn't helped his case that is for sure. I'd like to see us settle on our marking forwards for a 3 or 4 week block. i.e. choose three of King, Membrey, Hammer, Sharman, Marshall and Owens and bac...

Out Wilson, In Garcia Give Wilson a rest and reward the hard work Garcia has been putting in. Out Campbell, In Heath I've been a fan of Campbell but with the season now gone, it is worth having a look at Heath. Out King, In Stocker Battle, Wilkie, Webster Milera, Cammaniti, Bonner Marshall, Steele, ...

GWS player right on the fringe. Might be worth pursuing as a restricted free agent. 21 years old 20 games into his career. Sub affected statistically but often the 22nd, 23rd or 24th best player available at the giants this year. Bio (GWS player profile) A left-footer with silky skills, Ryan Angwin ...

I've done poos tougher than King

Waltzing St Kilda wrote: ↑Sun 30 Jun 2024 5:31pm That late hit, resulting in a Port free at crucial moment, was the last straw. Dumb, selfish player.

100% this.

desertsaint wrote: ↑Sun 30 Jun 2024 4:43pm

The Fireman wrote: ↑Sun 30 Jun 2024 4:42pm We had our chances … king must be dropped, keep Sharman in

tribunal might take that decision out of our hands.

Was a gutless, selfish act.

Drop him for the rest of the year.

Trade him for a packet of twisties.