Our "successful" period from 2004 until 20011 was due to hitting the draft hard for 4 years and then doing some trades. This rebuild we have butchered most of our draft picks yet we are acting as though we are a top 4 side and topping up. It's not going to work. You must build that core gr...

McCartin has to be de-listed for his own sake. One more knock and he could suffer brain damage. It's not worth the risk Patrick.

mr six o'clock wrote: ↑Sat 19 Oct 2019 10:22pm So he wants to come to st kilda so he and his good mate hanners can be breaking feet together .
Nice

That is why all my mates call St Kilda a Laughing Stock.

Hi Gurus, I was wondering if anyone knowledgeable can fill me in on the draft rules pertaining to academy players? Particularly interested in Biggy Nyuon. How do we sit given our low picks? Do we still have a chance? If he is bid on before pick 40 (roughly) and we want him we will have to use some ...

Face facts everyone, we offered more money than any other team could to Hill. $900k per year is ridiculous money. Now that our Salary cap has been squeezed to the max, lets see how many players "nominate" us next year. PS. How do you think the rest of the players are going to feel when th...

Now Brian Cook is in the media today claiming that Geelong don't want to part with one of their picks in the 20's or 30's. So if I was St Kilda, I'd stand firm and tell Geelong to shove it. If Jack wants to play footy with them in 2020 then they need to stump up or Jack can either sit out a year or...

Face facts everyone, we offered more money than any other team could to Hill. $900k per year is ridiculous money. Now that our Salary cap has been squeezed to the max, lets see how many players "nominate" us next year. PS. How do you think the rest of the players are going to feel when thi...

Now Brian Cook is in the media today claiming that Geelong don't want to part with one of their picks in the 20's or 30's. So if I was St Kilda, I'd stand firm and tell Geelong to shove it. If Jack wants to play footy with them in 2020 then they need to stump up or Jack can either sit out a year or...

I'm such a long time reader and decided to join in all the excitement as I think we are going to see a massive improvement in 2020 . Very exciting times. Welcome friend. Life is short. Enjoy yourself. What do you base this on minneapolis? Don't get me wrong, I hope you're right but I don't see it t...

I'm such a long time reader and decided to join in all the excitement as I think we are going to see a massive improvement in 2020 . Very exciting times. Welcome friend. Life is short. Enjoy yourself. What do you base this on minneapolis? Don't get me wrong, I hope you're right but I don't see it t...

They did do that?! A bid came in the first round for both players, and they matched. So now you’ve sort of got your head around it, let’s look at the original argument. Moore and Heeney were in a group of players who (with hindsight) could/should have gone as the number 1 selection as they have tur...

ace wrote: ↑Tue 08 Oct 2019 1:08am

Nick_BlueNRG wrote: ↑Mon 07 Oct 2019 6:28pm

SaintPav wrote: ↑Mon 07 Oct 2019 4:21pm

Nick_BlueNRG wrote: ↑Mon 07 Oct 2019 4:01pm It's happening this year. We now have a Full House.

BS.

Two Kings and 3 Jacks is a full house. Why BS SaintPav? It happening!! Lock it in!!

Our embrace of gay week implies we have plenty of queens as well .............. but there will only be one Ace.

stupid post

Well trade week is upon us. What is your vision for 2020? Here is mine! My Dream Trades would be: Josh Bruce and pick 57 for pick 13 from Western Bulldogs. 13 is just too much for Bruce but they need him big time. Throwing in pick 57 makes it more attractive and justifiable for them. They will pick...

SaintPav wrote: ↑Mon 07 Oct 2019 4:21pm

Nick_BlueNRG wrote: ↑Mon 07 Oct 2019 4:01pm It's happening this year. We now have a Full House.

BS.

Two Kings and 3 Jacks is a full house. Why BS SaintPav? It happening!! Lock it in!!

It's happening this year. We now have a Full House.

They did do that?! A bid came in the first round for both players, and they matched. So now you’ve sort of got your head around it, let’s look at the original argument. Moore and Heeney were in a group of players who (with hindsight) could/should have gone as the number 1 selection as they have tur...

I am not a doctor but I really believe Roberton and McCartin should retire for their own good (as well as the clubs). It is too risky for either of them to attempt to come back. One would be risking having a heart attack on the field and the other would be risking permanent brain damage (or heaven f...

I really hope it is not Ratten. Nothing against the guy but he is just an extension of Richo. After Richo departed there was a spike in our performance but the last 2 weeks showed it was still the same ol same ol. The players/club need a new voice to be able to go forward and more importantly to be...

We have alienated our best player. Banger will never forgive us this time.

I truly hope and pray Robert Harvey is announced as St.kilda's new senior coach. I see him as being St.kilda's Jock McHale for want of a better analogy. Robert Harvey is more thorough in preparation than anyone in the known universe bar none. With the right assistants around him and Lenny Hayes for...

I really hope it is not Ratten. Nothing against the guy but he is just an extension of Richo. After Richo departed there was a spike in our performance but the last 2 weeks showed it was still the same ol same ol. The players/club need a new voice to be able to go forward and more importantly to be ...

bassoon thats Nexus Nick ignore him everyone else does i’ve just read your ‘55 thread ... it’s all respect from the other punters nexus has always been a nob communicator ... find some compassion for him and his need to troll ‘n it’s not really cricket branding us (ss) by nexus’s work he’s still ra...

Honestly. I have a thick hide, I joined Saintsational to have an opinion, not to be abused against. It's happened too many times. Happy to have a discussion, not to be called stupid, troll, and any other derogatory name. I'll always bleed red white and black - just not with you mob. Big Footy here ...

I want B King at the club badly, but we would be so royally bent over if we attempt to pick him up before his contract is out, I just can't see it happening. We've got nothing that would satisfy them regardless. I'd rather we wait 'til the getting's good. Pick 5 and Carlisle for Bing. I would be ve...

Major sideways trading if we end up with him and trade out Carlisle, unless we get Keath dirt cheap and Carlisle nets us significant value. Would rather stick with a proven gun than a player who just put together his first solid season at 27 Why not both? My preference is..... Carlisle and pick 5 >...