Joffa Burns wrote: ↑Mon 24 Feb 2020 2:02pm

Nick_BlueNRG wrote: ↑Sun 23 Feb 2020 9:06pm
Which team would take Dunstan and Carlisle for pick 15?

The team that finishes 4th in 2020 ???

Correct

He was ok but I would not be surprised if he was traded next year. Especially if Bytel comes on as people have been saying. At the end of this year, and especially if Bytel comes on and also Austin hits top form, I can see both Dunstan and Carlisle being traded. If that was the case and we ended up...

He was ok but I would not be surprised if he was traded next year. Especially if Bytel comes on as people have been saying. At the end of this year, and especially if Bytel comes on and also Austin hits top form, I can see both Dunstan and Carlisle being traded. If that was the case and we ended up ...

If every one is fit and in form my defence would be as follows..... 3 talls Carlisle, Howard and Austin 3 Mediums Savage, Clark and Long Carlisle is the Interceptor and Howard and Austin are the elite Spoilers. Savage is the booming kick and Clark and Long are run and carry play makers. Love it. Cla...

Firstly on the sponsorship deals; the club sells itself as the vehicle for exposure, but what if you aren't getting much exposure due to ladder postion, well you do something similar to how player contracts are front or rear end loaded. You sell exposure based on short term deals that speculates yo...

The AFL have more power than the government, they are one of most successful and profitable businesses in the country. Heaps of cash to splash. We won't overcome their bias. The OS experiment projects are play things for some very small interest groups. You'd also be surprised how much the governme...

The AFL have more power than the government, they are one of most successful and profitable businesses in the country. Heaps of cash to splash. We won't overcome their bias. The OS experiment projects are play things for some very small interest groups. You'd also be surprised how much the governme...

.......and that was after a court case reversed the result. I hope the girls are not trying to beat this record!!!!

No offence intended.....this is just tongue in cheek and just for the fun of it.

Really surprised Marshall missed out. I am not - I would hazard a guess that he was made "Un-available". I would be thinking that of all the positions that we could least afford to lose a player combined with the higher risk of the position (you can't really go half pace in the ruck) - Ma...

I don't agree with this decision. I just hope Geary plays well and fully deserves his spot in the side. If his form is down and not deserving of a spot (which I suspect is more than a 50 50 chance), then the s*** will hit the fan. My original thoughts were that Geary should play only if we were hit ...

You all make good points. But as I said, we have the power to overcome the AFL's bias. China and New Zealand, if done properly, will make us one of the biggest clubs in the AFL. This will ensure that we are never in debt again and also ensure our long term survival in the AFL.

This is why we MUST continue to play one game in China each year. Also, when Western Springs in Auckland is ready, 2 games every year in NZ. Do both of the above and we will never be in debt again.

I don't agree with this decision. This was the perfect time to start fresh with a new captain. Now Geary will have to play every week regardless of form and in my opinion there are a lot of medium defenders that have gone past him. I won't name them all because we all know who they are. I can see la...

I think it is Patrikios

Just to clarify, I’m not advocating that Geary should not get a game. I am saying that he should not be captain anymore. I believe Seb Ross should be captain. If we have injuries and Geary’s form is good enough, then he plays. Your thread title state he should not be captain because he is not in ou...

I must admit, I did not see the intraclub game. I am only going by the articles on the game and the posts on here and Bigfooty. There is no way that Geary should be captain because he will not be in the starting 22. From what I can tell there is a plethora of players (small to medium defenders), th...

Seb wouldn't get a game in most midfields as an attacking mid. As a defensive mid however, he'd play in most. He's an A-Grade defensive mid. He's a C-B offensive mid though. Can't kick. You are completely off the mark Barry. His kicking may not be elite but to say he can’t kick is ludicrous at best...

Just to clarify, I’m not advocating that Geary should not get a game. I am saying that he should not be captain anymore. I believe Seb Ross should be captain. If we have injuries and Geary’s form is good enough, then he plays.

I must admit, I did not see the intraclub game. I am only going by the articles on the game and the posts on here and Bigfooty. There is no way that Geary should be captain because he will not be in the starting 22. From what I can tell there is a plethora of players (small to medium defenders), th...

I must admit, I did not see the intraclub game. I am only going by the articles on the game and the posts on here and Bigfooty. There is no way that Geary should be captain because he will not be in the starting 22. From what I can tell there is a plethora of players (small to medium defenders), th...

I must admit, I did not see the intraclub game. I am only going by the articles on the game and the posts on here and Bigfooty. There is no way that Geary should be captain because he will not be in the starting 22. From what I can tell there is a plethora of players (small to medium defenders), tha...

kosifantutti wrote: ↑Wed 12 Feb 2020 9:56am That’s what Fitzroy used to say, until they didn’t.

Kosi, Kosi, Kosi, that is something that the old Nick would say. Shame, shame, shame on you.

Thanks Saynta, All is looking godd at the moment. A few niggling injuries to others is probably to be expected. Geary will need to be at the top of his game. Geary should be playing for Sandringham and only come in if / when injuries strike. That's just rubbish. As for you Saynta, if that is all yo...

Thanks Saynta, All is looking godd at the moment. A few niggling injuries to others is probably to be expected. Geary will need to be at the top of his game. Geary should be playing for Sandringham and only come in if / when injuries strike. That's just rubbish. Why has he not been booted off this ...