Agreed. We were smashed through the middle anyway, giving them a spare made it worse, nigh on impossible to win the footy between the arcs.

It’s not paying out this season that’s the concern, it’s paying 600k for next season while paying a new coach 1M at the same time. That would be a poor business decision. Especially when there’s little to be gained for sacking him right now, as opposed to R18 when he will be sacked.

Pity we can’t sack the list. We have sacked the moron who devised our pathetic strategy to put us in this situation We have sacked the guy that picked the players in those drafts We have got rid of a few assistants and dev coaches We are about to sack the coach who’s been there during this s***show ...

Think Milney went alright in 2004 kicked a lazy 46

At that point of his career 73 games 139 goals

That 2gpg which is elite for a small forward

The plus two was created by AR folding back a wingman (Ross) after the centre bounce following the injury to Battle. This was probably to support an undersized and inexperienced defense. And try to stop the bleeding. Did not work. Wrong player. The spare wingman for North sat off every mid stoppage ...

Maybe we should throw the 30 million down the toilet that was spent to build Moorabbin And build a training base in our spiritual heartland - StK at the junction. We could share with CV because our relationship with cricket was so good last time. Surely if we were training at StK our fortunes would ...

Don’t want him to play. Stand in the way of development, and he is like Armo, Father Time has caught up with him. There’s a reason why he’s played twos this season. He’ll be 34 next year.

Would love him in an off field role. Either development or forwards coach.

BTW
The need to exit Lade

Big call to say a footballer is not putting in? I’d argue that every player on the field was having a go, Zeiball and Cunnington are contested ball beasts, Simpkin is a first rounder and is very skilled. Some days you try hard, run hard and chase hard, but the ball just doesn’t fall your way or your...

What I’m saying is, the move to Moorabbin, whilst important in some ways will make little on field impact. They still train on grass (which at Moorabbin is pretty ordinary) the still have a set of goals at either end and a fence around the ground, the footies are the same shape, the weights room has...

Jy Simpkin is a very talented player.

Moorabbin move has been such a game changer, we have gone from bad to worse.

Really, we are 12 million in debt, and we are funding a stand alone team and building another structure at Moorabbin?! Can you answer me this about having a stand alone team (which we basically have) If we had a stand alone team this weekend, how would they have gone... more so who the hell would ha...

Tough player, has good attributes as a defender, but is injury prone and can turn the ball over with poor decisions or skill errors

Right deal, I’d trade him

He’d be one on 10 I would trade for the right price

Oh, and if you have ever known Lenny Hayes, he is the furtherest thing from intimidating.

Softly spoken, calm and intelligent. One of the most modest persons I have met.

Scary, brutal beast of a player, a true gentleman off the ground

Gold Coast will get 1 & 2

Take it to the bank! The AFL will help this basket case because they are an embarrassment.

Only club in the AFL in a worst situation than StK

Just select the best coach Not who we think is the best coach (none of us have a clue about how good or bad they are) Doesn’t matter whether they are former players or not, or whether they were entertaining on the front bar, whether they are demonstrative (a negative character trait in a coach) Coac...

Wouldn’t mind being as successful as Old Xavs

Sandy team yesterday was horrible

18yo Jack Mayo was the only tall forward for the most part, and top up player Dave Secull

Not sure what has happened to Gilbert, but they needed him yesterday, and probably Nathan Wright to make an impact

But hang on Saintpav, that doesn’t help our agenda so it can’t be true.

AR just sits back and does nothing, that’s more like it,

On Seb, he found himself playing in the back half yesterday and had no idea, he was not the right person for that role.

Explain how one would empower the culture? And how the president sets the cultural standard? What does AB do set a high performance standard amongst a playing group. I’d say AR empowers his line coaches and development coaches and leadership group And Jarryn Geary + leaders set playing/training stan...

Rowan Marshall

Oh yeah, he’s doing ok, Richo mustn’t be telling him to play crap like he obviously does with others

If we had a new coach this week against Geelong

Would we win?

Who did play second ruck?

Not sure how that has any impact, having a run around in the middle for 5 minutes is not too difficult

Not sure there will be any effect, maybe close to the end of the season a people are playing for careers and contracts?

Not sure a new coach this year will have a magic wand

What should he say?

I’d like to know if anyone actually thought we’d play finals?

We won 4 games last year, what exactly was going to see us win another 8/9 games this year?