Cause Josh Battle Says So

Thought the work of Dunny, Steele and Marshall helped set us up early. Gresh was brilliant all day and gave us the spark when Carlton had the early lead. Loved the effort from our forward line and their tackling was very good. Kent was busy, Ben Long and Matt Parker provide a certain hardness that i...

Steele
Gresh
Dunny
Marshall
Membrey

We are still in the finals race We're tracking well. Sensational win and great play today. Carlton came at us hard. We were nearly overwhelmed by the wealth of high draft picks against us. Well coached too I personally think 2021 is the year that we will bring home silverware, but if we recruit wel...

You can still stay true to your values can't you Gaz?

They don't need to be mutually exclusive for someone to maintain integrity imo.

Richo is done as a coach - any sort of coach in the AFL. Full stop!!

I'd also strongly advise his manager to not bother trying to get him a job in the media

The best coach is Clarkson and it’s not even close.. what game have you all been watching. Clarkson Buckley Hardwick Chris Scott Other coaches Brad Scott, Bolton, Leon Cameron, Richo I would put the two qld coaches well well well above richo But I might be biased I think mightysainters has put Cho ...

I don't think that any St Kilda supporter would ever criticise Roo and Lenny and the efforts of the players (and I hope most don't because when you wear the jumper and bleed for the club, most people know that players are doing their best). I don't think people should be focussing on the PLAYERS the...

While what you have said about Lyon is correct that was 7 years ago he left. Richo has been here for 5 seasons, and when he started had the likes of Riewoldt, Montagna, Armitage , Milne?, Surely by now what you talk about could also have happened You forgot about Dempster, Sam Fisher, Stuv, Schneid...

Tackle count at half time

Norther Blues: 37
Sandringham: 20

It's been interesting. Brad's stocks would have fallen sharply had he been sacked or not had his contract renewed however to exit in the manner he has cast's an interesting new landscape for coach AND club. Agree Just saw the press conference. Brad spent time talking about the hard times when he wa...

Lots of good questions older saint Yes it is baffling Ghost Like. Perhaps one of the key ingredients to success is to assess each player and work out whether they are part of the future and whether they fit into the type of team you want to build. It's such a complex caper when you come in to a new ...

I rate Brett Ratten and always have. I rate him even more after he served time under Clarko. I'd rather Brett. I don't rate Brad Scott, although I agree that he is miles ahead of Richo. I think there'd be people at the club who were probably negative on Brad many years ago and now all of a sudden po...

Yes definitely sweetie, and Josh Battle Says So

I don't think any player has been dropped. Ben Paton may be carrying an injury or have some bruising and niggles so he's being managed. It's not like ALL our list is injured. There are players in the magoos who are playing decent footy and they are just not being given the same opportunities as some...

Here's a couple of quotes to choose from if you'd like to add them as your signature on the forum. Many thanks to the authors for their passionate contributions, which this frustrated supporter (moi) fully supports: The mistake I have made in getting frustrated/angry is to assume the club's primary ...

Getting nostalgic Kingy?

HighettMan wrote: ↑Fri 24 May 2019 11:16pm I already think our next coach has compromised selection integrity and should be sacked for gifting games.

I think you're being too harsh. Everyone makes mistakes early in their new role. I'd give him at least 5 and half years to get it right

Even if Dan gets on the park and plays a couple for Sandringham and then a couple for the seniors, he is highly likely to break down again...and that means he is a higher chance (at his age and with his recent history) of suffering more soft tissue injuries than our other players

Let's not let the facts get in the way of the apologist spin If Simon and Matt didn't hatch the plot to get Dan across to the Saints Hickey would still be lining up for us most weeks And...interesting that you mention that "Pierce" and Marshall were to be given a go. Yes!! And the selectio...

Anyone know how he's traveling? Is he training? Would love to see him back out there. Away from the club at the moment. Doing a bit of work on his own. He’s ok. Doubt if you’ll see him this year. He loves the club and the players. I also love the club and the players. I will support the players and...

Seems like people saying crap like he doesn't like Richo or is sick of the club are pretty far off the mark. Maybe it's time they shut up for a change. Unhelpful and quite frankly moronic responses. Here, here, time to stop stipulating and be more supportive of ALL! I've had my say on Jack in the p...

So now we are advised by a “Name” on this site that St Kilda have Salary Cap pressures therefore needed to retain a “player” on the basic wage in preference to a player on a higher wage Hmmm And in regards the other commentary, I could afford to retire 25 years ago - as a result of my achievements ...

Speaking of very very safe. Can't see Richo being creative or doing anything that might confuse the opposition but can you imagine if we played with those blokes in the middle aganst Carlton? It'd do wonders for their confidence and you may as well try these things against the bottom team. I know it...

That would make too much sense. Paton has been playing in defense. He goes out and a forward comes in...???

White (or maybe his mum) has obviously upset the coach in some way

viewtopic.php?f=1&t=96101&p=1750764&hil ... r#p1750764