I dont agree with the comments from Dermie and Lynch about Max King. Basically saying he needs more time before coming into senior footy. And listening to the game they did say some good things about Ben King, and he has 5 games. I think Max King should be playing to gain confidence and learn the g...

Was thst really stupid for Membrey to not chip it 15m to Billings, instead of taking that shot?

Would have taken another 30 seconds off the clock. Game over.

Ghost Like wrote: ↑Sat 15 Jun 2019 4:47pm Hind's disposal has been excellent today, he's not had it much but 3 entries into our F50 have been 3 of the best for the year.

Don't worry, we'll coach that out of him.

He's a far, far better defender than forward though.

Been digging around to see how long people have been bagging the 'bomb it in' thing, and found this thread! Reading this, not a single thing has changed in 2 years from the coaches box! According to the OP, we averaged 98 Points For when we beat GWS over 2 years ago - then once the 'bomb it in' yhin...

magnifisaint wrote: ↑Sat 15 Jun 2019 3:55pm There is no system going forward. Who is responsible?

Thre hasn't been for 5 years.

In Cho's first year, the system was 'kick it to Roo'.

Good to see the 'bomb it to the top of square' idiocy is alive and well.

There’s nothing in this. Poster is a well known troll. But, if we were to lose by 80+ points, then all bets are off. What a pathetic statement! If you believe I’m a troll then either prove it or shut up. If you do neither then I will be reporting you to the Mods. If you want more credibility tell u...

Yeah, let's trade Carlisle for a kid that we hope might be as good as Carlisle in about 5 years time.

You trade FOR guys like Carlisle. We've got one. Why in the f*** would you trade him out??


f***** hell.



By the way, cool troll List Manager. You must be getting your jollies big time lately.

Ian Drake George Huggins Allan Jeans Alan Killigrew Barry Breen Trevor Barker Nick Riewoldt I loved Thommo as coach but massive error of judgement to take a loan from Butterrs. Why? Sounds like he did pretty well out of it. Well yes GT did. But the bad blood caused by GT not wanting to repay it cau...

Couldn’t agree more. But it’s not just a matter of kicking straighter. It’s the whole process, including personnel in front of the ball. We’re continually kicking into a crowded forward line and many of our shots are scrambled and made under extreme pressure. Exactly!!! It's not a lack of ability, ...

Has anyone who posts on this forum ever said it made sense at the time? Although it was an unmitigated f*** up, to be fair, I at least understand why they did it. Stability. That's something we have not had, ever. And it's something that was clearly the flavour of the month at the time. There had b...

We have plenty to sell to potential FA's and trade targets IMO. Personally, I would love to train and work out of RSEA Park and live in a nearby Bayside suburb in Melbourne on a footy players wage. Lots of good assistants and development coaches to work under. Good bunch of blokes in the playing gr...

HighettMan wrote: ↑Tue 11 Jun 2019 10:03pm
In footy parlance I pulled your pants down with footy argument today.

Hahaha.

That explains why you rate Richo so highly.

What you posted is akin to saying "if you park 99% of the rubbish I posted today, my performance was strong."

HighettMan wrote: ↑Tue 11 Jun 2019 3:36pm

Select the same players for the game this week and tell me how much Ross would extract from them.

Select the same players for the game in 6 years, and I'd bet my life he'd extract more from them than Cho has in 6.

Again .. We all know it's a result driven industry. So it's a results driven industry, but you're crying and spamming the forum because people dare to want a coach sacked that has been unable to get any results for 6 years?? Just as you'd judge the coach on w/l, not on "trying to win", an...

happy feet wrote: ↑Sun 09 Jun 2019 10:43pm Ian Drake
George Huggins
Allan Jeans
Alan Killigrew
Barry Breen
Trevor Barker
Nick Riewoldt

I loved Thommo as coach but massive error of judgement to take a loan from Butterrs.

Why?

Sounds like he did pretty well out of it.

Furphy wrote: ↑Sun 09 Jun 2019 6:43pm

tedtheodorelogan2018 wrote: ↑Sun 09 Jun 2019 4:07pm Slug Jordan ?

We'd need a 'Ouija board' for that, he died in 2012. But, hey, worth a try...

InB4 'Still better than Cho'.

Samoht raises some excellent points in relation to recruiting. Which points are excellent? It's complete drivel. "Great players make you a better team"? No s***!! Players leave their club for the following reasons: Success Big games and big crowds For a coach Money To go home Under Richo,...

If you reckon coaching doesn't make a difference, then you haven't played footy. Over the years I've seen many clubs in various comps change coach and started winning more games with the same list. Sure any A grade player is desirable, but it's a team sport, not an individual sport- and top teams w...

If you reckon coaching doesn't make a difference, then you haven't played footy. Over the years I've seen many clubs in various comps change coach and started winning more games with the same list. Sure any A grade player is desirable, but it's a team sport, not an individual sport- and top teams w...

This is exactly the kind of posts ruining this forum and stops people from posting. Could have just said I disagree with what your saying but turns it into personal insults. Why? This is such an immature thing to do. Totally unnecessary. Grow up!! This is the stuff that moderators need to ban folks...

I notice there’s been some posts on Lyon and comparisons made with him. Lyon was a 19-0 coach and a 0-10 coach, depending on the strength of the list. Freo’s recruiting has turned their fortunes around recently with the addition of ... Hill, Hogan, Matera etc.. It really is all about recruiting .. ...

Saintmatt wrote: ↑Sun 09 Jun 2019 7:40am Get on your bike and do us all a favour you boring cliche ridden bell-end.

Extra points for 'bell end'.

Viz?

Our coach - even with the help of his able assistants - can't just wave a magic wand and turn our C graders into stars with elite skills, and/or develop game plans so superior to those of the opposition coaches that would overcome our list deficiencies. Carlton and North say hi. That made me laugh ...