If Windhager’s was “ Most clear-cut 50 you will ever see.”

Where does this sit on the Windhager scale?

3 minutes to go. 1 point down

He’s looked at two totally separate incidents and given his opinion. I’m not sure what you’re looking for here. The Windhager one I thought was 50/50 and if you think that wasn’t a free to Marshall, you need to learn the rules.

Explain your point and I’ll let you know if I missed it.

Just imagine, one week complaining that Windy standing 5m over the mark is not a 50 and should be a warning, then the next week saying a player getting up off the ground handing the ball to a teammate is a 100% legit free and goal and nothing to see here 😂 Absolute clown show! 🤡 No doubt you have n...

What about the soft free to Marshall for the goal, that gets ignored 99 times out of 100. Imagine the crack pots Curly and Saynta bleating about the Marshall free if it went the other way? The reason that free never gets paid is because almost nobody is stupid enough to do that. People claiming it ...

Wilkie
Battle
Wood
Sinclair
Marshall

Oh my God! The Swans will be under the pump next week. Should we bother turning up?

It appears RTB & Co have gone real cold on Pou, choosing to name Byrnes in the squad ahead of him. [/size] Byrnes is an emergency. On the back of a 5 possession game, WTAF??? Maybe I was too subtle with my last post. Ryan Byrnes had 25 disposals in his last game for Sandy. Not 5 Not 10 Not 15 N...

In NWM, Webster, Sharman
Out Cordy, Jones, Campbell

I'm a huge RTB fanboy...but I do believe he's prone to taking the piss...Byrnes? To quote every mafia gangster ever born...Getdafůkouttahere Byrnes hasn't got much of the ball for the Zebs. Last round he got about 5 touches. Is he insurance? Are one or two others a bit 50/50? #tellhimhesdreamin Whe...

Once Walsh's knee hit the ground and provided a pivot point with Dangerfield driving him down and forward his head was going to hit the ground. I don't know what Walsh could have done.

It has to be in line with where the infringement occurs and the centre of the goal. Which means 90 degrees. So I'm not sure why people are saying the umpires got the angle wrong. There were a few weeks at the start of 2009 where nobody knew about the exception for being under pressure and the footy ...

Doesn’t that signal indicate the siren has gone? But kicks can be taken after the siren.

There’s a few examples here:



Collingwood - Elliott
Gold Coast - Anderson?
West Coast - McGovern

The AFL and therefore umpires want close games. I do not understand trying to manufacture results - but to watch Jeremy Cameron have a shot at goal after the half time siren, the umpire call play on and the kick count is beyond me. The Umpire clearly calls play on - the kick has not happened - no c...

Did anyone see this?

How did it compare to the Butler one and the Brisbane one that wasn't deemed worthy of a report?

Yes, but 2 players running 10m over the mark is not as clear cut a 50 as Windhager standing in the wrong spot?

Or did I misinterpret "Most clear-cut 50 you will ever see."?

Clear and blatant 50 and correctly paid, the time of the game should be irrelevant. How many different umpiring threads to you need to start? No it wasnt he didnt enter the protected area he was already in it and stepped back to where he thought the mark was. No interruption in play no warning no c...

Windhager's problem wasn't that he came through the area. It was because he was about 3m in front of where the ball was marked and only took half a step back which made it pretty obvious he was over the mark. I don't think that is paid every time without a warning but he gave the umpire the option ...

Windhager's problem wasn't that he came through the area. It was because he was about 3m in front of where the ball was marked and only took half a step back which made it pretty obvious he was over the mark. I don't think that is paid every time without a warning but he gave the umpire the option o...

Saynta didn't provide a link or the votes. This was a community service. And maybe I can preempt those tedious argument about who that idiot Fagan voted for.

Lyon
5 Jack Higgins (STK)

Fagan
9 Joe Daniher (BL)
7 Hugh McCluggage (BL)
5 Dayne Zorko (BL)
4 Jarrod Berry (BL)

North Melbourne “Hold my beer”

Battle for tripping? I can’t remember that.

CURLY wrote: ↑Sat 15 Jun 2024 12:03am

The_Dud wrote: ↑Fri 14 Jun 2024 11:25pm Wasn’t in the contest and chose to stand 5m over the mark

Why wasn’t it 50 when the Lions player gave the ball to Butler even though the free kick wasn’t his.

Butler was playing for that BUT he only gave it to Butler after the umpire told him 3 times to “give it up now”

Marshall
Higgins
Sinclair
Clark
Schoenmaker