His last game was good and he is the type of guy who gives 100% if he is not AFL standard 2019 I’m not sure who is There are over 300 players I could name who are more 'AFL standard' than Gilbert. He is currently ranked 313th in the AFL. http://www.afl.com.au/stats/player-ratings/overall-standings#...

CURLY wrote: ↑Sun 30 Sep 2018 8:53pm Sheed misses that goal and the games of those 4 would be heavily criticised.

If if if if.

If you had a brain you might have a job.

<edited by mods>

Always if if if if with you curly.

<poster already banned>

All missing the point DeGoey gets drafted by StKilda has the off field issues he has had he’d have been sacked. The outside pressure from media and the AFL would have made it impossible for us to keep him. Another piece of curly " what if" hypothetical speculation not connected to reality...

If it begins now what was the last 5 years exactly?
Kindergarten?

Also, Phillips averaged about 20 touches in his first season of senior football......not bad, eh? Dunstan and sinclair are still struggling to average 20 a game. He only played 7 games. Shame the Cho kept dropping him back to VFL. Good work Cho! A bit of 'tough love'. What a developer of talent! Go...

No s*** sherlock. Of course we are small fry. We are the most irrelevant club in the comp besides the Suns. The AFL doesnt give a s*** about us. Has been like this for 100 years. We are minnows. Which is why we need to be making smarter decisions than everyone else and not sitting around being trend...

I'm not saying Richo is a good coach. What I'm saying is we really, really need to improve our recruiting. Hannebury, Lycett, Menzel ,,,, why are we continuing to look at list cloggers?? You have been saying richo is a good coach over and over and over again. You refuse to acknowledge how bad he is...

not a good look by Gaff - angry at himself rather than happy for the team. But who are we to judge. Maxy was similarly angry during the 09 gf. his omission set off alarm bells in my head a bit like the banner yesterday. realised lyon valued fitness over passion, meanwhile geelong pumped an unfit ch...

Its actually easier for a first year player to perform better in a top 8 side, especially a top 4 and GF side. He already has the better players, mature and harder bodies around him that can play 120 mins of football. Clark, Coffield and Claravino will end up having better careers in the end compar...

Gaff is coping it in the media. Very selfish. Glad he’s not coming to us. Yes. We want all our boys to have the personality of the Dalai Lama. Playing ability is secondary to a superficial glancing judgment of player's perceived personality. I have it on good authority from someone over in the West...

His last game was good and he is the type of guy who gives 100% if he is not AFL standard 2019 I’m not sure who is There are over 300 players I could name who are more 'AFL standard' than Gilbert. He is currently ranked 313th in the AFL. http://www.afl.com.au/stats/player-ratings/overall-standings#...

Venables had 3 touches, Ryan shirked some critical contests and Rioli was a bit part player. If Gaff and Shepherd were available, two of those three would not have played, most likely. Nothing wrong with Clark's season, and Coffield will be a star. How can you go backwards in your first season? As ...

Also, Phillips averaged about 20 touches in his first season of senior football......not bad, eh? Dunstan and sinclair are still struggling to average 20 a game. He only played 7 games. Shame the Cho kept dropping him back to VFL. Good work Cho! A bit of 'tough love'. What a developer of talent! Go...

Then there is Allen and Brander coming up....

axcellence wrote: ↑Sun 30 Sep 2018 7:45am Maybe other clubs are talking to him eg Gold Coast,so he's got dfa interest from them?

Southport will be keen as mustard.

The Cho is coaching in 2019 for one reason only.

So Matt Finnnis can save face.

They will be hoping like hell for a miracle and chasing Longmire, Clarkson or a Scott brother.

If not it will be from Caracella, Burns, Longmuir, Mitchell etc

I'm not saying Richo is a good coach. What I'm saying is we really, really need to improve our recruiting. Hannebury, Lycett, Menzel ,,,, why are we continuing to look at list cloggers?? You have been saying richo is a good coach over and over and over again. You refuse to acknowledge how bad he is...

Irrelevant. We didn't. He wouldn't be the player he is now as he wouldn't have the support if with us. Collingwoods list is better than hours and by a long way. Their forward set up is better than ours. And their midfield is one of the best in the league with pendelbury, Adams, treloar and the best...

Well done Eagles. Bad luck Collingwood. Now to 2019. Basset in. Lade and Ratten in. A couple more assistants on the way. Hannerbrey in. Kent in. Shiel in (maybe). More to come. New IT stats recruitment guru in (guy from Hawthorn - forgot his name). All bodes well for a better 2019. Looking forward ...

I'm not saying Richo is a good coach. What I'm saying is we really, really need to improve our recruiting. Hannebury, Lycett, Menzel ,,,, why are we continuing to look at list cloggers?? You have been saying richo is a good coach over and over and over again. You refuse to acknowledge how bad he is...

Get Mitchell now as the senior coach. It'll be a big signing all the way. Mitchell was critical for Eagles winning. Has some merit. Richo is a mindless copycat who has been trying to copy the Bulldogs and Tigers 'pressure game'. Not very well. Eagles stuck to their guns and played the Hawks style k...

I'm not saying Richo is a good coach. What I'm saying is we really, really need to improve our recruiting. Hannebury, Lycett, Menzel ,,,, why are we continuing to look at list cloggers?? You have been saying richo is a good coach over and over and over again. You refuse to acknowledge how bad he is.

desertsaint wrote: ↑Sat 29 Sep 2018 7:40pm all these silly sporting teams all over the world paying senior coaches so much money.

According to some posters above coaches have no impact.
We might as well save money and install a vacuum cleaner as coach.

Steele Membrey and Roberton we got at 20 or 21. Of course they are better at 22,23,25. Plus it's a team game. Simpson is batting at 64% wins after 5 seasons. He has one flag and one runner up. He is a good coach. That's how it works. That's how we judge. Actual performance. Not imaginary hypothetica...

CURLY wrote: ↑Sat 29 Sep 2018 4:47pm Umpires have given Collingwood the lead they are so biased.

Ffs